New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

RE: Retrograde question for neophytes LONG

Posts

RE: Retrograde question for neophytes LONG

#1

RE: Retrograde question for neophytes LONG

Doug Trembath

With belated apologies to all regarding the tongue-in-cheek reply I made to the thread David Barnett had posted on diamond sharpening, I have something to add...

Those of us who have been following forums for years will remember when the initial discovery of "Scary Sharp" came out, and the diverse and sometimes extreme reactions and dialogue that accompanied it. There were afficionados who stated that it was the 'ONLY' way to achieve an adequate sharpness level, measuring shavings with micrometers, using microscopes to see the sharpening scratches which were invisible otherwise in the highly polished edges, and debating different grit types and ranges. Lots of acrimony and heated discussion resulted for quite some time, then faded as the participants came to a more common understanding of the subject, and we were all friends again. The result was that that "Scary Sharp" ended up as one of the tools available, and the tool of choice for many, in our collective sharpening arsenal.

Diamond sharpening discussions almost reached that point, no?

After thinking a bit about the subject, I decided it was ludicrous to question anyone's approach without at least trying it.

I used the method Bill Tindall had suggested, with Acrylic and some diamond paste I had purchased from Graves about six years ago. It was a set of 3 syringes with 325, 1200, and 50,000 grit. I used a LV bevel-up smoother, with two 38 deg blades, one sharpened with the diamond, one SS. In my comparison, I was unable to pick up the finest shavings with the diamond sharpened blade that were immediately picked up with the SS method. The blade was sharp, yes, but not sharp enough to take the shaving I desired. That may equate to the portion of the latter discussion about how sharp is sharp enough?

CAVEAT!!! I believe that using a more progressive range of media grit would improve the performance of the diamond regime I used, and I am, as I write this, looking for a supplier of a broader range of grits. Also picked up a beautiful section of black Granite from a local supplier for $25 yesterday.

I do this because the speed, cleanliness and simplicity of the process is very attractive, and I applaud Bill and David, primarily, as well as others, for sharing the process with the group.

Any recommendations for a red-faced participant?

Doug Trembath

Re: RE: Retrograde question for neophytes LONG

#2

Taking advantage of advantages

Bob Hackett

One of the big advantages I find with diamond is the ability to skip all those intermediate steps.

For me the key was not to substitute diamonds for all the corresponding grits of stone or other abrasives I was using but to use diamond to it`s best advantage and that was as a very tough and durable,fast cutting abrasive.I backed it with what the industry experts recommend(cast iron) as a substrate.I took an old discarded tablesaw table from the dump and cut it down.

I found that I can get the same results that Bill T. does with his posted approach and go from the grinder (I use both an electric and hand powered bench grinders with 60 grit or equivalent wheels) directly to 1 micron diamond paste/powder and skip everything else,no worries about cross contamination moving from grit to grit.This has cut my sharpening time at least in half and I get great results.

If an average guy like me with physical disabilities can do this I`m sure it should be no problem for any able bodied newbie to get the same great results.BTW-because of my disability I use a grinding jig.Since I use only one grit size for diamond I don`t have to worry about transfer and contamination with the jig.

IMO-those who replicate all those same steps used with stones or other loose abrasives are really missing the boat on what diamonds are capable of.I suggest they try it exactly as Bill has suggested in his recent posts.I`ll be surprised if you aren`t able to get the same results as both he and I do.

I am also NOT surprised that you get less than stellar results when you change the parameters of the experiment/approach.

If you feel the need to refine the edge further then by all means use some of the time you saved honing to a chrome like polish on your choice of whatever combination you can`t keep away from.I prefer either 1/2 micron diamond or 3M Finesse-it on hard maple,but only because I have a 2 lifetimes supply of these things.

Re: RE: Retrograde question for neophytes LONG

#3

David Barnett

Sounds like you got it goin' on, Doug *LINK*

David Barnett

"I believe that using a more progressive range of media grit would improve the performance of the diamond regime I used, and I am, as I write this, looking for a supplier of a broader range of grits."

Right track, but that's a mighty big jump from 1,200 to 50,000.

"Any recommendations for a red-faced participant?"

14,000 grit. That's it. 14,000 grit.


Lopacki has everything but the 8,000, and cheap!

Re: RE: Retrograde question for neophytes LONG

#4

questions

Bill Tindall

Traditionally when comparisons are published details of both sides of the comparison are made. In this way the reader can best judge the experiment as well as repeat it should they wish to. While you provided sufficient detail of the diamond part, details were lacking on the other half of the comparison.

The comparison was with "Scary Sharp" a specific variant of a long used and reported sharpening method that uses abrasive sheets. (There is a reference to using abrasive sheets in the very early issues of Fine Woodworking Magazine and it has been used in machine shops well before that, as has diamond abrasion.)

Questions that would help the reader of your post:

1.In this comparison are you in fact using the materials advocated by the Scary Sharp author, or some other application of abrasive sheets? Is so, exactly what?

2. Do you begin with a hollow ground surface?

The best published work on this topic has been done by Steve Elliott. I would direct the reader to his web site where this work is discussed. As a result of his work there is no doubt that diamond abrasives, properly applied, yield equivalent sharp edges to any other technique. Additionally, he convincingly showed that some typical tools steels can be sharpened equivalent to carbon steel. The requirement for the tool steels is to employ an abrasive that will cut the hard carbides in these alloys.

Re: RE: Retrograde question for neophytes LONG

#5

Answer

Doug Trembath

Bill, it was never my intent to publish a full blown, detailed scientific comparison study to edify folks new to the diamond honing process, nor to disprove its efficacy. I did the comparison to try the process for myself.

My aim with this post was to ask for guidance from those in the know as to what additional grits or particle sizes might improve my own results with the diamond honing process.

I admire many of the folks like yourself, Steve Elliott, Derek Cohen, and many others who have taken that kind of presentation on, and provided a wealth of instruction for others. Again, that was not my intent. Had it been, the post would have been structured much differently.

To answer your question, for my version of Scary Sharp related honing, I use a progression of abrasive papers adhered to a glass plate, currently from 220 Silicon Carbide to 2500. I believe right now it's 220, 320, 400, 600, 1000, 1500, and 2500. I, like most of you, hollow grind and hone a short bevel, the length of which varies depending on the angle I am sharpening to. I don�t always start with heaviest grit, sometimes just go back a couple of steps, depending on the requirement. Others use different abrasives, methodology, etc.

I suppose I might have been better served to not use the "trademarked" name of the Scary Sharp process. My bad, I guess... I used the term as it seems to have evolved, as a generic reference to describe the use of abrasive sheet goods to sharpen.

Thanks for the reference to Steve's work. I can't seem to load his site presently, but will look for the info I require there when I can access it.

Now, off to the Super Bowl party!

Go Steelers!

Doug Trembath

Re: RE: Retrograde question for neophytes LONG

#6

Re: Sounds like you got it goin' on, Doug

Doug Trembath

Thanks, David, for the recommendation and the link. I'll check them out.

Doug Trembath

Re: RE: Retrograde question for neophytes LONG

#7

A different experience *LINK*

Larry Williams

Several years ago, when all the buzz about loose diamond sharpening started, the idea sounded like it might have merit for our work. We needed a faster way to flatten freshly heat treated irons.

I ordered a tube of 45 micron diamond from Joel and we tried it on both Lexan and machined flat aluminum sub-straights. I have a cast iron table from an old stationary belt sander I intended to saw up for lapping plates if things worked out.

Even though the 45 micron diamond is slightly more coarse than the coarsest paste at David's link, we found the process slow. In fact, it was slower than what we had been doing. The sub-straight also went out of flat quickly.

We weren't necessarily looking to change the sharpening we do, just make flattening faster. I find my coarse stone, a medium India, is almost too aggressive when it comes to sharpening. Don usually avoids the medium India in favor of fine India. He feels it offers slightly better control for little cost in speed.

I don't have a problem using diamonds. We use diamond stones to flatten oil stones. We also have an oscillating diamond grinder in the metal shop. The link below is to the diamond grinder we use for carbide metal working bits.

My experience with that brings up another issue. I once had a number of plane irons to do that needed accurate clearance angles ground to their sides. I decided to use the diamond grinder and ordered in a new set of grinding wheels for it. In a very few minutes and with little progress I had worn out a pretty expensive grinding wheel. I called the manufacturer and spoke to their tech rep.

He explained that diamond grinding wheels shouldn't be used to grind ferrous metals. They're designed for things that generate a granular grinding swarf like carbide, stone or glass. The diamonds are mounted in a nickel matrix that's intended to slowly wear away as the layered structure of the diamonds fail. Each diamond is a series of brittle layers and, as their cutting edges wear, they fracture and spall away exposing another layer with fresh edges. Steel and other ferrous metals have a stringy shaving-like swarf that quickly wears the nickel, undermining and releasing the diamonds. I believe some of the diamond stones available use a resin matrix but I doubt these are more resistant to the metal shavings in the swarf of ferrous metals.

This is why all the texts on machine shop practice say to grind away the steel backing on carbide tipped tool bits before grinding the carbide. It also explains why I wore out the first extra coarse diamond stone I bought so quickly. However, the extra coarse stones we use for dressing oil stones seem to last and last.

As to dealing with coarse grained steels with carbide inclusions, like A-2 or D-2, I don't have any advise. If that's what one wants to use, and I have no idea why anyone would, David might be the person to listen to.


Kool-Kut oscillating grinder

Re: RE: Retrograde question for neophytes LONG

#9

Re: RE: Retrograde question for neophytes LONG

Phil Smith

"I used the method Bill Tindall had suggested, with Acrylic and some diamond paste I had purchased from Graves about six years ago. It was a set of 3 syringes with 325, 1200, and 50,000 grit."

The step from 1200 (15 mciron) to 50000 grit is way to big. I recently picked up some 50,000 grit (o.5 micron) paste. Tried it this morning. Does not cut fast enough to produce good edge quickly with something that has the previously be sharpened with 15 diamond powder.

"CAVEAT!!! I believe that using a more progressive range of media grit would improve the performance of the diamond regime I used, and I am, as I write this, looking for a supplier of a broader range of grits. Also picked up a beautiful section of black Granite from a local supplier for $25 yesterday."

Been there and done that. I have 4 cast iron plates charged with 30, 15, 3, and 1 micron diamond powder. The coarser grits do cut very fast but managing the diamond carry over from larger to smaller plates is not worth the effort unless you are flattening the backs of new tool steel plane irons or chisels (CPM 3v and CPM M4).

Now I hollow grind on grinder, put small bevel on with fixed diamond stone and then hone with 1 micron powder on cast iron plate.

Plane iron of choice is a CPM M4 particle steel hardened to rockwell 64. You cannot sharpen with any of the other media commonly used.

Re: RE: Retrograde question for neophytes LONG

#10

Difficulties with my website

Steve Elliott

For over a week my web hosting service has been ignoring my requests to get my site back online. I'm getting no response whatsoever and will be switching to a new web host.

Sorry for the inconvenience. I'm glad somebody is interested, though.

Re: RE: Retrograde question for neophytes LONG

#11

Re: RE: Retrograde question for neophytes LONG

Doug Trembath

Those were my thoughts as well, Phil, I was just looking for a recommendation for what to use in addition. Thanks for your help!

Doug Trembath

Re: RE: Retrograde question for neophytes LONG

#12

Re: RE: Retrograde question for neophytes LONG

Doug Trembath

Thanks, Phil. My sense is that the seller must have had a bunch of the three grits and put together a "Special Offer", not knowing the incremental increase would hurt the end result. They no longer offer the trio, as far as I can find on the website. Interesting experiment, though.

Doug Trembath

Re: RE: Retrograde question for neophytes LONG

#13

Graves...

John in NM

They are primarily a lapidary supplier, and the jump from 1200 to 50k is not totally un-heard of with lapidary materials, depending on what is being cut. That said, even for lapidary work I don't think I'd have put those three grits together as a package.

Re: RE: Retrograde question for neophytes LONG

#14

Pick your poison

roninkokomo

The cabinet makers two hundred years ago got smoothers razor sharp with oil stones. Out here we have 4 or more techniques that are used. They all produce razor edge tools or we would not have heard of them/ The secret is picking one and working at it enough till you are good at it.

It's like the comment I heard Mike Speas say about dovetails. " I'll bet you ten bucks your hundredth joint is a lot better than your third one."

I am guilty of looking for the "secret". The secret is practice.