I know. Don't buy sets. Sound advice, but... *LINK*
David Barnett
... you can't buy these carving tools any other way. At these prices, though, it might not matter, even if you don't use but half of them.
One thing, if you're looking for traditional Western gouges with traditional sweeps and profiles, these might not be for you. Some Western carvers use specific sweeps and sizes for carving specific features, when carving formal alphabets, for example. This doesn't bother me, but I do my own lettering styles and find the fishtail shapes to be exceptionally versatile for getting into corners and serifs.
I have these gouges, recommended them before, liked them a lot when I first tried them and like them even more now. I also paid more than what they currently sell for in the U.S., and a good deal more than the price Dick Fine Tools (Germany) is asking. Yes, you'll need to make your own handles (but you can do this without a lathe -- only the socket plugs need be round), but no handles means less shipping weight. And yes, you'll need to do some edge refinement, but I can tell you, these gouges sharpen beautifully.
Nora Hall told me about these in the '90s and I asked her to find me a set. I paid about 160 dollars for the socketed gouges, with adequate (but just so) handles. These are now sold as the socketed sculpting set, but are entirely versatile for all types of work.
Later, I added the detailing set from another seller at about the same price. The selection of these smaller pointed-tang tools differs somewhat from the carving set offered by Dick and reviewed by Whittington. Mine had several tools explicitly for background excavation (with no Western equivalents to my knowledge) and include no wide gouges whatsoever, but I'd buy them at this price if I didn't already own the others.
To compare, the similar Wood Carver's Supply version of the sculptor's set (with handles, tool roll and some edge refinement) sells for $199.95 http://tinyurl.com/WCSscupting, and a detailing set (different, as described above) also sells for $199.95 http://tinyurl.com/WCSdetailing. Even at these higher prices, I consider these Chinese carving tools to be good value.
Anyway, here's links to Iain Whittington's review and to DICK GmbH.
Sculptor's blades, 74.90 � converts to around $100 US:
http://tinyurl.com/ChineseSculptingSet
Carver's blades, 37.40 � converts to around $50 US:
http://tinyurl.com/ChineseCarvingSet
Shipping costs -- see Zone 4 (N. America) via DHL:
http://tinyurl.com/ShippingToZone4
I'd say these tools may need a few supplemental Western tools, such as veiners, and may be better for carver's who've learned to use and sharpen a few Western tools -- these are thin and will require some tuning. They're not perfect, as the reviewer explains, but I sure enjoy mine and would hate to be without them.
Just thought I should pass it along. Next week I'll have to get back to work and I'll likely curtail these recent lengthy and copious postings.
Review of Chinese Carving Tools




