New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Archives questions for Admins

Posts

Archives questions for Admins

#1

David Barnett

Archives questions for Admins

David Barnett

I've been searching the archives for material and threads I contributed over the last few years and am unable to locate posts for a disturbing number of keywords and subjects, such as "quebracho", "Beilby", and so on. Although some results are offered, they are incomplete. Cross-searches (keywords for "quebracho" and "Boggs", for example) also fail.

Are these documents missing or simply inaccessible? And if so, why? I do recall expressing my concerns during the changeover to the newer system, but was admonished that "patience is a virtue" and that all things would be made stable.

I'm hoping that it's pilot error in searching for these earlier posts, and would be most grateful for clarification.

Re: Archives questions for Admins

#2

Re: Archives questions for Admins

bugbear

On a related note:

Is there any particular reason the archives have been made non crawlable (and thus nicely searchable...) by the public search engines (Bing, Google, etc)

BugBear

Re: Archives questions for Admins

#3

Ellis Walentine

Archives

Ellis Walentine

Hi David,

I have forwarded your comments (and BugBear's) to our developer in Germany for a more precise determination than I can give. What I can tell you regarding searching posts by author is that, a year ago, when we upgraded to the current system, that was not an option. Convinced that it was necessary, I got him to write a conversion script that appended a searchable author tag to all subsequent messages. The idea was to wait until we moved to our new server to run the script on the several hundred thousand prior archived posts. As of yet, we are still preparing to make the server move, so it isn't yet possible to search those older posts by author.

I'll let you know what our guru has to say. Sorry for any inconvenience.

Ellis

Re: Archives questions for Admins

#4

Ellis Walentine

RE: Searches

Ellis Walentine

David, our guru tells me that "...What's in the text is searchable, what's not in the text isn't." Posts are searchable by poster name since last March but not before. This will be updated when we make our move, hopefully in the next couple months.

If you would document specific cases you want us to investigate (e.g., your search term(s) and the results vs the expected results), e-mail them to me and we'll press further.

Patience is a virtue, especially around here. :)

Ellis

Re: Archives questions for Admins

#5

Ellis Walentine

RE: Search engines

Ellis Walentine

We have nothing blocking search engine access to our forums or archives. Can you be more specific?

Ellis

Re: Archives questions for Admins

#6

Re: RE: Search engines

wilbur

I think I know what bugbear is referring to. If the search engine sites are allowed access to the WoodCentral forums, then you can go to Google/Yahoo/Bing/etc. and do a search that is limited to a website, and that might be a workaround to the limited search facilities available right now on WoodCentral.

But I think that the WoodCentral forums are blocked from the search engine sites. I remember a couple years back an announcement was made that search engine crawlers were blocked from WoodCentral forums because they were slowing down WoodCentral quite a bit.

I did a Google search for "site:woodcentral.com shoulder plane", which should return all references to "shoulder plane" from WoodCentral. I got results from nearly every part of WoodCentral except the forums: Shop Shots, articles, video reviews, contests, chat transcripts, Badger Pond articles. Just no forum posts.

Re: Archives questions for Admins

#7

Re: Archives questions for Admins

Warren in Lancaster, PA

About a year ago James Watriss asked for help locating a workbench plan posted by Dirk Vogel on this forum in 2006. I thought it would be easy to find since I remembered telling Dirk that his bench with four vises made me think of a car with four steering wheels. A search for steering wheels did not work because, as it turns out, about half of the 2006 archives were deleted when the forum was changed in early 2010. I was able to find Dirk's drawing for James on a German site. Even if you don't know German it is easier to Suche the Handwerkzeugforum f�r Holzwerker than to search the Hand Tool Forum.

I reported this last year and repeated my steering wheel comment, but now I find that that does not show up in a search either. The search function does not pick up most of 2009 and 2010, even though they are in the archives. I was able to find this because I remembered it was in February 2010, but you won't find it through Search.

http://www.woodcentral.com/cgi-bin/archives_handtools.pl/bid/3001/page/20/md/read/id/145106/sbj/book-research-thom-can-help-i-think/

Here is an interesting post made by David Barnett on February 1, 2010, also currently not searchable.

http://www.woodcentral.com/cgi-bin/archives_handtools.pl/bid/3001/page/22/md/read/id/144746/sbj/no-ellis-say-it-ain-t-so/

Re: Archives questions for Admins

#8

David Barnett

Re: Archives

David Barnett

Thanks, Ellis.

I realize it's been a huge undertaking but had not known the server move was still to come. So first things first, of course, and I'll content myself with littering the forum with new posts while waiting for things to fall into place with the archives. I'm just relieved everything's still there even if not always accessible. Thanks again.

David

Re: Archives questions for Admins

#9

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)

David Barnett

Re: Archives questions for Admins

#10

Ellis Walentine

What am I missing?

Ellis Walentine

Your examples all found instances of the search phrases.

Ellis

Re: Archives questions for Admins

#11

Re: What am I missing?

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

OK, I tried a search last week that didn't return messages/threads that I remembered reading. I wanted to see what Sir William said about bullnose planes being useful; so I did a search on "William bullnose" and received a lot of messages, but the one I was looking for was not one of them. The one I wanted was posted in late 2004 and preceded my jib that William had enticed me to buy a bullnose a couple of months before but LV was out of stock.

I'd be real happy if it was something I did wrong.

A note about text outside the text not being searchable: I'd assume that everything text outside the main body would be included as text in the main body. That is, if the poster is William, William would be copied into the searchable text. I think you're doing this, at least for the posts later than 2004.

Pam

Re: Archives questions for Admins

#12

Re: What am I missing?

Warren in Lancaster, PA

If you search for steering wheels you get 122 responses. What are not included in these are the post I made in 2006 which included that phrase, the post I made on 2/14/2010 which included that phrase, or the post made on 2/15/2010 by VLParisian which also included the phrase.

No search of any keyword yields any Hand Tool results from roughly 2/2009 to 5/2010 even though these dates are in the archives. The hand Tool material from 7/2006 to 10/2006 is not in the archives and not searchable. If you want a good joke look at the first (or last) few pages of the 2006 Hand Tool archives.

Pam, William Duffield's bullnose review is on page 5 of the 2004 archives. I saw Sir William at Williamsburg last month; he seemed well.

Re: Archives questions for Admins

#13

Re: What am I missing?

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Thanks, Warren. How did you find it? Amazing.

Ellis, I think that maybe the search wasn't including the message title. As I said before, if this is the case it should be changed to include the message title in the text being indexed.

Pam