New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Japanese chisels?

Posts

Japanese chisels?

#1

Japanese chisels?

TomD

They got the memo, but not the form. The decided to do their rendition of a blister pack chisel.

http://dick.biz/product/710838/Damascus-Hybrid-Chisels-6-piece-set/detail.jsf

Re: Japanese chisels?

#2

Chris Scholz

Re: Japanese chisels?

Chris Scholz

Not Damascus steel of course but folded steel, very low layer count and strong etching (clear sign of inferior quality).

Nevertheless I am glad to see more of the folded steel making it's way to the West. Probably a very usable set of chisels.

Re: Japanese chisels?

#3

Re: Japanese chisels?

David Weaver

I can't think anything flattering looking at those. They're blue steel but only hardened to 61, which itself isn't really a problem, I guess, but blue steel is very durable at 64. Is it 61 because they are lacking the hollow in the back? If so, that's not a tradeoff I'd want - I hope they are extremely flat without the hollow, even at that hardness. LN chisels out of flat would be a bear for a new user to flatten.

Second, the lamination appears to be straight across. The only chisels I've seen like that are reform grade japanese chisels (like the grizzly chisels, etc).

At the equivalent of $380 for the chisels, I'm just not feeling it, but I guess they are a compromise to sell japanese chisels to people who want western chisels.

Wait until someone puts them on a power grinder and then complains that they're soft.

Re: Japanese chisels?

#4

Re: Japanese chisels?

TomD

If you want to power grind Japanese chisels, that would be these guys:

http://dick.biz/product/718937/Cabinetmakers-HSS-Chisels/detail.jsf

The second set of Japanese chisels I bought was a HSS set from Mahogany Masterpieces. They are as a good a set of chisels as I have ever found, awesome sharpening pottential. Can be dry ground, but I always hand sharpen then except for the odd accident. I've bought some good/expensive chisels over the years.

I have a HSS plane kanna and it isn't the same quality, so it isn't always the case, but it can be an excellent option in steel.

Re: Japanese chisels?

#5

Re: Japanese chisels?

David Weaver

What do you sharpen them with, have you been using standard waterstones, or have you been using diamond?

I bought my last "expensive" set of chisels just before the full HSS chisels started coming out in droves. I dry grind western chisels, but I don't mind hand honing japanese chisels because by and large, they get dull and don't get dinged or rolled over edges or anything else where you have to spend much time on a medium stone or more coarse.

I have some HSS planes, no kanna, though. I am impressed by their ability to stay sharp enough to use for a really really long time, and not rust - which makes them nice to keep at the bench in my unheated shop.

Re: Japanese chisels?

#6

Re: Japanese chisels?

TomD

Typically I sharpen Japanese tools in accordance with their tradition. My current shop is cold in the winter, and about the time I moved into it I was giving seminars, and got into carrying sand paper for touch ups, so I wouldn't have to take a lot of time out to sharpen. Obviously I would arrive with sharp tools, but one never knows... Next thing I was using sand paper because of the cold shop, wet hands not being much fun, and frozen stones worse. Then I experimented with oil stones, and recently diamonds.

I prefer to use the water stones, because they give crisper results. I don't find the diamonds on cast iron plates are as level as a proper stone. Half way like a strop. They are fast, but in a world of 350 dollar chisels, more or less, what is the point to not sharpening them properly. At some point you just need to go dry grind and buff if you go far enough down the sharpening speed path. One wants to savour every inch of the precious steel. But as others have pointed out, this becomes a hobby beyond practical use.

But anyway, for the various confusing zigs and zags above, I find myself using the full waterstone routine only in the summer these days. I also find that I more and more am making customs tools out of O1 and that I power sharpen them.