Consider the Rob's approach
North of the Border
After taking a full day course from someone who is good at the Rob Cosman's method, I now largely use Rob's method - with the help of a fret saw, a shallow rabbet cut (skew plane e.g.), and chiseling. No test fit and bang! the tail and pin pieces come together tight (in most of the cases). I don't agree with some of the ways he does things for his business, but when it comes to dovetailing approach and efficiency, I can't find a more efficient way than his (after trying other methods (e.g. Frank Klaus's) covered in books or magazines). I use no jigs to help me pare to the baselines.
Here's how Rob does it: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xxIgNel0H_I
Disclaimer:I am not recommending or promoting any of his products (in fact I have none of his tools), but I suggest that people who have had difficulties of doing clean and accurate dovetails look into his method. You don't need to buy any of his products to use his method.