New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Bevel angles in high angle BD plane

Posts

Bevel angles in high angle BD plane

#1

Bevel angles in high angle BD plane

Dave Mount

Hello all -- been a while since I posted, but I've been around in lurk mode.

I bought one of the Lee Valley woodie replacement plane irons (3/16" thick, no cap iron) with the idea of making a fairly high angle (like 55 degrees) bevel down wood smoother for cleaning up difficult grain. It isn't as though there is no other way to accomplish the task, it was just a combination of a need and an excuse to build a new plane instead of doing other things that are higher on the "ought to do" scale but lower on the amusement scale.

Right after I ordered the iron, there was a snippet of discussion here about whether cap irons helped stabilize the cutting edge of thick irons. As I recall, there was not uniform agreement as to whether they did or didn't. As I understood the "camps", folks that thought that cap irons help even on thick blades argued that out at the cutting edge the projecting angle of steel is the same as in a thin iron, and that a cap iron therefore helped support even thick irons. Others thought that the greater mass back from the cutting edge still helped to stabilize the cutting edge.

Regardless of which view is most correct (I'm suspecting the truth may be in the middle), it got me thinking about whether, in the absence of a cap iron, there would be benefit to increasing the bevel angle in a high angle bevel down plane like the one I'm contemplating. The theory would be that doing so would put more metal closer to the cutting edge and avoid having it cantilevered as far out in front of the bed. Even if you went as high as 40 degrees on the bevel, there would still be 15 degrees of clearance, which is plenty as I understand it.

Does this make any sense and/or is there some other factor which comes into play that negates whatever benefit might come from a steeper bevel? Is a 40 degree bevel any less "sharp" if it is honed to the same extent a shallower bevel is?

Best,

Dave

Re: Bevel angles in high angle BD plane

#2

craigd

Re: Bevel angles in high angle BD plane

craigd

I personally like 55�-60� for a cutting angle and have several woodies at those (HNT Gordon). I also have metal planes at 45-55� (BD & BU). I tend to use 1/4" or 1/8" irons. I don't use a cap iron for anything over 1/8" and dislike them, except they do make good depth adjusters (they collect sweat between the cap and the iron and rot the iron).

I use a 30� bevel angle for plane irons and think there is more benefit to solidly bedding the iron down towards the mouth, for wedged irons, this would mean mounting the wedge pin/plate low so that the wedge really presses down on the iron. Of course, at 3/16" it probably won't make much difference.

You could always use a back bevel to reduce the cantilever, say 30+10 (and using a lower bed angle). I, for one, would be interested in how it works.

Re: Bevel angles in high angle BD plane

#3

Re: Bevel angles in high angle BD plane

Bob Hackett

It is my understanding that the angle of the bevel needs to be just enough for clearance between the iron and the wood.What the wood "sees" as far a sharpness goes is the angle you bed the iron at.

If you are curious as to if a steeper bevel angle will help support the edge and the overall performance and longevity of that edge then I would think the answer would be to grind it to the steeper angle and see if it effects both the performance of the plane and your ability to resharpen/restore the edge effectively.

If there are no negative effects then why not continue at the steeper grind?If nothing else it will cut your time at the grinder.

Re: Bevel angles in high angle BD plane

#4

Re: Bevel angles in high angle BD plane

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Dave

I have one of these A2 3/16" wide LV blades in an infill smoother I built. It has a hollow ground bevel of 35 degrees .... but then it is a BU plane with a 25 degree bed. The point is that the blade takes a keen edge and holds it pretty well even at this high angle. Excellent blade!

I think 30 degrees would be optimal for a BD smoother with an A2 blade. I have a couple of HNT Gordon planes, which have 1/4" thick "tool steel" (O1) blades and are bedded at 60 degrees. These come standard with a 30 degree bevel.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Bevel angles in high angle BD plane

#5

Optimum Bevel Angles

Steve Elliott

Dave,

Your proposed plane sounds like a useful one. With a 55 degree cutting angle and a 3/16� thick blade I doubt that a chipbreaker would add anything at all to the plane�s performance. Getting the wedge to fit well should prevent any tendency of the blade to chatter.

There will likely be some small differences in edge performance and retention that depend on the angle the blade is sharpened at, with the worst problems showing up if the angle is too acute. By looking at a worn edge under magnification you�ll be able to see whether the blade has chipped in use. If it has, you�ll want to increase the bevel angle until the blade doesn�t chip at all. I�d guess that an A2 blade used at 55 degrees will need at least a 32 degree angle but won�t require an angle greater than 35. If the angle is larger than needed (say 40 degrees) even a well-honed edge won�t �feel� quite as sharp or slice into the edge of a piece of paper as well or cut thread with as little force. This doesn�t mean that it won�t plane well, but it�s likely to lose its clearance angle a little faster. As a less-acute edge wears away its cutting surface becomes wider more quickly than an edge with a more acute angle. I�ve done some controlled tests on this and found the smaller angles to provide a noticeable but not dramatic increase in edge life. I�d post a link to the page on my website but right now my site seems to be down.

Re: Bevel angles in high angle BD plane

#6

Re: Thanks all

Dave Mount

Thanks all for your thoughts. Sounds like just trying it where it is and screw with it if there's a need. I had a temporary brain cramp thinking that changing the bevel angle would affect the mouth opening, but quickly got my geometry back in line.

Shavings pics to follow when finished.

Best,

Dave