New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Absolutely the end of the build.

Posts

Absolutely the end of the build.

#1

Absolutely the end of the build.

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

It began with the attempt to retread a set of coopered doors into curved sides for an end table.

It looked like this...



There were issues with the different colour woods on the front, and the top looked too thick.

So mods were made, and the front became one panel, which added a curve to soften the look, and the top received stronger bevels at the sides.


But when it came to using this new panel I found it did not work. It was too thin and would flex if used as a false panel. I almost threw it in and decided to return to the original drawer. In fact I built and fitted a new pull (having cut off the original one).

It is not as though this table was that important. It was more of an experiment in building with curves. In fact, my priority was an entertainment centre. The coopered doors were for the original design. And it was not as if I was not already busy enough with the final design for the entertainment centre - this was to be two Military Chests in Jarrah, each 900mm long, to be used side-by-side. I have been working on the panels and have thicknessed, jointed and glued up enough panels for the carcases ...


But I couldn't leave it alone. And so once more into the fray!

I made a thicker panel, twice as thick, and retained the original drawer. The top was widened - this served two purposes: it added more overhang at the front (and a slightly deeper bevel, and it became possible to curve the front of the top in sympathy with the curve of the front panel.

I chose a darler wood for the front, partly to link in with the darker section of the top, and partly as a contrast to the sides.

I am not changing anything! :)


The offending front drawer (note that the pull is now centred in the panel) ...



The widened and curved top along with the curved to the front panel ...


Last one ..


I will post a pictorial on my website in due course - fitting the panel and building a pull.

Thanks for all the critiques along the way. I hope that some got something out of this build-along.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Absolutely the end of the build.

#2

The evolution of a really nice design

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Your openness about the design and redesign of this piece has been great, Derek. It's healthy for all of us to see how the design struggle goes, and I think your final design is markedly better than any of the intermediate stages. Of course, that may be because you included some of my suggestions...no, I think it would be true anyway.

I'm intrigued by how well the drawer pull location works with drawer closed or open; its placement about 2/3 of the way up the drawer front looks very right when the drawer's opened.

I've been unable to get to furniture with all the house refurbishment that's consumed me since retirement (before which, between job, care of parents, and house maintenance, there wasn't much time for furniture either); but I've got a notebook full of ideas, and your open discussion of problems and solutions has been inspiring and comforting. I know that, when I start to act on some of my ideas, it will be OK to struggle; and OK to bring my problems to this cracker barrel for consultation.

Re: Absolutely the end of the build.

#3

Re: The evolution of a really nice design

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Thank you Bill. You are generous with your praise. The truth is, we learn more from our responses to mistakes than from our successes. I learn something new with every project.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Absolutely the end of the build.

#4

Re: Absolutely the end of the build.

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I wouldn't have thought that design by committee would be a good option :) , but you started with a very good basis. The final design is even better. I also originally thought that the drawer needed no pull at all but have changed my opinion. You understated approach complements the overall design very well.