New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Sharpening - feel good sentiment

Posts

Sharpening - feel good sentiment

#1

Sharpening - feel good sentiment

TomD

Just thinking about the sharpening wars below. I got a shock a year or so ago, when I was reading one of the knife forums. It was the Canadian section of the forum, that often deals with border issues since the desirable product is often in the US. The thread I was reading was all about how difficult it was for knife owners up here to get their knives sharpened at the factory. I was floored. I didn't realize that a significant proportion of knife owners, I mean the custom knife hobbyists, not just householders, couldn't sharpen a knife!! Knife sharpening used to be tricky, but a very serviceable job can be done with crock sticks, and the job becomes one of the simplest.

So take a second to pat yourself on the back, if you have mastered the art of sharpening anything!

Re: Sharpening - feel good sentiment

#2

Re: Sharpening - feel good sentiment

Bruce, a MN Galoot

One knife-making forum I read talked about that as well and someone stated that some of his customers just got a new knife when the first one got dull. At a couple hundred bucks a pop, I think it would be in someone's interest to just learn the ropes.

Re: Sharpening - feel good sentiment

#3

Re: Sharpening - feel good sentiment

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

It doesn't hurt to have a few duplicates when starting out. :)

Pam

Re: Sharpening - feel good sentiment

#4

Those must be the same people...

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

...who wear clothes once then donate them to the thrift store where my wife volunteers, rather than cleaning them.

Good for those of us who know how washing machines work - thanks to her work there, we've got the best wardrobes we've ever had.

But still weird.

Re: Sharpening - feel good sentiment

#5

Still weird but...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

I can barley sharpen a kitchen knife. I can but the time involved... :\

A pane blade, chisel, gouge is another story.

I could cut my own spiral cut ham... :D

Re: Sharpening - feel good sentiment

#6

Re: Sharpening - feel good sentiment

bugbear

The thread I was reading was all about how difficult it was for knife owners up here to get their knives sharpened at the factory. I was floored. I didn't realize that a significant proportion of knife owners, I mean the custom knife hobbyists, not just householders, couldn't sharpen a knife!!

About the only thing that makes sense to me is if you want a cosmetically perfect uniform mirror bevel on a convex bladed knife with a tightly radiused tip.

That is way hard.

Or you're nervous of a single stray stroke on the stone mussing up a damascus, or engraved, or mirror'd blade surface.

Almost anything else the end user should be able to manage.

BugBear

Re: Sharpening - feel good sentiment

#7

right on Tom

roninkokomo

It is alarming how fast some pretty basic skills are disappearing.

Re: Sharpening - feel good sentiment

#8

Lost

Kenneth Martin Sacramento

I remember my dad telling me that if you are lost in the woods all you need are a knife and a stone. You sit down and start sharpening the knife and someone will come along and tell you "you are doing it wrong" then you ask them for directions out.

Maybe that's not so true anymore.

Ken

Re: Sharpening - feel good sentiment

#9

Modern equivalent

Bob Hackett

You sit stoning the knife till someone comes along and asks "What are you doing to that knife?".

Then you use his cell phone with GPS tracking system to call for help,put the dull knife away and surf the web while waiting for the helicopter to show up. :D

Re: Sharpening - feel good sentiment

#10

Or...

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

As Alfred Lord North Whitehead, inventor of social psychology, was fond of saying: I never understood why someone lost in the forest always asked "Where am I?" when the only pertinent question is "Where are all the others?"

Pam

Re: Sharpening - feel good sentiment

#11

Re: Or...

TomD

That sounds like a Wig. I mostly know people who if lost in the woods, don't want to find other people. :)

Re: Sharpening - feel good sentiment

#12

Re: Sharpening - feel good sentiment

TomD

I got a letter from my sister today, by coincidence. It came with some good news, and a backhanded insult. She mentioned she had finally bought a steel, and learned to sharpen a knife. She was delighted how simple is was, given how hard I had always made it look. I don't really get that, since for knives I mostly use those ceramic sticks.

Re: Sharpening - feel good sentiment

#13

I used ceramic sticks for years UNTIL

Bruce, a MN Galoot

My brother gave me a Henckels diamond steel. It's more for sharpening than a traditional steel and it absolutely works wonders.


Re: Sharpening - feel good sentiment

#14

There`s still hope for me then

Bob Hackett

Here I thought I`d never own one of those incredible high dollar pattern welded blades because they are just not in my budget.Nice to know all I have to do is wait till they get dull and useless and then I can probably pick one up from the side of the road.

I`m assuming single shot hunting rifles are not big sellers up there.

Re: Sharpening - feel good sentiment

#15

  And what's a "Wig?"

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Re: Sharpening - feel good sentiment

#16

Re: Sharpening - feel good sentiment

Phil Smith

"I was floored. I didn't realize that a significant proportion of knife owners, I mean the custom knife hobbyists, not just householders, couldn't sharpen a knife!! Knife sharpening used to be tricky, but a very serviceable job can be done with crock sticks, and the job becomes one of the simplest."

Do you mean a knife like one of these?


My brother makes these all of the time and sells to local knife collectors and enthusiast down in Ga. He learned the craft from knife maker in Ark. They are wickedly sharp and stay sharp for a long time. Edge is put on with belt sander followed by series of buffing wheels with different compounds. The edge is a convex profile which gives it good durability as well as good edge.

The steel is for this knife is CPM S30V, but he also makes them out of CPM 3V and other particle steels. No way will you sharpen one of these with a ceramic croc.

I can understand why some folks will have difficulty if they buy any of the high performance knives and don't also learn to use diamond or go to power strop with the appropriate buffing compound.

Re: Sharpening - feel good sentiment

#17

Re: I used ceramic sticks for years UNTIL

TomD

The ceramic sticks are just for honing, and the set I have has a course for doing heavier work. Some of those are diamond sticks. That big one looks like the business.