Too long (no surprise there), and mostly about me.
David Barnett
"My eyes see shapes and subtle angles that I cannot recreate on a machine. Handtools are point-and-shoot. Handtools can finesse a joint, dimension, shape that would take hours to set up on a machine (if one was so inclined ... and still not capture)."
There's little I would add to your first point, or for that matter, the other three, Derek. You've pretty much nailed it. But your post really made me think about this, so I'll share some thoughts and feelings within your framework.
The seeing of formal subtleties are integral to craft as I experience it. It's the near-ceaseless making of even the smallest, fleeting aesthetic decisions and making those thoughts materially manifest that I most crave -- that mercurial intimate tango of mind and hand. I have a very hard time stopping, though. It takes real discipline for me to take breaks before finally giving into exhaustion. And even then, I'll stay frustrated until I can get back to it.
As for machines, while I sometimes enjoy using them, as I get older, more limited physically and less secure in my vision, (optically, that is), I'm far more comfortable with and grateful for hand tools. I've seen some extreme and appalling (and sometimes ingenious) examples of jigging, but for the most part, the end result too often leaves me cold. And I just don't have the patience for that.
"I certainly get more pleasure from using handtools because the end result is more readily "owned" as "my" skill."
For woodworking, this used to be far more important when I was learning than now, but it's probably a matter of time, as I still derive considerable pleasure this way in goldsmithing and even more so in glass sculpting, which is the order I came to them.
"I enjoy most the tactile experience of working with my hands (and especially since I spend so many hours talking and problem-solving in a chair during the day)."
"Often the hands will solve a mystery that the intellect has struggled with in vain." --C. Jung
I firmly believe the hand knows first, and in truly surprising ways. It has made the right chess move when I was utterly flummoxed, and started my opponent's clock before I'd even realized, much less analyzed, having made the move. And I certainly couldn't play piano if I was constantly aware of what my hands were doing, other than in that trance-like meta-managerial state. After cutting back on playing due to tendonitis and CTS, I was lost until I finally took up less demanding hand work. My need and appreciation for things haptic* reawakened and propelled me back to hand tools. I began working wood. And found that the hand in thrall to the unconscious can reliably produce beautiful work.
After talking and sitting all day, that makes complete sense to me. And when I began woodworking, and for a few years thereafter, I, too, enjoyed the benefits of greater mobility and freedom. Unfortunately, mostly what I do now is from a chair, and now am I not only entirely sedentary, I'm sitting in fixed, restricted positions, especially as I work long stretches through a microscope, which for all its advantages, does not promote much movement and affords no exercise at all. At least the years of piano for hours each day was physical enough to wear me out and relieve stress. Getting worn out at a jeweler's bench is quite a different matter.
"There is nothing like the quiet of a shop, broken only by the quiet refrain of soft piano or sax in the background, and the swish of a plane or the slicing of a paring chisel."
This is wonderfully true for me. At least in the sense that it's quiet when I need it to be. I'm generally alone with my thoughts and have only rare interruptions. While I can and do derive pleasure in shaping, carving, and other hand directed operations with power tools, it's those times when I just sit and think and imagine that have made craft most worthwhile. While there are times I love listening to music while working, I'm too often distracted by it. Also, I can't abide radio programming -- so unpredictable. Luckily, I have an FM stereo transmitter that covers my house, so I simply broadcast my own playlists to the shop radio.
"I do not see using powertools as some sort of "moral weakness" nor a "shortcut" to a skill."
I'm glad to hear it said this way. I think are too often underlying assumptions, one's of which we're not always aware. Of course, I still gall at derision from power tool elitists, but mostly it entertains me -- I've found woodworking stores especially good for this.
"I have a limited interest in discussing powertools. My website is about using handtools."
I'm pretty much that way regarding stationary tools, and while I do like some hand-guided power tools, small angle grinders, flexshaft rotary tools, and so on, they're not nearly so interesting to talk about as planes, saws, chisels, scrapers -- heck, even awls and marking knives are more interesting than power tools.
"David, those plywood boxes are very striking. I will borrow the concept, if I may."
Please do. I did. 
Those little cases were therapeutically antidotal to my incessant and compulsive tweaking, tweaking, tweaking, by the way, and it was hard making myself do it. There are no craft challenges in making these, obviously. And cheap? Leftovers.
Lord knows they're disturbingly simple, but that was the point. The plywood cutoffs were already stacked and glued, so I bandsawed the electronics cavity and glued on the top. Let's just stop and savor that -- let it sink in. No joinery. None. Nada. And the chassis is just 1/2" aircraft aluminum. My only indulgences were turning the knobs and the anti-vibration stabilizers.
Later on, I built a 8-foot-long workbench for another room to support my Taig lathe, miniature drill press, a couple small buffers, and so on. The top is glued up BB (plies facing up, of course), with a huge ebonized red oak trestle base. The top couldn't have been easier to construct and I would urge anyone with limited skills and tooling to give the method consideration. Fast, easy, cheap -- and surprisingly pleasing to look at.
"Which raises another point. I have worked almost entirely in solid wood, and now see the limitations of this. Fine woodwork is not simply about the tools."
I gain tremendously from cross-disciplines. While I do love wood more than most anything, I love metals, stone, and glass almost as much, and enjoy way too many other materials to enumerate. Which is why I'm very mixed media in my approach to craft. But more to the point, I'm materials driven.
It's materials and combinations of materials that most stimulate me, which is why jewelry is a perfect fit. But I can mix wood, metal, glass, and leather in so many ways without getting bored or stale. A small wood cabinet with hammered or copper panels. Or a shagreen-covered table lamp. And on and on.
Of course, the irony is that I've become enamored of sleeker, more minimal design. With a few exceptions, I'd much rather look at George Nelson, Probber, Eames, Rhode or Noguchi than most furniture. Anything that goes with terrazzo, I guess. The further, and more deep-cutting irony, though, is the chairs and seating I most admire cannot contain me nor intercede for gravity. Damn.
Derek: "Okay... this would seem a good place to stop, and I see our time is up. Next week, then. You can pay on your way out."
David: "Uh... Okay. Right. Next week, Doc."
__________________________________________
*Some interesting reading on the hand as it relates to perception, thinking, learning, and craft.
Human Hand Function [Hardcover]
Lynette A. Jones (Author), Susan J. Lederman (Author)
Absolutely terrific.
The Thinking Hand (Architectural Design Primer) [Paperback]
Juhani Pallasmaa
The Eyes of the Skin: Architecture and the Senses [Paperback]
Juhani Pallasmaa (Author)
The Craftsman [Paperback]
Prof. Richard Sennett (Author)
Chapters on machines, the hand.
Hands [Paperback]
John Napier (Author), Russell H. Tuttle (Editor)
The Hand: How Its Use Shapes the Brain, Language, and Human Culture [Paperback]
Frank R. Wilson (Author)