New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Why all the sharpening complexity?

Posts

Why all the sharpening complexity?

#1

Why all the sharpening complexity?

Paul M.

I've seen lots of discussion around here on diamond paste and cast iron lapping plates. It seems that sharpening is the main topic on this site.

I seem to be quite content with my very minimal sharpening inventory:

1 Norton combo waterstone 1000/4000

1 Japanese man-made stone (probably around 8000 equiv)

1 Course grit 10" DMT diamond plate (used only for flattening above waterstones, and never touches steel)

That's it. Three grits of waterstone in two separate stones with something to flatten the stone when it starts to wear. I've been using these same stones for a few years, and I've used less than half their lives.

I've never found a desire to strop, to use diamond paste, to use sandpaper glued to flat surfaces, to use a surface plate, etc.

Any other simpletons out there like me?

Re: Why all the sharpening complexity?

#2

Re: Why all the sharpening complexity?

David Weaver

>>Any other simpletons out there like me? <<

Yes, but they use oil stones.

Re: Why all the sharpening complexity?

#3

David Barnett

Good question

David Barnett

Why is your system so complicated, Paul?

All you need is a 600 grit stone, then jump to 1 micron on a suitable substrate and you're done!

"I seem to be quite content with my very minimal sharpening inventory:

1 Norton combo waterstone 1000/4000

1 Japanese man-made stone (probably around 8000 equiv)

1 Course grit 10" DMT diamond plate (used only for flattening above waterstones, and never touches steel)"

That isn't minimalist sharpening to me, but whatever floats your boat.

"It seems that sharpening is the main topic on this site."

Lately, yeah. Mea culpa! Mea culpa! But anyone's entirely free to start another topic and participate or not. So, what's on your mind besides sharpening?

"I've never found a desire to strop, to use diamond paste, to use sandpaper glued to flat surfaces, to use a surface plate, etc."

I was just talking to someone who told me they never had the desire to learn or play piano. Which is fine. Of course, he doesn't play piano. I do.

Re: Why all the sharpening complexity?

#4

Good point

Paul M.

I used to use a cinder block for flattening the waterstones, but changed to the diamond plate when one fell into my lap at Christmas time. :D

Re: Why all the sharpening complexity?

#5

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)

David Barnett

Re: Why all the sharpening complexity?

#6

Re: Now that's gotta smart

TomD

Why not, that sounds like a good story.

There is a lot of sharpening talk, but this is an anomalous period. Every few years something new comes out and has to be talked to death. Shaptons come to mind. I didn't go in for the shaptons, but over thrity years I have done the oil stones, files, carbide, ceramic, water stones natural and artificial, used Shaptons, all kinds of electric systems, diamonds fixed, diamond laps, scary sharp, and SC laps.

Diamonds are like scary sharp, fast, cheap, and to my way of thinking not the most stable base. But the speed is there, and I can see why people are excited. Most of these options have something to offer. I have acquired a lot of different stuff, but never thrown any of it out.

Re: Why all the sharpening complexity?

#7

Jack Guzman from Maine

Me too

Jack Guzman from Maine

I have a Tupperware "pond" on the counter next to my shop sink. In it are a 6000 grit King, 800 grit King, and 240 Norton that rarely sees use. For stone flattening I got a 400 grit diamond plate that I bought at one of those 50% off one item sales at Rockler. I keep planning on trying other methods but this works so why bother.---Jack

Re: Why all the sharpening complexity?

#8

I`m WAY simpler than YOU are!

Bob Hackett

Somehow that didn`t come out the way I had planned.

Anyway,bench grinder to 1 micron diamond on a piece of an old tablesaw.Done!

The only time I strop is to impress the ladies,they love it when you bring on the bling. :D :D

The thing I like about my way is that is even works on HSS and carbide,just takes a little longer.

Re: Why all the sharpening complexity?

#9

Re: Why all the sharpening complexity?

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

I think this diamond talk is because of the new steels used in tools these days. Waterstones work great for carbon steel, but get a few A2 or CPM 3V tools, and you start searching for another way.

Pam

Re: Why all the sharpening complexity?

#10

Re: Why all the sharpening complexity?

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I use a clean leather strop after polishing. I use it because years of experience have taught me that it gives a better edge.

There is a very neat model of sharpening that goes like this: After abrading away the rounded part of a dull edge, one makes finer and finer scratches on the bevel and the back. Then the finer the scratches, the better the edge. This is an extremely helpful model. It is helpful to look at edges under magnification. It is helpful to try to quantify sharpening media. However, what we are after here is how the tool actually works. The greatest sharpening skill is discernment. It is noticing how subtle changes in sharpening technique bring about subtle differences in the performance of the tool. I think experience suggests that things are rather more complicated than the finer scratch model.

To me, making up or evaluating a sharpening routine on paper is like playing football on a computer. You can't take a 265 pound guy who can lift so many pounds, run the 40 in so many seconds, etc., and evaluate him as a player without seeing him actually play. In the real world it takes a great deal of experience and discernment to know whether some guy might be helpful to one's team, or to know how to coax a better performance out of a certain player.

Re: Why all the sharpening complexity?

#11

Well said, Warren...

Doug Trembath

I tried the diamond regimen to get to an adequate edge cleaner and quicker. Not done with my evaluation, other things in the way...

Adequate edge is where your thoughts meld with mine. When I tested the new way with stuff I happened to have on hand, I was unable to get the fine shaving I am accustomed to, and happened to be flattening a Walnut crotch slab that was giving me fits.

Went back to Scary Sharp type sharpening, and finished the slab.

I do think, however, that when I get back to it, it will make a difference in the speed and cleanliness of my shop, as well as the resulting finish on the wood. I'll let you all know when that happens...

Doug Trembath

Re: Why all the sharpening complexity?

#12

David Barnett

Mystery beyond the measurable

David Barnett

In the West, we're often so inundated with the culture of quantification and the mythos of measurement we forget the personal. I don't remember who used the example, but it's an apt one.

"I'm cold," says one person.

"You can't be," says the other while checking the thermostat, "it's 75F in here."

Yet I remain skeptical that there's anything in the geometry and application of a sharpened edge that can't be observed, accounted for and replicated by modern analytical methods and techniques, whether through finer scratches or Beilby flow, or whatever. Human performance? Nope. Planes blades? Sure. But that's just me. And never the twain shall meet, maybe. But who knows? Maybe I'll evolve a Tielhard de Chardin straddle for sharpening.

[optional stridency-amelioratory your-mileage-may-vary kumbaya statement]

We all sure have different needs, different ways of working, don't we?

Re: Why all the sharpening complexity?

#13

Re: Mystery beyond the measurable

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I am claiming that the finer scratch model, however helpful it is in teaching sharpening, is limited in trying to explain all the phenomena we actually observe. Beilby's explanations may be somewhat outdated, but plasticity is a factor that is not accounted for in the simple model. I have no doubt that a fine metallurgist could construct a better analysis than we usually see.

In 1967 my chemistry teacher said this to me. "A model is expected to do three things. It is expected to explain the known phenomena, to explain new phenomena as we observe it, and to predict things that we have yet to observe. If it fails to do these things, we must construct a new model." Theory is pretty hollow if it doesn't gibe with experience. Charles Darwin actively participated in a pigeon breeder's club, just so that he could draw on the real world experience and wisdom of its members.

Re: Why all the sharpening complexity?

#14

Re: Why all the sharpening complexity?

David Weaver

The individual in question could choose to strop with an 8000 waterstone simply by letting the surface of the stone dry and continuing to sharpen the tool with the ever burnishing surface.

I think this would be similar to the effect of a plugged and fine oilstone, it would reduce the depth and width of the scratches, and at the same time burnish the steel with the swarf that was already there. with the waterstone, removing this burnished swarf is as easy as applying more water on the next iron.

I use a strop, too, if I am not using a very fine stone, or if the iron is heavily cambered where a strop makes it much easier to finish the edge. But there are options to go sharper for people who don't have one.

Re: Why all the sharpening complexity?

#15

Re: Why all the sharpening complexity?

TomD

Actually, that is pretty much what an 8000 artificial stone, like the KING does wet. Users of traditional waterstones complain about that effect, though I have to say it has given me some of the most brutal cutting power I have observed.

I have yet to see any edge that was superiour to the ones I used to get when I preped tools with SC on an iron plate, and then sharpened them on Kings. I cared more at the outset. It's probably out there to be had, but I haven't seen it.

Re: Why all the sharpening complexity?

#16

Steven Antonucci

I discuss this with carvers all of the time

steven antonucci

I agre that sharper is better, but only if you can get there very quickly and maintain it easily.

Assuming that I am dealing with a flat edged tool, I simply use a small diamond paddle on the bevel (I think it's 600 grit) to remove enough metal to get back to sharp. I then go "sharper" with a finer diamond paddle (1200?), and maybe even sharper on a piece of wet/dry 2000 sandpaper backed by a small glass block.

I finish off with a strop and some compound (Flexall Yellow/White diamond... all of them make the edge "sharpest"). Time from start to finish is under 1 minutes, and perhaps 2-3 strokes at each stage. I have bare spots on my arm from using the resulting edge to shave hair, and I sharpen often because it can be done quickly with no fuss.

My entire setup is about $20.

Steve