New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

I've seen better butts, sure... *LINK*

Posts

I've seen better butts, sure... *LINK*

#1

David Barnett

I've seen better butts, sure... *LINK*

David Barnett

Okay, first let me say that Joel at ToolsForWorkingWood sells a primo horse butt strop for an entirely reasonable price, especially if you need only one, and it's ready to go.

Even so, I felt I should share that Siegel of California is offering a Friday Special on grade #2 horse butts. You need to know that this ad was sent by email, so there's no link to the picture showing five representative horse butts (no, not congressional horse butts), but if you email me, I'll try to send it to you (my sleep is quite haphazard, lately).

What will you see? Five sorry butts, that is, smallish and not so pretty as their grade #1 butts they normally sell for $13.95/lb (which comes to about one long butt). These are shorter and they may even have a hole now and then, but you can work around that for the amazing price of $6.00/lb with free freight.

Two things: you have to order at least five, and their minimum order is $25.00, so you'll need to buy enough to meet that -- these likely weigh less than a pound each. Anyway, this is chance to get horse butts for cheap and have enough for, well, ever.

If you wish to add or would rather have their #1 butts, search horse.

From Siegel's Friday Special ad:

Prices are Valid only for Friday and Monday ONLY)

The sale is no longer valid on Tuesday, so please don't ask.

#2 Grade of Horse Butts

At this special price, we cannot sort for selection; but please specify if you prefer: Hard-Rolled or Soft-Rolled and Light Weight (5-7) or Heavy Weight (7-9)

Special Price $6.00/lb, (freight included) minimum 5 pcs

Since the first offering of this leather, we have had EXCELLENT feeback on this leather for value. We also offer the #1 grade of horse butts for those of you who may need more length with less cosmetic defects.

Vegetable Tanned Horse Hide 2nd Grades

Normally we only carry the top selection of this product which is used for everything from Barber Strops to Holsters to Belts to Spur Straps, etc

These are second grades. A representative 5 skins were taken from the top of the "stack" which appear to the left.

The second skin from the right has my waist belt laid across the top of the skin as a reference point for length and size of these horse butts.

Place your phone orders on Friday from 7 am to 4:30 pm PST: 1-800-862-8956 or 805-686-2700


Siegel of California

Re: I've seen better butts, sure... *LINK*

#2

Re: I've seen better butts, sure...

Tom Colligan

Many thanks, Dave; I'm going to call on Monday. In the past they told me they wouldn't sell to individuals though. Can you recommend if soft or hard rolled is the way to go for our sharpening purposes? Take care, Dave, and many of us so appreciate your writing and input (as well as ThomD, Derek, Wilbur and a consistent gang of 5 or 6 others.)

Re: I've seen better butts, sure... *LINK*

#3

David Barnett

Hard or soft butts? What can I say? I like both. *LINK*

David Barnett

"Many thanks, Dave; I'm going to call on Monday. In the past they told me they wouldn't sell to individuals though."

You're welcome. I don't remember Siegel asking for my tax ID, and I know a couple others who've ordered that don't even have one, so I hope it won't be a problem.

"Can you recommend if soft or hard rolled is the way to go for our sharpening purposes?"

There are honest differences of opinion here, but I slightly favor the soft jacked for my strops, especially for wide carving tools. I use both hard and soft, however, and both work well. The hard is excellent for chisels and planes, of course, and is better for narrow tools. I don't get dubbing on the softer strops (none visible at 45x, anyway), but maybe I have a lighter touch. I doubt it, though.

Believe me, when Siegel says soft, though, it means something different than anything else I'd call soft in the leather industry. It's plenty hard for stropping, in my opinion, is the way most horsehide would've been until the leather industry started calendaring hides, and to me, holds and presents larger micron particles exceptionally well.

Hard jacked is very hard indeed, and yes, sometimes it's a tad heavier than soft jacked of similar thickness. It usually has a more calendared surface than the soft, as well. If you are using chrome crayon or 14,000 grit or finer diamond, and could only choose one jacking, then hard is what I'd go with. Besides, you can abrade the surface to suit your preference.

Bob Strawn, in an earlier thread, says:

"Soft means more dubbing. You can also glue up and then lap your butt. If you want it really hard, then wet it and let it dry without disturbing it."

That's a good rule of thumb, I know, but I still prefer the soft. Anyway, since you have to get at least five pieces, perhaps try both. Maybe two soft and three hard.

By the way, I prefer the lighter weight hides at 5 to 7 oz.

"Take care, Dave, and many of us so appreciate your writing and input (as well as ThomD, Derek, Wilbur and a consistent gang of 5 or 6 others.)"

Thanks, Tom. I, too, get great pleasure reading and learning from those guys.

The following link covers more on hard vs. soft. However, I've grown to appreciate the hard strops more now, so please take that into account.


I must respectfully dissent... (Mar '08)