New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Wet wheel grinders and diamond dressing tools *LINK*

Posts

Wet wheel grinders and diamond dressing tools *LINK*

#1

Wet wheel grinders and diamond dressing tools *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

After the lively discussion of honing systems the last few days, I am creeping out of cover very carefully on this one...

Years ago, frustrated by my inability to grind edge tools on my bench grinder without turning them blue, I bought a Delta 10" wet wheel grinder (pictured below). Delta no longer offers these, and they seem not to have been very popular; but some of the import companies like Grizzly were offering them for a while, so there are some out there. I offer the following experience for anyone who happens to have one of these or a similar wet grinder.

The main virtue of wet grinders - the steel stays cool - has a matching flaw: they're slow as a turtle in a Minnesota January. I recently discovered, though, that a diamond dressing tool (I bought the multi-diamond item Lee Valley offers, linked below) roughs up the stone so well that grinding happens much more quickly. Still not as quickly as a bench grinder, but close enough that I'm no longer going to be depressed when I realize I need to regrind a bevel.


img

example of diamond dressing tool

Re: Wet wheel grinders and diamond dressing tools *LINK*

#2

Re: Wet wheel grinders and diamond dressing tools

wilbur

Roughing up the surface definitely helps with a Tormek as well. The other thing that helps on a Tormek, which may or may not be possible on a Delta wet grinder, is to make sure that the wheel is turning into the tool. On a Tormek, it can be set up so that the wheel is turning into or away from the tool, depending on how it's set up.

Here's a copy of a post I did last year on another forum with some real world data on how quick a wet grinder may or may not be.

-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-

I have a Tormek, and I've used it to grind down chisels and plane blades. It is slower than a dry wheel grinder at removing metal, but it may not be as slow as you think.

I've figured out some ways to optimize a Tormek for removing metal quickly, such as when you have a nick in a chisel to get out. Here's what I found, cribbed from a post I made back in April.

The first thing to do is to get the Tormek as optimized as it can be for removing larger quantities of metal. The best way I've found to do this is redress the stone wheel. This picture will show that I'm just as bad as anyone about letting the wheel get loaded up with metal as anyone, and may be a big reason why some of us are reporting results that are slower than what we would want.


The next thing to do is find a victim. I have one antique plane blade that could use refurbushing, but it doesn't really have a nick -- just a bevel angle that is much too shallow for my taste. So I decided to sacrifice a 3/4" Marples chisel. I took my chisel and banged on the concrete floor of my basement, and various other hard objects to try to get it dull.


I put the chisel into the straight edge jig (the older one), set up for a 25� bevel angle, and started grinding with the wheel turning towards the tool. I used a fair amount of pressure on the tool. This is what I got after about 2-1/2 minutes.


So all the nicks were gone after just a few minutes. Of course, one might argue that this isn't a huge amount of damage. So I decided to mess up my chisel some more. This is what I did to it:


Japanese chisel vs. western chisel. This was the outcome:


These nicks are about 1/16" deep. I set up the jig again, and this took me about 4 minutes to do:


I then used the fine stone conditioner on the wheel of the Tormek to convert it into a finer grit stone, and got this in about 30 seconds:


And I get endgrain shavings off of Douglas fir like this:


Now, normally I would take the tool from the rough grinding stage and go to my waterstones to hone an edge.

Again, I want to emphasize that I don't think that this is faster than using a dry wheel grinder, and that you should use the tool most appropriate for the job. It just so happens that I don't have a dry wheel grinder. Some may also think that the amount of time that I spent on these operations is too long, but I can live with it.

At least we now have some numbers to discuss. 4 minutes for a 1/16" nick. Extrapolating, that's 8-10 minutes of Tormeking for a 1/8" nick. Whether that's too slow is up to you.

Re: Wet wheel grinders and diamond dressing tools *LINK*

#3

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Wet wheel grinders and diamond dressing tools

Jesper, Denmark

There seems to be an almost fanatical attitude of Tormek Grinder owners about the virtues of their tool. For my money, it's too slow for dressing turning tols and the need for dressing the wheel with the diamond is the same for both wet and dry grinders.

I use a Baldor slow speed - originally 1725 rpm, but here on 50 Hertz, it is now down to a little under 1500 rpm. One blue and one white 8" wheel, both around 100 grit. A Oneway jig on one for turnng gouges and an extended flat guide on the other seems tobe both quick and accurate.

Sharpening - or re-grinding chisels and plane blades is quick and easy. Having a small tub of water to dip the end of the chisel occasionally takes care of the heat.

The dry grinder doea make a mess with dust, and I am afraid to connet it to the dust/chip collection system for fear of sparks igniting something. This is not a problem with a Tormek, but there must be a need fo cleaning out the water tub.

Re: Wet wheel grinders and diamond dressing tools *LINK*

#4

Re: Wet wheel grinders and diamond dressing tools

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

My Tormek is only used on the 220 grit setting, that is, I do not regrade the stone to 1000. What is the point? I want the Tormek to shape a primary bevel - I will use waterstones to refine this.

Now the Tormek may be slow compared to a dry grinder, but the speed is certainly improved by ensuring the stone's surface is clean. The diamond dresser is an essential tool, and should be used regularly. Grinding O1 is relatively quick, while A2 is reasonably so. I have even used the Tormek wheel to complete the hollow created by my 8" half-speed grinder on CPM 3V steel. The key at all times is a clean wheel at the coarsest setting.

The relative slow speed of grinding, however, is compensated for by the increased speed in subsequent honings. Less steel to hone means less time in honing. The advantage of the wet grinder is that one can grind to the edge of the blade without endangering the temper of the steel. Further, the 10" circumference of the Tormek creates a shallow hollow, so the reinforcement to the edge remains. A dry grinder forces one to leave at least 1/16" at the edge, usually much more.

From the Tormek I move to a 1000 Shapton. The refined primary bevel only requires 1-2 strokes. Further, subsequent resharpening of the edge also requires much less time on the stones that would be the case on a wider bevel.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Wet wheel grinders and diamond dressing tools *LINK*

#5

Wilbur! You're one bent...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

Mother F*%$er :D

And to think, I ground my Marples' into skews.

How stupid can I be!?! :b

Re: Wet wheel grinders and diamond dressing tools *LINK*

#6

Bent and fanatical

wilbur

Not really. ;)

The main reasons I did this was because: [1] I needed to sharpen that chisel anyway, and (b) I was tired of comments like, "The Tormek is too slow" without any sort of quantification. There seems to be a fanatical need for non-Tormek users to exaggerate what the Tormek cannot do, and the attitudes of Tormek owners.

As I said above, I want to emphasize that I don't think that a Tormek is faster than using a dry wheel grinder, and that you should use the tool most appropriate for the job. It just so happens that I don't have a dry wheel grinder. Some may also think that the amount of time that I spent on these operations is too long, but I can live with it. And I have reshaped turning gouges made of CPM successfully with a Tormek. It took a good while to do so, but as Derek noted, subsequent honings go very quickly.

But at least we now have some numbers to discuss. 4 minutes for a 1/16" nick. Whether that's too slow is up to you.

By the way, it is true that the water tub needs cleaning. I take it into the backyard and hit it with the hose about twice a year. Better than inhaling grinder wheel and metal dust.

Re: Wet wheel grinders and diamond dressing tools *LINK*

#7

Re: Wet wheel grinders and diamond dressing tools

TomD

I thought this was going to be an injunction to rub diamonds onto the water stone!

Three things will make it impossible to burn your tools:

Clean wheel

For a regrind to take a chip out, grind the chip out at 90 degrees first

dip the tool into water, and grind it until the water starts to visibly lessen, then dip and repeat. Not always necessary, but it will keep you out of trouble with really sensitive steel.

Do those three things and you can toss the tormek. Better still get a belt sander.