Question regarding burning in tangs.
Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA
I understand the concept, but what to you do after burning it in?
Do you put the tang in water to cool it off or just let cool down naturally?
Thanks!
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Question regarding burning in tangs.
Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA
I understand the concept, but what to you do after burning it in?
Do you put the tang in water to cool it off or just let cool down naturally?
Thanks!
bad idea, well maybe exciting idea
Bill Tindall
Especially if you are doing larger tangs with lots of heat capacity and smoke and fire generation ability. It can remind one of a Mythbusters episode.
I drill a hole some smaller than the diagonal distance across the tang. Drive in the tang and fill the half moon spaces with sections of a dowel and epoxy. If you drill the hole parallel to handle the chisel will be parallel to handle. I had less success with the smoke and fire procedure.
Re: Question regarding burning in tangs.
Frank D. in Montreal
I just let it cool. You have to be careful with this method not to get too close to the final seat on the final burn. It took me on average 2 to 3 tries (after the first try, I'd take off the handle and reheat the tang), depending on th size of the tang, the hole, and the type of wood. If I got closer than about 1.5 inches to the final position before the final burn, the handle wouldn't be seated very tightly. Ideally I'd get about 3/4 or 1/2 inch from the ferrule with hand pressure on the last burn, then I'd give a few taps with a mallet to seat the handle completely. This way the tang won't continue burning the handle. Takes a little practice to get right (use some scrap first if you have the patience).
Re: Question regarding burning in tangs.
Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX
Have you tried holding the chisel vertically above a bench/table with the handle down and tapping with authority?
Pam
Re: Question regarding burning in tangs.
Frank D. in Montreal
Hi Pam,
I could try that, but I'm not sure how it would help. When I burn in the tangs the blade gets pretty hot, so the blades are in a vise. This lets me hold the handle at vertical, and when I tap it to finish off the process I have two hands free, which I think allows me more precision than tapping the whole setup on a bench. Another thing is that I try to let the heat do the work, never pushing too hard until the final few taps. This way the tang burns a mortise that's a perfect fit, and the handle doesn't risk splitting as it might if I drove it home too hard.
Re: Question regarding burning in tangs.
Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX
Sorry, I meant drilling and tapping as an alternative to burning.
Pam
Re: Question regarding burning in tangs
Frank D. in Montreal
No problem.
Drilling And tapping certainly works, but I prefer burning in. With drilling, either you drill a hole that's just big enough to fit the end of the tang in, then you have to pound the handle like crazy to seat the shoulders of the blade onto the ferrule. This introduces a weakness into the handle, if it doesn't split, that can make it split relatively soon. If, on the other hand, you drill a hole big enough to easily fit the tang into (with light taps only), there'll be voids on both sides of the tang where it's flat. Then you're kind of stuck using dowels as Bill suggests, or a lot of epoxy.
Burning in tangs, besides from being time-tested, is faster, and it does a more than adequate job of seating the tang so it doesn't split the handle or move around. It takes me 15 or 20 minutes to put handles on half a dozen new files (including cutting and splitting wood) and I don't have to use ferrules. It would take me a lot longer to do the same using other methods.
Todd Hughes convinced me to try this technique when I made a batch of chisels, and since then I don't use any other method to attach handles. Not to say there isn't more than one way to do it though.
Maybe I'll give burning a try. Thanks.
Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX
Article
Jack Guzman from Maine
Frank this would make a good article for Woodcentral's files. Would you mind outlining the process from start to finish so someone like me could follow it? I think I finally want to give this a try.---Jack
Re: Article
Frank D. in Montreal
Sure Jack.
My shop is in disarray right now (basement renos), but I think I already have enough pics to throw together a little tutorial. It's really quite simple. My only question is how I go about this...do I post it as a regular post, like starting a new thread, or should I talk to Ellis?
Re: Article
Jack Guzman from Maine
I'm not sure how to go about getting it in the archives ,but I suggest you just post it as a message. It would then be available for viewing to anyone who wishes to learn from it. I believe it could be posted to the articles section from there. I know they have taken articles directly from the messages before. I always wanted to try burning in a handle but I only have a vague idea of how it's done. ---Jack
Send it to "articles@woodcentral.com"
Dan Donaldson
You can also send it directly to me at dondad@gmail.com and I will get it up. For interest, we are trying to get some more articles going, so anyone that has an idea is welcome to send it in. It doesn't have to be "polished" if you don't want to take the time. Just send in the text and pictures and we can arrange it. For pictures, send as large as possible so they can be edited more easily.