Re: That isn`t what I had in mind
TomD
Plank on frame boatbuilding isn't real boatbuilding, it's making boats that don't last and that nobody uses. Like using the best .01% of musical instrument grade wood to make furniture you then store in the yard. This is why you can pick up project boats by some great makers for the cost of an outboard.
Skill is overrated, because at some point you have it, so what? It's an amazing achievement that an under 2 year old can speak, but at the age of 20, unless one is afflicted, one had better have something more to show for the past twenty years than having learned a few words. There is a reason why manual labour has had a lower rank in the scheme of things. The real achievement was getting up at 5 in the morning 6 days a week. Combine the low grade skills with a short work week or hobby schedule and you aren't making much of an impression.
There is, however, a lot of skill involved in wood epoxy boat building. I think it may suffer from that thing that hits trades that rather than having one skill absorb 5, so it is hard for the passer by to figure out, or to respect, since we tend to respect specialists. Wood epoxy boatbuilding involves woodwork, plastering type work, work with fabrics, work with paints (piano type finish, not house paint). Most of the leading practitioners are also designers, and have invented novel technologies like constant camber, KSS, Cylinder molding, etc...
Much of the skill involves integrating a lot of design and build information. While epoxies can confer long life it is far from guaranteed and very bad things happen if the water is trapped inside plastic with the wood. Developing your own suite of techniques that work with your skill and available materials takes a while. There is also a lot of structural challenge that is rarely fully communicated in plans. For better or worse there are a lot of material substitutions going on, and so you need to know strucuture. There is also a lot involved in the combination lofting and layout. Almost anything that can be dreamed up can be done, but knowing how to configure stuff in 3D is not a skill everyone has.
There are manual skills. Obviously the woodwork, scarphing, freehand grinding, work with laminates, fabrics. Lots of tooling like vacuum bags, molds... Coving is pretty simple but it takes a fair bit of skill to be fast. Then the whole wet work part is like the plasterer's art, Leveling and fairing surfaces, and ultimately painting them. This can be done to a much higher degree than in wooden boats traditionally, since for better or worse the work it gets compared to is series productions fiberglass moldings.
Wood epoxy boats use smaller pieces of wood, they all have to be under .75". It is true that a lot of that stuff can be purchased, or is produced by machines. But it is also true that it is some very nice wood, and is a pleasure to produce by hand. I have used Shoji techniques to turn it out on occasion, so there isn't anything saying you can't use traditional skills. If traditional wooden boat building was still a vital force, as is the timber frame housing it parallels, there would be a Ted Benson somewhere who had figured out how to use CNC and low wage labour to do it. Traditionally the veneer level work as done in wood composite work has a higher trade grade than the guy outdoors with a adze stuff. Just saying, as the kids say.
Epoxy work also mostly takes place under the gun. While nobody wants to lolly gag around at least with other materials you can choose your pace. With epoxy the pace is imposed on you, in two senses. There is the always impending kick off of the epoxy itself. But at other times there is also almost always a big rush to meet a deadline. So you start the day racing to get to a point where you can do some wet work, because if you don't you will essentially loose a whole day since the part will not get overnight to cure, or will miss a weather window, which is both a daily cycle, and good weather vs. bad thing.
And while the whole chemical weapons working environment is a bit of a drag, there is non-negligible skill in leaning how not to poison yourself, or the world around you. There is also skill in learning how to do delicate tasks, while dressed in a condom. One of my great pleasures is figuring out how to avoid the more toxic steps altogether. Sometimes one can come up with clever workarounds when money isn't on the table, or disposable lungs of guest workers aren't on offer, or unreasonable standards don't need to be met.
My only real regret about wood composite building is that there aren't more uses for steam...