New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Changing my mind again ...

Posts

Changing my mind again ...

#1

Changing my mind again ...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I received many valuable comments when I posted pictures of the coopered end table, one of which I have definitely decided to impliment, and the others I am in the process of testing out.

The main criticisms were that the top looked a little thick, that the front rail was a different colour to the drawer (it came from the same board as the side rails, but turned out lighter than expected), and that the drawer was too small for the design.


The first modification was to increase the bevel to the sides of the top. There was no point in altering the front and rear bevels as there was not enough area to make a difference (and in any event it probably would not show when looking down).


A sharp A2 blade in a scrub plane works amazingly well ...


The second modification aimed to kill two birds with one stone. I would add a false panel to the front of the table. This would cover the rail and drawer. Instead of a drawer pull, the drawer would open from the underside, thus leaving a clean front to the table. In addition, I decided to create a curved front panel. This would be a subtle curve, but should add a softness that I felt was lacking in the original front panel.

Note that the following is a work-in-process and, therefore, I am looking for comments - a good idea or not, and why?

The curved front panel was roughed out on the bandsaw and then shaped with a skew block plane (across the grain) ...


The front panel is attached with hot glue, so this area can be reversed.

So, smoothed and oiled, this is the result of reshaping.


A couple of full size pics:

In the first, the panel is sawn for the drawer front ...


In the next one you can see the subtle curve to the front.


And a last one of the top ..


Another question: what is your opinion whether the drawer needs a pull, as in the original, or a recess for a grip as I suggest.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Changing my mind again ...

#2

Re: Changing my mind again ...

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I think it looks a little barren without a pull; but this is one of those areas in which people's tastes vary. It needs, at any rate, something there, I think, to signal that there's a drawer.

Having introduced that subtle curve to the "apron," should you be thinking about a curve to the front of the top?

I am now thinking that this could easily turn into one of those projects where you, metaphorically, cut off the chair legs in turn, aiming to get the chair level, until you have a footstool...

Re: Changing my mind again ...

#3

Gotta agree with Bill

Bob Hackett

I think it would look better if you curved the front edge of the top to echo the drawer front.

The solid,slightly curved front is an excellent improvement IMO.

Re: Changing my mind again ...

#4

I like the changes

Dan Donaldson

Especially the front/drawer treatment. To me, I think it looks better without a pull, just a clean front. That way the drawer is a surprise addition and not integral to the "look" I like the simple lines better.

(of course, what do I know? ;-))