New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

The meaning of handcrafted

Posts

The meaning of handcrafted

#1

Chris Scholz

The meaning of handcrafted

Chris Scholz

It's early in San Jose, CA and I have to catch a flight.

Half asleep I buy a cup of coffee and what do you know, a big banner right behind the barista "informs" me that the coffee that I am fixing to enjoy is "hand crafted".

Ok, Miss Barista, you got my attention, what is "hand crafted coffee?" Is there indeed someone who grinds the beans by hand, watches the put until the water boils and carefully brews the coffee just right to release the full flavor of the hand-picked beans that have been rosted in small mountain village in South America according to ancient traditions?

"Sir, we push the green button", she replies, "that's why the coffee is hand-crafted."

Oh, well, never mind.

Re: The meaning of handcrafted

#2

Geographical interpretations

Bob Hackett

One must remember that in this country it`s not the steak that`s sold,it`s the sizzle.

"Chicken is the new steak" was one line of spin I heard but couldn`t believe.

Another is "Black is the new chrome".

We may soon be moving back toward more truth based marketing techniques as the pendulum returns and hits us between the eyes.Then we can look forward to marketing strategies we can more readily understand like "Consumers are the new sheep".

Marketing is all about fleecing,shearing and clipping after all.

Re: The meaning of handcrafted

#3

Re: Geographical interpretations

wilbur

Black is not the new chrome.

Black is the new black.

;)

Re: The meaning of handcrafted

#4

Different circles

Bob Hackett

It`s my understanding that if you are speaking in terms of 4 wheels then "Black is back"

If you are talking about 2 wheels then "Black is the new chrome".

I could very well be wrong as I don`t follow the current trends in transportation these days any more than I keep my finger on the pulse of fashion design.I know only enough to engage in well aimed sacasm.

What with "rat rods" and "bobbers" sporting satin finish on everything and the pendulum having swung from highly polished CNC "billet barges/circus bikes" to handmade "garage built" modes of transportation/creative expression,it would appear that things have come full circle to the point where "No bling is the new bling".

Speaking as a lifelong metalworker and MC enthusiast I`m glad to see that the TV viewers may finally be getting that "choppers" got their name from chopping all the BS off a bike rather than piling even more BS on,no matter how tricky and/or highly polished that BS may be.

I tend to brew my own coffee at home and on the rare occasion I buy it brewed by others I look at where the truckers get it.It tends to be cheap there and the buzz lasts far longer than any of the residual aftertaste from a gourmet blend.

Remember,You`re talking to someone who finds it acceptable to put a pinch of freeze dried coffee between his cheek and gum when working to meet a deadline. :O

Re: The meaning of handcrafted

#5

David Barnett

Arabica -- drug of choice

David Barnett

"... I look at where the truckers get it.It tends to be cheap there and the buzz lasts far longer than any of the residual aftertaste from a gourmet blend."

That's because lower grade beans roasted and sold bulk don't always do so well when dark roasted, so more caffeine is retained when given an American roast (an oversimplification -- processing and rates of water loss in roasting, and whether you measure by weight or volume figure into it, as well, but that's the rule of thumb.) At any rate, while it seems like a small difference when measured, it's a difference that makes a difference, as you've found out. And that "residual aftertaste", Bob? Some would call that its finish.

If you roast your own green beans, as I do every two or three days, you could roast for caffeine content. Of course, I just roast for taste and drink more. Just bought another 25 lbs of green Costa Rican hard bean (Tarrazu region). Man, is this stuff good. And at $3.82/lb, it's truckstop cheap. Handcrafted, too. :)

Re: The meaning of handcrafted

#6

Re: Aplly Sophistry now...

TomD

"Is there indeed someone who grinds the beans by hand"

That would be hand powered, not hand made. Even in the world of hand making there is very little that is made by hand, it is a complete nonsense term. So in that sense, they are as accurate in their claims for coffee as anyone else. What is more, where coffee comes from, there is actually some chance there is some hand work involved.

Re: The meaning of handcrafted

#7

David Barnett

Don't need to -- the FTC will do it for you.

David Barnett

"Even in the world of hand making there is very little that is made by hand, it is a complete nonsense term. So in that sense, they are as accurate in their claims for coffee as anyone else."

Actually, for specific industries such as silversmithing and goldsmithing, handmade, handcrafted, and handwrought are regulated trade terms under the FTC, with specific requirements to use those terms legally for trade.

� 23.3 Misuse of the terms "handmade," "handwrought," etc.

(a) It is unfair or deceptive to represent, directly or by implication, that any industry product is handmade or handwrought unless the entire shaping and forming of such product from raw materials and its finishing and decoration were accomplished by hand labor and manually-controlled methods which permit, and finish of each part of each individual product.

NOTE: As used herein, "raw materials" include bulk sheet, strip, wire, and similar items that have not been cut, shaped, or formed into jewelry parts, semi-finished parts, or blanks.

(b) It is unfair or deceptive to represent, directly or by implication, that any industry product is hand-forged, hand-engraved, hand-finished, or hand-polished, or has been otherwise hand-processed, unless the operation described was accomplished by hand labor and manually-controlled methods which permit the maker to control and vary the type, amount, and effect of such operation on each part of each individual product.

"What is more, where coffee comes from, there is actually some chance there is some hand work involved."

Considerable. In the small Costa Rican estate, Hacienda La Minita, that comes to about 30,000 hours every season.

Re: The meaning of handcrafted

#8

Moses Yoder

Re: Roasting your own

Moses Yoder

I would be interested in knowing where you buy your green coffee beans and the process for roasting it if you can take the time sometime. It would be very much apreciated. We have a good convection oven, but I have not found a dependable roasting recipe.

Re: The meaning of handcrafted

#9

At least they're not using their feet

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Re: The meaning of handcrafted

#10

That's at the wine shop.   

wilbur

Re: The meaning of handcrafted

#11

David Barnett

Roasting your own -- hand tool content *LINK*

David Barnett

Moses, there are several low-tech ways to do it, but the method I most recommend for beginners (I prefer it, in fact) is a heat gun and a stainless steel mixing or doggy bowl. This method offers superb control. You can roast just enough for a few cups or a pound at a time, and you'll see exactly what you're doing and how the beans react to each stage of the roast. Ten minutes with a heat gun will teach you a lot.

If you'd rather forego the heat gun, you can try other methods, such as a skillet, oven, or make yourself a nice little hand-powered rotary roaster for small batches over a grill or other simple heat source. Some are as simple as a 48 oz juice can with a crank handle. I do suggest doing this outdoors, though, as it can be a smokey process. Porches and balconies are good. I sit on the lanai.

Oh, and maybe best of all, especially with the heat gun, you can lean right over the roasting beans and breathe the smoke. A good amount of caffeine wafts upwards and the coffee simply smells terrific. Heaven. Your neighbors will quickly befriend you.

As for the beans, Caracolillo Coffee Mill is a great source. It's a third-generation family-owned mill in Tampa with consistent quality, service and they really try to hold the line on coffee prices. They're so accommodating, inasmuch as you can order just one pound or twenty-five, which lets you try different varieties, and there are some amazing ones.

http://www.ccmcoffee.com/index.php?cPath=21

By the way, green beans will last a year or two, so don't be afraid to order enough coffee to save on shipping. They'll keep.

Here's some links to get you started, but feel free to ask me anything.

http://www.homeroaster.com/heatgun.html

http://www.sweetmarias.com/tradition.php

http://www.sweetmarias.com/homemade-homeroasters.php

http://www.breworganic.com/coffee/howtoroast.htm

Here's a great forum for home roasters.


Home Roasting Talk at CoffeeGeek

Re: The meaning of handcrafted

#12

Re: Don't need to -- the FTC will do it for you.

TomD

Cool. Interesting text. Something is hand made if it is - hand made, apparently. Hand controlled would presumably mean milling machine, or grinding on a belt sander, or forging with a 3 story high trip hammer. And I don't think anyone would have a problem with that. Then you go to the Williamsburg gun shop.

The thing is that every tool is jigged to take the variability out of something. From the very simplest tool. So, so long as you can arrange your work so that you proceed in steps where the variable element in a given tool is not a problem at each step, you can make something "by hand" that meets that criterion. Guitar makers are the masters of that. Can be very skilled, and can be workmanship of risk. But there are some very good makers who couldn't change a light bulb without a jig.

So take for example the perfling channel of a guitar body. Even with the best jigs it is a risky business. There are some very fancy jigs to do it. They cut the rebate with ball bearing router cutters, with the guitar and the router held firmly in jigs. It is possible to vary the outcome by simple moving the router backwards, or feeding it too fast forward. Other than the tear out problems, it can be a pretty no-brainer kind of thing. Would certainly meet the hand made criterion.

Re: The meaning of handcrafted

#13

Re: Roasting your own -- hand tool content

TomD

Great info Dave.

Re: The meaning of handcrafted

#15

David Barnett

What can I say? I'm a 'coffee achiever' ...

David Barnett

... and all-round factotum, at your service, sir. As for actually knowing so much stuff, I just make it all up!

Or, "What is no, Alex?"

Re: The meaning of handcrafted

#16

Air Popper

John M in Mid Mich

An oft recommended coffee roasting trick is to use an air-pop popcorn maker. I have been pretty happy with results. Sure does make the house smell like fresh coffee, too. Pour in a half cup of beans, turn it on and watch 'em get darker until where you want them.

Re: The meaning of handcrafted

#17

Re: Arabica -- drug of choice

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

I've been very happy buying roasted beans at my local coop, all of it organic fair trade. I do grind it with a hand crank right before making.

Pam

Re: The meaning of handcrafted

#18

David Barnett

Great for small roasts and can't get much easier

David Barnett

For small and consistent results, you can't beat an air popper. You can still find the legendary West Bend Poppery II at garage sales and thrift stores, but there are a few other models that work quite well.

Some soup them up with variacs, timers and so on, for enhanced roasting profiles, but they work just fine without modification. I like most fluid air roasters (air poppers, heatguns, etc.), but favor the versatility of heatguns and their larger roasting capacities, which comes in handy around Christmas for gift baskets.

It's surprising how many are roasting their own, nowadays. Or maybe not -- it is fun, the coffee's incredible and it sure beats the heck out of high prices for stale 'gourmet' coffee.

Re: The meaning of handcrafted

#19

David Barnett

Handcrafted enough

David Barnett

"Something is hand made if it is - hand made, apparently."

Well, pretty much, in the U.S.A., at least, unless it's explicitly regulated by the FTC. As for woodworking, I don't of a specific ruling by the FTC. The jewelry and metalsmithing regs have been cited in woodworking matters and appear to influence the model for the ACC shows, although it's of dubious enforcement from what I've seen.

The jewelry, silversmithing, pewter trades have a long history of hallmarking, maker's marks and so on, especially in regard to metals contents, and it should be remembered that signed craft work by individual artisans is a relatively recent development in the overall timeline of craftsmanship.

"Hand controlled would presumably mean milling machine, or grinding on a belt sander, or forging with a 3 story high trip hammer. And I don't think anyone would have a problem with that."

I certainly don't. I consider using a flex shaft tool to be a hand tool. Not a hand powered tool, obviously, but a hand tool nevertheless. Same for a Lindsay AirGraver, too. Anything that can bite you, ruin your workpiece or destroy the tool is risky enough to count for something.

"The thing is that every tool is jigged to take the variability out of something. From the very simplest tool."

Or pretty much can be, replicating the action through some other mechanical means. Files, gravers, and so on, all have jigged versions or power equivalents, right.

"So, so long as you can arrange your work so that you proceed in steps where the variable element in a given tool is not a problem at each step, you can make something "by hand" that meets that criterion."

At least for jewelry, though, under the FTC guidelines, the jigging cannot supersede the hand-guided finesse that makes it handwrought. As most interpret it, you must retain and have control of all variable elements, inasmuch as any jigging must not remove the human control, or "workmanship of risk", in Pye's term, from the making process.

Guitar makers are the masters of that. Can be very skilled, and can be workmanship of risk. But there are some very good makers who couldn't change a light bulb without a jig.

"So take for example the perfling channel of a guitar body. Even with the best jigs it is a risky business. There are some very fancy jigs to do it. They cut the rebate with ball bearing router cutters, with the guitar and the router held firmly in jigs. It is possible to vary the outcome by simple moving the router backwards, or feeding it too fast forward. Other than the tear out problems, it can be a pretty no-brainer kind of thing. Would certainly meet the hand made criterion."

Good example and a good problem. I'll agree, even a Williams-type binding jig requires mastery and coordination and can be scary enough for early builds, while the usual trim router or Dremel jig is even trickier still. I'm more comfortable with a gramil and chisel. All tools and methods require mastery and skill, and you can screw up with any of them. It's plenty tricky and fiddly enough without worrying about whether or not it is handcrafted.

Re: The meaning of handcrafted

#20

David Barnett

Pam, Pam, Pam, Pam, Pam. Fair trade?

David Barnett

Aside from the added price, pennies though it may be, would you really deprive me of my simple pleasure? Of pondering, remembering, imagining those peasants toiling, as is their lot, in the coffee plantations, as nature surely intends, dreary though it may be?

But toil of serf and sweeper--

The tale of common things.

Have we not sacrificed enough already to our oppressive social burden?

The blame of those ye better,

The hate of those ye guard.

Perhaps rereading Kipling might reshape and assuage your guilt-ridden notions. I, for one, will never cave to fatuous and quixotic modernity. :)

Re: The meaning of handcrafted

#21

Chris Scholz

Handcrafted Pasta???

Chris Scholz

Went to a well-know Italian-style chain restaurant in Irvine tonight. What do you know, they sever "handcrafted pasta".

I don't know, are they following me? Too much "handcrafted" in one day for my taste...

Re: The meaning of handcrafted

#22

David, David, David....

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

I wonder if suggesting that we pay the people who work for us a living wage is political? Maybe not if they're in a different country?

And you are a fairly wealthy fellow, right? Why not lighten up your pockets just a bit? :)

Pam, who loves Kipling and doesn't think he was a racist, as those things went 100 years ago, but does think he could have been somewhat more enlightened

Re: The meaning of handcrafted

#23

I 'Handcraft' my coffee ever morning

Kevin French, Henniker, NH

2/3 of a cup of grounds for 12 cups of water.

My guess is that if you get your coffee for a "barista", that's where you started going wrong.

I like my coffee like I like my bent wood, Hot and Steamy.

Re: The meaning of handcrafted

#24

Re: Handcrafted enough

TomD

My favorite hand tool for boat building is a 7 inch disc grinder, you can bark back anything with that baby. OK favorite is a bit much, but it can be nice with big hearing protectors and enough of a cross breeze. :)

Re: The meaning of handcrafted

#25

David Barnett

"Gardens are not made by singing... "

David Barnett

... "Oh, how beautiful," and sitting in the shade.--RK", Pam.

"I wonder if suggesting that we pay the people who work for us a living wage is political? Maybe not if they're in a different country?"

I was being somewhat tongue-in-cheek, of course. A living wage, then. But just so.

"And you are a fairly wealthy fellow, right? Why not lighten up your pockets just a bit?"

Not so much these days as before, mind you. But I'm quite comfortable, yes -- far more so than most of the world. Hey, there's an idea! I could have the Horatio Alger stories translated into Spanish and sell... okay... give them away to all those needy little beggars. Now how inspiring would that be?

"Pam, who loves Kipling and doesn't think he was a racist... "

Certainly not for Victorian times, no.

You Lazarushian-leather Gunga Din!

Though I've belted you and flayed you,

By the livin' Gawd that made you,

You're a better man than I am, Gunga Din!

Actually, the poem from which I quoted earlier was a stern warning to America following our Philippines annexation, to avoid Britain's mistakes in India.