New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

Removing The Set On A Dovetail Saw

Posts

Removing The Set On A Dovetail Saw

#1

Removing The Set On A Dovetail Saw

Robby Wright in San Marcos, CA

I thought I would come to the experts for this question. Years ago, I bought a Freud dovetail saw. It has 20 teeth per inch and cut fairly well, but I wanted it resharpened as a rip saw, so I took it to what I thought was a reputable saw sharpening shop and asked them to sharpen it rip with no additional set. They said fine, come back in a week.

A week later, I came back and they had sharpened the saw as crosscut with heavy set. It won't cut a good line anymore and wanders all over the place. I put in in a drawer and left it for ages.

Recently, I have gotten the urge to dig it out and try fixing it. I have the necessary files now and can make up a sharpening clamp, but I am not sure how to remove the set. I don't have a saw set either. I remember reading in one of James Krenov's books where he took a saw with too much set and clamped the teeth between a pair of metal lathe bits, which I could do easily enough if that would really work.

What do you think is a good way to remove the set from this saw?

Thanks in advance for your help.

Robby Wright

Re: Removing The Set On A Dovetail Saw

#2

Re: Removing The Set On A Dovetail Saw

Dean J from MN

I use three approches to removing too much set:

1) Just file it. Each time you file you take a bit of the set away. If you are resetting rake angles anyway this may do it for you.

2) Sandwich it between some hardwood and pinch it in your vise. This may not do much on what I'm guessing is pretty minimal set on this small saw, but is is worth a quick try.

3) Tap it out with a brass/bronze hammer. Set the plate on some softwood and walk down the plate gently taping each tooth set toward you. Flip and repeat.

Method 1 is the safe bet, 2 may not do much on such a small tooth, and 3 has a tiny risk of breaking a tooth (that said, I've never broken a tooth doing the hammer tap method.)

-Dean

Re: Removing The Set On A Dovetail Saw

#3

Re: Removing The Set On A Dovetail Saw

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Robby

I think that you will get several different replies.

My LN 15 tpi dovetail saw, which I have had for several years, cut aggressively and a little roughly from the outset. The roughness was due, in my opinion, to the set. Otherwise I liked the saw as it cut fast and true. Anyway, I removed all the set with a 600 grit diamond stone. The saw tracks a very straight line, leaves a smooth kerf, but is harder to push in hardwood (I was recently using it on 3/4" Jarrah casework). A little wax helps, and now is a desirable user.

It sounds to me as if you will need to refile the teeth to rip anyway, so you have less to lose by removing the set and trying it out this way first. Wait for a few responses to my suggestion firstv before you act.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Removing The Set On A Dovetail Saw

#4

Re: Removing The Set On A Dovetail Saw

TomD

I have just gently clamped it in a metal jaw vise. Since you can't overbend it, it won't be all that drastic. Also, since the steel is harder than the iron, it doesn't seem to dull the teeth or anything.

Re: Removing The Set On A Dovetail Saw

#5

Hi Robby...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

Did you have the saw re-toothed?

If not 20 tip for a rip saw might be seen as a bit extreme.

I'd take a 1000 or so stone and just grind off some of the set by wiping the stone down the sides of the saw.

Re: Removing The Set On A Dovetail Saw

#6

Re: Removing The Set On A Dovetail Saw

Robby Wright in San Marcos, CA

Thanks to all for your replies. I will give this a shot this weekend.

Robby Wright

Re: Removing The Set On A Dovetail Saw

#7

Re: Removing The Set On A Dovetail Saw

Jon

Did you have any luck with your saw?

Re: Removing The Set On A Dovetail Saw

#8

Re: Removing The Set On A Dovetail Saw

Robby Wright in San Marcos, CA

Unfortunately, I have been traveling so much for work I haven't had any shop time. I did think about it Saturday though. Thanks for asking.

Re: Removing The Set On A Dovetail Saw

#9

Re: Removing The Set On A Dovetail Saw

Marv

Robby,

As a hard and fast rule, I will not bend a tooth in the opposite direction than it has been bent/set. There is always a risk in chipping or breaking off a tooth, even the very small teeth.

Only two non-risk ways to reduce set is to either hone off the sides of the teeth or reduce it by filing the teeth.

Lets say that you hammer on the teeth and reduce the set too much.... when you reset the teeth to make them right, the tooth will have been bent three times. Hammering on the teeth also deforms them to a small degree, same thing if they are smashed in a vise.

Marv