New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

I know. Don't buy sets. Sound advice, but... *LINK*

Posts

I know. Don't buy sets. Sound advice, but... *LINK*

#1

David Barnett

I know. Don't buy sets. Sound advice, but... *LINK*

David Barnett

... you can't buy these carving tools any other way. At these prices, though, it might not matter, even if you don't use but half of them.

One thing, if you're looking for traditional Western gouges with traditional sweeps and profiles, these might not be for you. Some Western carvers use specific sweeps and sizes for carving specific features, when carving formal alphabets, for example. This doesn't bother me, but I do my own lettering styles and find the fishtail shapes to be exceptionally versatile for getting into corners and serifs.

I have these gouges, recommended them before, liked them a lot when I first tried them and like them even more now. I also paid more than what they currently sell for in the U.S., and a good deal more than the price Dick Fine Tools (Germany) is asking. Yes, you'll need to make your own handles (but you can do this without a lathe -- only the socket plugs need be round), but no handles means less shipping weight. And yes, you'll need to do some edge refinement, but I can tell you, these gouges sharpen beautifully.

Nora Hall told me about these in the '90s and I asked her to find me a set. I paid about 160 dollars for the socketed gouges, with adequate (but just so) handles. These are now sold as the socketed sculpting set, but are entirely versatile for all types of work.

Later, I added the detailing set from another seller at about the same price. The selection of these smaller pointed-tang tools differs somewhat from the carving set offered by Dick and reviewed by Whittington. Mine had several tools explicitly for background excavation (with no Western equivalents to my knowledge) and include no wide gouges whatsoever, but I'd buy them at this price if I didn't already own the others.

To compare, the similar Wood Carver's Supply version of the sculptor's set (with handles, tool roll and some edge refinement) sells for $199.95 http://tinyurl.com/WCSscupting, and a detailing set (different, as described above) also sells for $199.95 http://tinyurl.com/WCSdetailing. Even at these higher prices, I consider these Chinese carving tools to be good value.

Anyway, here's links to Iain Whittington's review and to DICK GmbH.

Sculptor's blades, 74.90 � converts to around $100 US:

http://tinyurl.com/ChineseSculptingSet

Carver's blades, 37.40 � converts to around $50 US:

http://tinyurl.com/ChineseCarvingSet

Shipping costs -- see Zone 4 (N. America) via DHL:

http://tinyurl.com/ShippingToZone4

I'd say these tools may need a few supplemental Western tools, such as veiners, and may be better for carver's who've learned to use and sharpen a few Western tools -- these are thin and will require some tuning. They're not perfect, as the reviewer explains, but I sure enjoy mine and would hate to be without them.

Just thought I should pass it along. Next week I'll have to get back to work and I'll likely curtail these recent lengthy and copious postings.


Review of Chinese Carving Tools

Re: I know. Don't buy sets. Sound advice, but... *LINK*

#2

David Barnett

Huh? Whut? Maybe this'll clear it up.

David Barnett

"I also paid more than what they currently sell for in the U.S., and a good deal more than the price is asking."

Should've read:

"I also paid a good deal more in the U.S. than what they currently sell for overseas from Dick Fine Tools (Germany)."

Or something like that. Sheesh.

Re: I know. Don't buy sets. Sound advice, but... *LINK*

#3

Re: Huh? Whut? Maybe this'll clear it up.

TomD

That's really serendipitous. I read your post and thought to myself that those chisels seemed high. I was going to say that it sometimes seems these days that a lot of suppliers are digging in for a lot of profit, since often the wholesale is about 5%. I recalled seeing chinese chisels at Dicks, but for a while now I haven't had their catalog, or been able to call up their site. I had opened another window, and was looking for them. Then I opened another one of your URLs. So thanks for that!

Re: I know. Don't buy sets. Sound advice, but... *LINK*

#4

Ouch, you really got gouged!

TomD

http://dick.biz/product/700970/Chinese-Carving-Blades-18-piece-set/detail.jsf

Admittedly not as tough, but there is a lot of very hard wood over there, these might be OK. Think of them a Flexcuts. I like sockets, but they are relatively less likable if not well formed. Problem with these cheap deals, I feel like buying both. It would be cheaper to start with these than O1 if one wanted some different shapes.

Re: I know. Don't buy sets. Sound advice, but... *LINK*

#5

Re: I know. Don't buy sets. Sound advice, but...

steve mackay

Tell ya' what. Just for fun take a look into The Texas Woodcarver. I think hes on the web and he tours several woodcarving shows around the country. I buy gouges and tools from him singly. I also send off plane irons and knives for him to "save". I've got several specific shapes I thought I'd use, and do. I wouldn't have a use for whole sets. He charges fair prices and fees and hes a really nice guy.

Sorry but, a hundred smackers for gouges I might or might not use or, after I got them, might not even like is awfully steep.

(of course if it were that sweet set from LV I could just look at 'em and feel it worthwhile)

Re: I know. Don't buy sets. Sound advice, but... *LINK*

#6

David Barnett

Hahaha... but Flexcuts actually do flex

David Barnett

These, not so much. Yeah, they're fine on softwoods, basswood, and so on, but surprisingly, I've put them through their paces on some fairly unforgiving woods and haven't had a failure yet.

Re: I know. Don't buy sets. Sound advice, but... *LINK*

#7

David Barnett

$2.70 to $5.55 per gouge is steep?

David Barnett

I've got a pile of gouges older and new, but I actually do like these, and I am a sucker for fishtails, heh.

Re: I know. Don't buy sets. Sound advice, but... *LINK*

#8

Re: $2.70 to $5.55 per gouge is steep?

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Many thanks, David. I've been looking for Chinese chisels for about a year now, not full time, of course, but a saved search on ebay. I'm also a sucker for fishtails.

For the carver's chisels the price is 37.40 �, total vat (might not have to pay this) + shipping is $12; so this seems incredibly cheap. I don't usually buy sets either, but with such a new type tool, for me, it seems prudent to get a lot more than one, once shipping costs are factored in.

But when I tried to check out, I got a complaint from Firefox that it wasn't a secured site. Did this happen to you, too?

Pam

Re: I know. Don't buy sets. Sound advice, but... *LINK*

#9

Re: $2.70 to $5.55 per gouge is steep?

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Hmmm, looks like the security problems disappeared when I reentered via my bookmarks; and I probably was wrong on the VAT/Shipping costs. The chisel cost decreased to 31.43 E. I won't know the shipping until they ship. But still, a great deal.

Pam

Re: I know. Don't buy sets. Sound advice, but... *LINK*

#10

David Barnett

Re: $2.70 to $5.55 per gouge is steep?

David Barnett

I checked and had trouble in Chrome, as well. I went on and entered stubs into the checkout procedure and it failed utterly. Yeah, it's hard to go wrong at these prices. I have no doubt people used to highly polished ready-to-go Western carving tools are put off and suspicious of these, but having used them for years alongside my Western gouges, I would be totally uncomfortable without them.

Re: I know. Don't buy sets. Sound advice, but... *LINK*

#11

VAT

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

We bought some bathroom hardware* from an English firm last year. One person told us we didn't have to pay VAT, another included it in the price until we questioned it. The outcome was that we didn't pay it, because the first person was right. I'm not sure if this is a nation-by-nation practice, or universal in Europe, but it's worth asking about.

*We retained the original doors and locksets (latchsets, actually - no locks) on our bathroom doors when we remodeled them. There's only one company in the U.S. still producing bathroom door locks separate from the lockset, and it's a commercial design, not very suitable for our Queen Anne cottage, requiring a special little key to open from the outside in an emergency. The English company offered, for half the price including shipping, period-looking solid brass locks that can be opened, if need be, with a coin.

Re: I know. Don't buy sets. Sound advice, but... *LINK*

#12

Re: VAT

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Yep, VAT is an in-country tax. I shouldn't necessarily be allowed to post at the end of my day. I didn't have to pay it. :)

Pam

Re: I know. Don't buy sets. Sound advice, but... *LINK*

#13

Chinese chisels final cost

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

OK, as stated, last week I ordered 18 Chinese carving chisels from DICK in Germany for 31E. The shipping costs turned out to be 29E, no VAT, for a total of 60E, or about $80. That works out to $4.44444... per, plus I'll need to refine the edges and make handles.

Pam

Re: I know. Don't buy sets. Sound advice, but... *LINK*

#14

David Barnett

I can live with that -- & some tuning notes

David Barnett

These gouges, as you will soon notice, are thin. Their cutting geometry and lightness, when used properly, give them more of a paring than a chopping feel. Keeping the bevel angles low and consistent on bench stones may be challenging for some, which is why I helped tune up a socketed set for one beginner. It may be useful to pull the gouge across the stone or sandpaper rather than push. A stropping action seems to be easier for most and avoid the very real possibility of gouging a soft water stone. Another challenge is the inside edge of the gouges, especially the smaller ones. Here's two things that helped ease the process.

Firstly, if these will be entirely prepared and sharpened by hand methods, I suggest using sandpaper with a stropping motion (Scary Sharp), being careful not to rotate the angle at the final lift (of course, it shouldn't be either a lift or a drop, but come straight off the abrasive surface). Also, rather than rotating the gouge throughout its entire arc to cover the entire cutting edge on a single pass, just do small portions of the arc, at least at first, and then consolidate these slight facets with single strokes before moving on to the next grit.

I have and prefer to use a 1"x42" belt sander (linisher) to speed things along, with the belt moving away from the edge -- not into it. The Klingspor Gold 120-grit belts are the best for this initial work followed by the 180-grit. Light pressue against a backing pad on the platen, preferably graphite, promotes a smooth but not dubbed result. Obviously, find something other to practice upon than the carving tools before having a go at it.

Honing can proceed once the gouges are ground to shape. I do this by hand. If using waterstones, I suggest a pulling motion, at least at first. On hard stones, Arkansas, India or diamond, push or pull. Avoid diamond stones with perforated surfaces, however -- I prefer EZE-laps or Nortons. Arkansas stones work beautifully on these tools and hard slips are excellent for gouge concavities.

Now I use stropping to keep these tools going from this point, and it takes a lot of carving and stropping before I need to go back to honing, although I might touch up an edge with a hard translucent stone or occasionally, an 8000-grit diamond-charged hard strop. By far, my compound of choice for these tools is Herb Dunkel's Yellowstone. It's dry, not a crayon, and cuts beautifully on this type of steel. One bar seems to last forever. Of course, I bought more, just in case, but I'm still on my first.

Although by now I'm well beyond my two tips, the second one was intended to be the following, so...

Secondly, I sometimes use (and have formerly relied much more upon) shaped strops. No doubt everyone's heard of and many have tried gouging into soft wood and using compound to get a custom-fit honing divot. And others have bent and folded leather with the same intent, both for outside and inside edges, but I have long advocated making inside and outside shaped strops for my most-used tools. To this end I've used almost anything with sufficient plasticity and form-holding properties. Pitch, hard plastiline, wax, Jett-Sett, hot-glue, and combinations of pitch, wax, and various resins (dop wax and diamond-setter's wax), and anything else that seemed worth a try.

Don't pour anything hot enough into your gouge to draw the temper. There's no need. Wait until it's cool enough to the touch to be molded and pressed into the gouge and the gouge into it, the latter being the most common for stropping the bevel, of course. Charge with SiC, CBN, diamond or whatever, let cool, then strop. Works for me.

Some waxes and plastilines can even be charged and remolded until the whole glob eventually becomes abrasive-filled, making it surprisingly convenient (unfortunately, this idea has not yet made me rich).

Lastly, you can leave your tools black as they come from the toolmaker. I did. I like how they look and even like the way they feel. There's really no need to polish the entire tool unless that's your preference.

And lastlier, although matched handles are attractive, I find it much more useful to make handles appropriate to the tools. They're easier to identify as you work. At least use different woods or mark them to make them quickly visible. I also like rounded triangular handles for their ergonomics.

Re: I know. Don't buy sets. Sound advice, but... *LINK*

#15

Re: I can live with that -- & some tuning notes

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Yes, I have absolutely no problems with the price; but then I'm accustomed to buying Japanese chisels, which are appreciably more expensive. The price of the Chinese are more like big lots of old western chisels I bought several years ago when ebay was new, usually about $3-5.

Thanks for all the tuning tips. Some of it introduces some trepidation, but I'll get that under control. :) Probably I'll have plenty of time before they arrive to accumulate stuff.

Pam

Re: I know. Don't buy sets. Sound advice, but... *LINK*

#16

Re: VAT

TomD

Other than the massive tax grab, one of the main purposes of VAT is to add to national competitiveness, by not charging tax on export. Or crippling exports with tax. So in general, you should not be required to pay VAT. The US has a number of domestic focused excise taxes that are not intended to collect revenue from abroad, but that are charged on foreign sales anyway. So for instance, the archery excise tax is 17 percent, and was recently slapped on even cedar dowels. When I buy US stuff, I pay it too, though it is targeted for US conservation expenditures. So sometimes the unfair trade practices the US suffers from are domestic in origin.

Re: I know. Don't buy sets. Sound advice, but... *LINK*

#17

Jesper, Denmark

Re: VAT

Jesper, Denmark

The VAT is essentially an in-country tax, not levied on exports of goods. When selling goods inside the EU from one country to another, it gets a bit more complex. If I buy something in the UK for my personal consumption, the UK VAT is paid as if I went to a store in the UK and paid cash. I then do not have to pay the higher Danish VAT on importing the goods.

If buying something in other countries in the EU as a registered corporation, there is no VAT paid in the country of origin, but the local VAT is paid administratively in your quarterly VAT report to the tax authority. Essentially, you charge and collect VAT on all sales and can deduct any VAT paid on purchases.

Exports to countries outside the EU are exempt from VAT. Companies taht do not regularly export goods to non-EU contries often are confused about this, so if you as a USA resident buy from the EU, you may have to remind tham that they should not charge the VAT.