RE: Retrograde question for neophytes LONG
Doug Trembath
With belated apologies to all regarding the tongue-in-cheek reply I made to the thread David Barnett had posted on diamond sharpening, I have something to add...
Those of us who have been following forums for years will remember when the initial discovery of "Scary Sharp" came out, and the diverse and sometimes extreme reactions and dialogue that accompanied it. There were afficionados who stated that it was the 'ONLY' way to achieve an adequate sharpness level, measuring shavings with micrometers, using microscopes to see the sharpening scratches which were invisible otherwise in the highly polished edges, and debating different grit types and ranges. Lots of acrimony and heated discussion resulted for quite some time, then faded as the participants came to a more common understanding of the subject, and we were all friends again. The result was that that "Scary Sharp" ended up as one of the tools available, and the tool of choice for many, in our collective sharpening arsenal.
Diamond sharpening discussions almost reached that point, no?
After thinking a bit about the subject, I decided it was ludicrous to question anyone's approach without at least trying it.
I used the method Bill Tindall had suggested, with Acrylic and some diamond paste I had purchased from Graves about six years ago. It was a set of 3 syringes with 325, 1200, and 50,000 grit. I used a LV bevel-up smoother, with two 38 deg blades, one sharpened with the diamond, one SS. In my comparison, I was unable to pick up the finest shavings with the diamond sharpened blade that were immediately picked up with the SS method. The blade was sharp, yes, but not sharp enough to take the shaving I desired. That may equate to the portion of the latter discussion about how sharp is sharp enough?
CAVEAT!!! I believe that using a more progressive range of media grit would improve the performance of the diamond regime I used, and I am, as I write this, looking for a supplier of a broader range of grits. Also picked up a beautiful section of black Granite from a local supplier for $25 yesterday.
I do this because the speed, cleanliness and simplicity of the process is very attractive, and I applaud Bill and David, primarily, as well as others, for sharing the process with the group.
Any recommendations for a red-faced participant?
Doug Trembath



