New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Let's talk drawboring pegs ..

Posts

Let's talk drawboring pegs ..

#1

Let's talk drawboring pegs ..

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I posted this topic on WoodNet in response to a question raised there, then thought it could be the basis of a great discussion here as well.

The basic issue comes down to the shape of the drawbore peg - should it be round and straight, as in a dowel (the method demonstrated by Chris Schwarz in his DVD, as well as the method depicted on my website) - or should the peg be whittled into a taper (the method reported by Peter Follansbee and a very experienced furniture restorer and cabinetmaker on the Australian Ubeaut forum) to wedge the mortice and tenon even more securely.

It is worth reading the info at the links I provided even if you are familiar with this area. Are we just dealing with "new" and an "old" school methodology? Or, does the "old" school deal with an issue of joinery that the "new" school fails to take into account?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Links:

Derek Cohen (and Chris Schwarz) ... http://www.inthewoodshop.com/Furniture/Drawboring.html

Peter Follansbee ... https://pfollansbee.wordpress.com/tag/drawboring/

Ubeaut forum ... http://www.woodworkforums.com/f152/new-dowel-plate-131521/index2.html#post1279046

Re: Let's talk drawboring pegs ..

#2

Moses Yoder

Re: Let's talk drawboring pegs ..

Moses Yoder

Round or square is kind of a design choice. It depends on the look you are going for. I like square pegs for a more traditional look like the Green & Greene stuff, so I bore round holes then square the top 1/4" or so with a chisel or mallet, taper the bottom of the peg a little to ease insertion and pound it in. Square pegs go into a round hole pretty easy.

I suppose someone is going to post test results showing the round peg holds 5% better than the square peg. Then I would have to reconsider my preferences.


Re: Let's talk drawboring pegs ..

#3

Re: Let's talk drawboring pegs ..

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Moses

I think you are referring to the end of the peg that lies outside the joint. I, too, like the square look. However, here I am asking about what goes on inside the joint.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Let's talk drawboring pegs ..

#4

Re: Let's talk drawboring pegs ..

Dean J from MN

In the period pieces I've looked at I see only evidence of square(ish) pegs in round holes; they exhibit the "lemon" shaped hole left from a shell bit. However, my sample size is far too small to make a sweeping statement that round pegs were never used.

My pegs start as squares, I knock the corners off with a chisel to make a tapered kind of octagon peg prior to inserting them. However, I don't drawbore -- I'm also with Peter F. on this one, I don't think furniture scale joinery used offset holes.

Re: Let's talk drawboring pegs ..

#5

Re: Let's talk drawboring pegs ..

Patrick Gibbons

I believe it is very difficult to drill a hole by hand that does not enlarge in the making. This may not be a significant enlargement. A tapered peg makes this problem moot. A tapered peg does not have to be precisely measured. One can "eyeball" the fit knowing that the taper will seat the peg correctly. I would think that a tapered peg helps to offset the problem of shrinking pegs.

Re: Let's talk drawboring pegs ..

#6

Re: Let's talk drawboring pegs ..

Dean J from MN

However, I don't drawbore -- I'm also with Peter F. on this one, I don't think furniture scale joinery used offset holes.

I'm not referring to Peter's 17th C riven work when I say I don't think furniture scale joinery was drawbored -- I don't think the sawn 18th C work was drawbored, just pegged. Sorry for any confusion!

Re: Let's talk drawboring pegs ..

#7

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)

David Barnett

Re: Let's talk drawboring pegs ..

#8

Stephen Shepherd

Drawboring = timber framing

Stephen Shepherd

Drawboring was used on timber framing; bridges, buildings, etc. because of the green wood used in the construction and clamping big things can be difficult. The pegs are rived square with the corners taken off

I have never seen evidence of drawboring on early furniture, just drilled and pegged. The old pegs I have examined are almost always octagonal like the trunnels on timber framing. I would like to see some historic evidence of drawboring furniture, but I haven't seen any references.

Stephen

Re: Let's talk drawboring pegs ..

#9

Re: Wood seasoning factors

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Forty years ago people were writing that in the colonial era wood was dried for 15 years or more before being used for furniture. Can you imagine a joiner saying "Sorry, we can't do anything until 1645, when the timber is ready"?

Equally ridiculous is the notion that furniture making was orchestrated around carefully monitored moisture content. This is 20th century thinking, not 17th century. Yes, freshly cut wood is too wet for good turning or good carving, but guys didn't keep charts and say that piece will be optimum moisture in a month. They didn't throw away a nice piece just because it sat around since last year.

Re: Let's talk drawboring pegs ..

#10

Incremental improvements

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

"I suppose someone is going to post test results showing the round peg holds 5% better than the square peg."

Only if diamond abrasives are used to shape the peg.

Sorry, I couldn't resist.

-----

On a more serious note, this is a good conversation.

Re: Let's talk drawboring pegs ..

#11

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)

David Barnett

Re: Let's talk drawboring pegs ..

#12

Moisture content

Bob Hackett

I think what went on was that the craftsmen back then had a far better understanding of what wood was and did or wouldn`t do in relation to both moisture content and using the type of wood most appropriate for the work at hand.I know that was the case in regard to wooden boat builders.It only seems reasonable that the same knowledge that was applied on the coast would work it`s way inland and be applied to furniture.

BTW-Peter`s blog that was linked to in the OP mentioned John.I believe John to be John Alexander who worked closely with Peter.You`d be hard pressed to find two more knowledgeable green woodworkers than those two.Drew Langsner also comes to mind.

Re: Let's talk drawboring pegs ..

#13

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)

David Barnett

Re: Let's talk drawboring pegs ..

#14

Debunking myths

Bob Hackett

Wooden boat builders came to mind(as well as coopers) because they had much the opposite experience that furniture makers had.Someone who made furniture was interested in taking wood from from wet to dry enough to be stable to use for their work.Boat builders and coopers took relatively dry wood and made things that had to be water tight and then put them to work in an environment that caused them to swell and take on moisture.

Same material used for two completely different purposes which exploited characteristics at opposite ends of the spectrum.

Where I live a piece of wood can be expected to go from 4% MC in the winter with the wood stove going to +11% in the humid summer with the windows open.

Many of the "furniture boys" who wanted to try their hand at being a joiner in a boatyard had to put up with a lot of rather blunt re-education from the old hands.Much of what they felt they knew for sure about wood got turned on it`s ear and they found they didn`t know quite as much about wood as they thought they did.

As a metalworker I knew more about the nature of wood than many of them did just by having to know how to attach things like deck fittings, drive lines and other metal assemblies to it.

Re: Let's talk drawboring pegs ..

#15

Re: Let's talk drawboring pegs ..

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Jim Kingshott certainly thought it useful to drawbore, which he accomplished by offsetting the holes a bit.

Pam

Re: Let's talk drawboring pegs ..

#16

Re: Let's talk drawboring pegs ..

TomD

I agree that drawboring ins't necessary or desirable in furniture. If the glue joint fails the pin will soon destroy the joint. Pins for the most part aren't found on quality furniture. It looks mostly to exist to get around clamps during assembly, which is also part of the function in timber framing. Traditionally in hide glue times, but joints were rubbed, dovetails assembled without clamps, but M+Ts need a little something else, so with pins you could really get by without much in the way of clamps at all.

Speaking of timber framing, there is one company that makes most of the pins used today, and the design is a thin diameter a quick transition to the full diameter. This allows on to get the pin into the space left with the design offset, to hammer everything home and have a full bore pin throughout. So if you wanted a version for 3/4" wood frames that have 1/4" hole and 1/16" offset, you would have a pin about 1 3/4" long with a minor diameter

Re: Let's talk drawboring pegs ..

#17

Re: Let's talk drawboring pegs ..

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

My guides in joinery and drawboring are Kingshott (M&T dvd) and Alexander (link below). I like the idea of making things from trees vs lumber, using riving vs sawing, pegs vs glue (doesn't work so great in wet wood), handmade pegs, etc. The only real problem is I don't need furniture.

You (impersonal) can hide the pegs if you wish.

Now if you prefer to use kiln dried wood, the only possible advantage to drawboring is to snug up M&T joinery; but even then it's important to fill the hole with a properly shaped/formed peg.

Pam

Re: Let's talk drawboring pegs ..

#18

Re: Debunking myths

TomD

It is funny what you say about the boatyard. That has been my least testing ground, because in modern wooden boat building, you can pretty much ignore moisture, so long as everything is dry during assembly:

This kind of thing:

http://www.youtube.com/user/WestSystemEpoxy#p/u/0/GDs_BKdYjaQ

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bDSk-RizrPg

Re: Let's talk drawboring pegs ..

#19

That isn`t what I had in mind

Bob Hackett

What I was talking about was plank on frame,real wood boat building.

Epoxy takes all the skill out of it.Make a mistake,no problem,add filler and cover with more cloth and resin.

Nope,not at all what I had in mind.

Re: Let's talk drawboring pegs ..

#20

Re: That isn`t what I had in mind

TomD

Plank on frame boatbuilding isn't real boatbuilding, it's making boats that don't last and that nobody uses. Like using the best .01% of musical instrument grade wood to make furniture you then store in the yard. This is why you can pick up project boats by some great makers for the cost of an outboard.

Skill is overrated, because at some point you have it, so what? It's an amazing achievement that an under 2 year old can speak, but at the age of 20, unless one is afflicted, one had better have something more to show for the past twenty years than having learned a few words. There is a reason why manual labour has had a lower rank in the scheme of things. The real achievement was getting up at 5 in the morning 6 days a week. Combine the low grade skills with a short work week or hobby schedule and you aren't making much of an impression.

There is, however, a lot of skill involved in wood epoxy boat building. I think it may suffer from that thing that hits trades that rather than having one skill absorb 5, so it is hard for the passer by to figure out, or to respect, since we tend to respect specialists. Wood epoxy boatbuilding involves woodwork, plastering type work, work with fabrics, work with paints (piano type finish, not house paint). Most of the leading practitioners are also designers, and have invented novel technologies like constant camber, KSS, Cylinder molding, etc...

Much of the skill involves integrating a lot of design and build information. While epoxies can confer long life it is far from guaranteed and very bad things happen if the water is trapped inside plastic with the wood. Developing your own suite of techniques that work with your skill and available materials takes a while. There is also a lot of structural challenge that is rarely fully communicated in plans. For better or worse there are a lot of material substitutions going on, and so you need to know strucuture. There is also a lot involved in the combination lofting and layout. Almost anything that can be dreamed up can be done, but knowing how to configure stuff in 3D is not a skill everyone has.

There are manual skills. Obviously the woodwork, scarphing, freehand grinding, work with laminates, fabrics. Lots of tooling like vacuum bags, molds... Coving is pretty simple but it takes a fair bit of skill to be fast. Then the whole wet work part is like the plasterer's art, Leveling and fairing surfaces, and ultimately painting them. This can be done to a much higher degree than in wooden boats traditionally, since for better or worse the work it gets compared to is series productions fiberglass moldings.

Wood epoxy boats use smaller pieces of wood, they all have to be under .75". It is true that a lot of that stuff can be purchased, or is produced by machines. But it is also true that it is some very nice wood, and is a pleasure to produce by hand. I have used Shoji techniques to turn it out on occasion, so there isn't anything saying you can't use traditional skills. If traditional wooden boat building was still a vital force, as is the timber frame housing it parallels, there would be a Ted Benson somewhere who had figured out how to use CNC and low wage labour to do it. Traditionally the veneer level work as done in wood composite work has a higher trade grade than the guy outdoors with a adze stuff. Just saying, as the kids say.

Epoxy work also mostly takes place under the gun. While nobody wants to lolly gag around at least with other materials you can choose your pace. With epoxy the pace is imposed on you, in two senses. There is the always impending kick off of the epoxy itself. But at other times there is also almost always a big rush to meet a deadline. So you start the day racing to get to a point where you can do some wet work, because if you don't you will essentially loose a whole day since the part will not get overnight to cure, or will miss a weather window, which is both a daily cycle, and good weather vs. bad thing.

And while the whole chemical weapons working environment is a bit of a drag, there is non-negligible skill in leaning how not to poison yourself, or the world around you. There is also skill in learning how to do delicate tasks, while dressed in a condom. One of my great pleasures is figuring out how to avoid the more toxic steps altogether. Sometimes one can come up with clever workarounds when money isn't on the table, or disposable lungs of guest workers aren't on offer, or unreasonable standards don't need to be met.

My only real regret about wood composite building is that there aren't more uses for steam...

Re: Let's talk drawboring pegs ..

#21

Let's Agree On Assumptions - then Analyze

charlie belden

To do an analytical comparison of square vs round let's agree on assumptions -so we're comparing apples to apples - then analyze and draw conclusions.

To that end I submit the following text and accompanying illustrations as a starting point - and my version of an analytical comparison. If I've left out something important please feel free to point it/them out. If I've made a false assumption (or two or three) I'm sure it will be pointed out as well.

And let's limit things to "dry wood" to begin with and the application limited to furniture as opposed to boat/ship building or timber framing.

(I did using round pins when I draw bored the through tenons of the base of my workbench - mainly to

permit dismantling if Das Bench ever has to be moved to another location. A workbench may or may not be considered "furniture" by some)


Re: Let's talk drawboring pegs ..

#22

Seems to me...

Bob Hackett

Pins are driven in with side grain surrounding and end grain showing so expansion and contraction should be equal over the entire pin.In essence a pin acts more like a quartersawn board and will be more stable than the board it`s driven into.

If you drove a metal pin into the hole and negated the expansion and contraction of the pin due to humidity there is still a good chance that the pin would loosen over time because the wood surrounding it will expand and crush then contract and gap as it cycles.

Ideally you would use as stable wood as possible milled to be as stable as possible(quartersawn?) and then pinned with pins that will closely match the expansion and contraction rate.

Unfortunately we are slaves to fashion and just like our wives/GFs insist on stuffing their feet into uncomfortable shoes because they just look so darn sexy in them many of us will continue to choose wood for both project and pins based on visual impact rather than function and utility.

Re: Let's talk drawboring pegs ..

#23

Re: Seems to me...

charlie belden

Wood expands and contracts Axially (along the grain), Radially (between the growth rings - I think) and Tangentially (acrossed the board - I think). The Axial movement is almost zero. It's the Radial and Tangential that's the challenge - and the Tangential is usually twice as large as the Radial. For flat boards, quarter sawn is preferred over riff sawn or through and through sawn because the Tangential movement is over the THICKNESS of the board, the Radial acrossed the width of the board. The use of QS boards advantage is that it's less apt to cup. The following illustration is from Lee Valley - and may help with this discussion


With a round peg, the width and thickness are the same so there's no big advantage to using QS vs riff/through and through = other than aesthetics. A round pin or square peg WILL change dimensions with changes in temperature and humidity and it won't do it uniformly.

Yes, the holes in the mortised part and the holes in the tenoned part will also change dimensions with changes in temperature and humiidity - but much more slowly because the exposed grain is side grain - and - if you use glue - semi sealed if you put glue on the end of the tenon.

Yes, having all the parts quarter sawn will reduce expansion and contraction differences but, that alone won't solve the basic problem of wood movement. And because the mortised part and tenoned part have their grain running 90s to each other their holes won't change dimensions in the same direction.

But my conclusion that square pegs are better than round pins still seems to make sense based on my earlier post with illustrations and text.

As for Utility vs Aesthetics, our challenge is to favor aesthetics over utility when it comes to House Furniture. An ugly cabinet - that's really strong and durable will lose to a less strong and less durable cabinet that looks really nice and maybe even elegant.

Givien the strength and durability of modern wood glues and epoxies, round pins or square pegs "pinning"/ "draw boring" a M&T joint is more of a decorative/aesthetic thing than a functional thing - at least for House Furniture M&T joints.

As for why some women choose to wear shoes AND clothes that are too small . . .?

Re: Let's talk drawboring pegs ..

#24

Re: Seems to me...

TomD

Yeah, well I also didn't get the fact that your peg appeared to be 100% short grain. Also the knock on round things in round holes is that the glue bond is not as favourable, In the example you gave with the non-plug, what looked like a screw covering plug, the side grain would have a 100% bond so shrinkage would be unlikely. Other factors are the section properties of the square vs. round in a load bearing situation, particularly one in which the loads are linear. And a furter issue would be the strength of the mortise round vs square. For any of this to make sense you would have to have an actual scenario, assign the governing condition, then choose from whatever 6-10 or more properties that could be optimized.

Also in practical terms nobody is going to choose similar areas

You buy stuff marked 1/4" say, where the sectional properties of a square are going to be even more favourable,

You sellect based on visual weight, results probably similar to above.

You sellect a starting point stock like 1/4" squares, and it turns out the same as above.

There are also a number of tricks like compressing the peg to allow reconstitution so the hole is overfilled, or drawboring which seems in practical terms biased to rounds

Which would take me back to a Michael Fortune kinda decision where given the complexity or irrelevance in most cases - which looks better.