New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

A new low in diamond sharpening... *LINK*

Posts

A new low in diamond sharpening... *LINK*

#1

David Barnett

A new low in diamond sharpening... *LINK*

David Barnett

... prices, that is. I don't think you'll find a cheaper source for 5 gram syringes of diamond paste, and it's available in six meshes: 360, 600, 1200, 3000, 14000, 50000. I thought it was germane and worth a heads up while diamond is a current topic.

Now this isn't Norton, so the microns may range a bit wider per mesh size*, nor is it the pricier DMT compound, but for everyday sharpening and honing, unless you're set up for microscopy, you're not going to notice or care.

Would I use this for sharpening, honing, and stropping? Sure I would.

Would I use it for carving and polishing gems? No. But I make my own compound in higher diamond concentrations than needed for hand sharpening, and with waxes and oils that work better for rotary tool speeds. And the loose diamond I buy is tightly graded for polishing gems, where it's critical to avoid unexpected scratches.

Daniel Lopacki is one of the good guys, and he has a broad selection of interesting diamond products, including Eastwind diamond discs from 3/4" (at only $1.25 each) to 8" and in fifteen mesh sizes. Fun stuff. Useful.

*Okay, here's the deal. As an example, particles can commonly range from 0 to 2 microns in 14,000 mesh paste, the standard for most diamond compound manufacturers. Imagine a broad bell curve with the larger outliers to one side (the smaller stuff doesn't figure in). As the 2-ish micron particles are friable, when you rub them during honing and stropping, they break down (diamond has perfect cleavage ... never mind ... so it breaks down rather easily when pressure is applied on the cleavage planes). Cheaper diamond compounds may have more particles to either end of this curve. This will never matter for sharpening steel by hand but might require a few more polishing strokes for material that must be perfectly polished, especially by mechanical methods. Synthetic monocrystalline diamond compounds are much more consistent (and expensive) than natural or polycrystalline. Do they make a big difference in sharpening? I don't find so, but now you know the issues.


Diamond paste from Daniel Lopacki

Re: A new low in diamond sharpening... *LINK*

#2

Re: A new low in diamond sharpening...

bugbear

Anyone know the micron sizes for those - I think this is first time I've seen diamond abrasive list via mesh size.

BugBear

Re: A new low in diamond sharpening... *LINK*

#3

David Barnett

Here ya go, Paul. Oops! My bad. *LINK*

David Barnett

Jeff is sadly no longer with us but his helpful website lingers on. Here's a handy chart with equivalents. They may not exactly conform to Lopacki's mesh numbers (360 mesh instead of 325, say), but they're ballpark, as we say on this side of the pond.

You'll often see mesh used in this way, equivalent to grit as in the MSC catalog (Big Book, page 1024, as Mesh Approx). I'm fairly used to seeing it so. Mesh is more properly the micron range of particle sizes.

Daniel probably should've said grit, of course, and I extended his nomenclature in my post. Thanks for questioning this.


How are grit/mesh/micron related and what is what?

Re: A new low in diamond sharpening... *LINK*

#4

Powder?

TomD

How does the powder compare?

In a tube does one know what the diamond content itself is in a tube, and would powder be more economical. Also, one could mix it into whatever carrier one wanted, hand creme, butter, whatever. Any thoughts.

Re: A new low in diamond sharpening... *LINK*

#5

Re: Powder?

anotherBob

Tom, I've ordered powder from http://www.lascodiamond.com/products/dmdpdr.htm a few times now. Did again earlier this week, got an email from them a day later informing me that they were in the process of sending out 20% off coupons to their customers, so they went ahead and gave me a price brake on a couple 25ct vials. I'll go back to them again when I need what they have.

I have only dabbled with diamond powder in the past but picked up a good tip on using it... make a paste/jell out of vasoline thinned with mineral oil to your liking. You can make it as thick or thin as you like, then add the powder and stir.

Re: A new low in diamond sharpening... *LINK*

#6

David Barnett

Works for me *LINK*

David Barnett

I've been corresponding with another diamond aficionado about loose diamond grit and how to compound it.

Firstly, yes -- diamond powder is cheaper and does allow one to adapt the vehicle to the application, which is what I do. Mixing your own compound is simple. But let me tell you about changes in compounding over the last few years.

Olive oil has been the traditional vehicle for most of industrial diamond's history. Diamond was graded by timed settlings in olive oil according to particle masses and measured oil viscosities. Originally, and until recently, diamond grit compound (or paste) used olive oil paste, a byproduct of olive oil distillation. In the last two decades, distillation has been entirely supplanted by the much more efficient, cost-effective and cleaner centrifugal technologies. As a result, olive oil paste, once a cheap and plentiful commodity, has virtually disappeared and is for all practical purposes extinct. Mind you, you can Google olive oil paste, but will find ozonated paste used for it's claimed rejuvenating properties. In fact, the oil fractions used widely in cosmetics are now cold-extracted and have no use as a diamond vehicle.

When I began gem carving, I used olive oil paste as described by Henry Hunt's "Lapidary Carving for Creative Jewelry", 1980, 1993. He says, in the section on Mixing Diamond Compound:

"The virtues of olive oil paste ... has a very high melting point, does not get rancid, is virtually odorless and is not greasy. it is the product of an industrial process involving considerable heat and pressure, and is not in the do-it-yourself class."

When he originally wrote this, diamond powder and compound suppliers sold olive oil paste in syringes for mixing with diamond powder. By the time Henry published "American Lapidary -- designing the carved gemstone" in 1996, he notes that with the disappearance of olive oil paste, carvers making their own higher-concentration compounds generally used Vaseline or floor wax.

"Both of these have serious drawbacks. They liquify at low temperatures, the wax is sticky and cakes when it begins to dry out, and both have an oily and slippery aspect."

"There is a much better solution. You want to obtain a pound of china clay from a ceramics supply store. It costs about a dollar and is enough for the rest of your life. It is a very fine kaolin clay used for making slips and glazes and other things that potters do. You can mix it with Vaseline to make a dry, thick compound, somewhat like toothpaste. To do so empty a small jar of Vaseline into a bowl and start adding powdered clay until all the oiliness disappears. Stir and stir. Now add a little more Vaseline until just a touch of oiliness reappears. Stir this thoroughly, and tthen store in the empty Vaseline jar."

His mixing instructions:

"To make this compound, spoon out what you need into a small container and add the diamond powder. I use one carat of diamond powder for each gram of compound, and usually mix 3 to 4 grams at a time. I use small 4 to 6 gram cosmetic jars to keep each size compound. The compound and diamond powder needs to be thoroughly mixed, lots of stirring, and always start with the finest and work down in order to avoid contamination. The china clay is usually a buff color that turns to a medium brown when mixed with the Vaseline. If you can get a pure white clay, do so. It keeps the surface of the work piece more visible. This material is just as good as the olive oil paste."

Understand that Henry's proportions yield compounds in the medium-high to high concentrations as far as honing goes, which is fine as long as you realize how little you need to charge and maintain your laps. You can certainly use less diamond to make it easier to spread and distribute, and I would recommend this, at least at first.

He goes on to say that he mixes it with as much as 3 carats per gram to speed things up when carving, which is about the concentration I use, nowadays.

I should add that a very well-known lap manufacturer to the faceting industry told me that one producer of top grade diamond compound admits they use hydrolyzed vegetable oil, Crisco, as a main component.

Until yesterday (I kid you not), I had used my dwindling supply of olive oil paste with hardly a thought to replenishment -- I had no idea it had all but disappeared -- but having been asked in private mail about this very subject, I quickly discovered its current scarcity, so reprised Henry's '96 writings on the subject, tried it last night and can say it does indeed perform as he states. I will also say, however, that I prefer the older olive oil paste on hand laps, but enjoy the newer paste on my rotary points and may even grow to like it better.

As for which china clay to use, I'm using Axner's New Zealand kaolin, described as: "From New Zealand China Clays, for use in highest quality tableware where exceptional whiteness and translucency are demanded. Extremely low Fe2O3 & TiO2." I'm sure most any finely ground china clay will suffice, however.

It sells for $2.03/lb, which is a lifetime's supply, but if you actually need more for whatever purpose, it's $1.17 for 5 lbs.

I used Vaseline last evening, but today I'm using a heavier petroleum jelly with a small amount of microcrystalline wax and damar resin.


Axner's New Zealand kaolin

Re: A new low in diamond sharpening... *LINK*

#7

Re: Works for me

anotherBob

David, thanks again! Really appreciate you sharing your knowledge/tips/links. You're gonna keep the postman busy this week. :)

Re: A new low in diamond sharpening... *LINK*

#8

David Barnett

A correction

David Barnett

I corrected an error in the above post. I said olive oil butter where I meant olive oil paste.

Re: A new low in diamond sharpening... *LINK*

#9

David Barnett

Anything to stimulate the economy.

David Barnett

Re: A new low in diamond sharpening... *LINK*

#10

David Barnett

Diamond concentrations in compounds *LINK*

David Barnett

Tom,

You asked how much diamond powder is in a tube. If by tube you mean the vial containing the diamond powder, it will be expressed in carats. There are five carats in a gram by weight, and vials come in different sizes and weights, almost always expressed in carats.

If, as I assume, you meant the amount of diamond contained in a syringe of paste, that can best be expressed by percentage of diamond to the gram weight of aqueous or oil-based vehicle.

A rather simplistic but serviceable approach is taken by Reentel International. They manufacture a high concentration paste aimed at lapidary polishing and pre-polishing, with 20% diamond by weight. Therefore, a 5 gram syringe of any grit will contain 5 carats of diamond and 4 grams, or 20 carats, of vehicle. I consider this a very high concentration for honing and metallographic applications. One can, of course, use it, but lower concentrations may ease the application over laps sized for woodworking tools. Perhaps 3 carats diamond to 22 grams compound would do every bit as well. Even less would probably be fine.

Reentel International says:

"Our diamond paste provides and excellent medium for polishing and pre-polishing all stones. We use high quality powders mixed in a silicon compound to form a paste. Depending on your usage these paste will serve you well and provide that polished shine that you demand. IMPORTANT - We use a high percentage of diamond powder in our compound (20%). Don't be fooled by others with extremely low prices, they will certainly have a very low concentration of powder so you'll end up paying for more for less."

This is as simple as you'll get. Other manufacturers are less informative and up front in their designations. Companies may offer several concentrations, such as Dianamic Abrasive Products:

"Compounds, Paste and Slurries are available in light, medium, heavy, extra heavy and super heavy concentrations. The concentrations by carat weight are the highest available on the market."

Unfortunately, they don't offer what these carat weights actually are.

Some companies have interestingly complex explanations. NDP, or NanoDiamond Products, says:

"Concentration refers to the amount of diamond in the paste. Unlike other NDP products the concentration of diamond in NDP pastes is not stated as a meaningful value. This is due to the significant difference in surface area of nanodiamond and micron diamond and also the different compositions of paste available. Therefore pastes are ordered by diamond weight or carats without stipulating the concentration."

But most manufacturers just state light, medium, heavy or whatever without further explanation.

Really, while one can overdo the diamond concentration, this is easily remedied by diluting until you begin to get slower and less satisfactory results. Add a little diamond and you'll soon be back in business.

I pretty much mix by feel, especially when carving with points or wheels on a fixed arbor or flexshaft. Some stones seem to need more diamond, some less, and this can vary with cutting direction on the same stone. Honing is more straightforward and forgiving. The tendency is to use more diamond than you really need.

Diamond powder is surprisingly reasonable, even cheap, so don't be afraid to try different things.For that matter, diamond pastes seem to last and last. Although I no longer buy pastes, I still have lots and often add more diamond to get the concentrations I routinely need. Most of my diamond charging on laps is done dry, then rolled or pressed into the surface. I mostly use 6" diameter rotating laps for faceting. So I buy diamond as loose grit. The only exception is spray diamond for ceramic laps. This is an example of less is more. You want a very low but even concentration on ceramics.

I guess what I'm trying to say is keep it easy and fun. I'm fairly casual with every aspect of diamond lapping and carving except where contamination is concerned.

For a deeper look at diamond paste concentration issues in metallography:


Metallography, principles and practice

Re: A new low in diamond sharpening... *LINK*

#12

David Barnett

I suppose I should say something more about cost

David Barnett

Since commercially prepared diamond paste lasts so long for honing hand tools in a one-woodworker shop, it's hardly worth the trouble to buy diamond powder unless one foresees a need to experiment with varying concentrations and in various vehicles. Of course, if you're doing anything other than sharpening and honing, then by all means go for it.

It costs me anywhere from a dollar to mix 5 grams of high concentration (20% or greater) paste for lapidary work, to nearly $3 or even $4 for special grades of loose diamond.

I sometimes use very coarse grits, say 80 to 100, which costs 20 to 25 cents per carat in 100-carat amounts. I don't care if the coarser diamond is as well-graded as the finer, so this keeps my cost exceptionally low. In fact, diamond in this degree of coarseness often contains grit throughout this entire range (80-100) and usually is so stated.

When buying finer grits, I opt for tighter control of mesh micron ranges to avoid unwanted scratches that would extend cutting and polishing times. For very tightly-graded top-quality well-shaped polycrystalline diamond, I'll pay up to $1.50/ct in smaller 25-carat lots, although most averages .66/ct to .89/ct.

While these economies work for me at my slow rate of use (I'm just amazed and grateful diamond is even available to us piddly gem cutters), they might not work for others. I'm not averse to buying the lower mesh sizes from eBay dealers, by the way. For my best efforts, though, I will spring for the higher price spread from proven vendors. And again, my issues differ entirely from plane and chisel sharpening, honing, polishing requirements. So I say, keep it cheap and upgrade only if need to. That way, diamond sharpening should stay just about the cheapest, fastest, easiest way to sharpen ever. IMO, anyway.

Hope this helps. If anyone has questions, I'll try to answer them, but I can't think of anything more to say at this point.

Re: A new low in diamond sharpening... *LINK*

#14

Re: Diamond concentrations in compounds

TomD

Thanks a lot David for all the effort you put into that reply.

A follow up question, what would you use to cut back the commercial pastes available. I had two uses in mind, one was ancillary lubrication in various machining applications where there is rubbing in the general area of the loaded surface (actually arguably one might want a product that didn't loosen the paste); or to loosen up the black and loaded surface of the lap/hone itself. In general, and given the changing compositions, do you think olive oil would be the ideal?

Re: A new low in diamond sharpening... *LINK*

#15

David Barnett

Diamond extenders

David Barnett

De nada, Tom.

"A follow up question, what would you use to cut back the commercial pastes available. ... In general, and given the changing compositions, do you think olive oil would be the ideal?"

In most machining operations, especially those that generate significant heat, olive oil would be a poor choice. Instead, diamond extenders are formulated for various diamond-bearing pastes, loose grit, and commercially prepared suspensions and slurry mixtures. Extenders generally come in three varieties; oil, alcohol, or water-based. The water-based extenders may incorporate propylene or ethylene glycol (diols), as well. My copy of Handbook of Fillers, Extenders, and Diluents lists terephthalic acid-ethylene glycol polyester and a few other tongue-twisting additives.

When faceting, I use extenders to accomplish five purposes: to facilitate even distribution of the diamond-bearing vehicle across lap surfaces, to decrease concentation on ceramic laps, to keep the diamond compound from seizing on the lap (lubrication), to facilitate the cutting action of the diamond grit, and to generally diminish the rate at which diamond must be refreshed. When I flatten the back of a plane iron by hand, I mostly care about lubrication.

Know that faceting probably differs from your machining application inasmuch as the sectional density of a single facet (excepting the table) is far more concentrated than what you will likely encounter, so for you, lubrication would play the dominant role. The gylcols would, of course, be very slippery, lowering the coefficient of friction of the workpiece under load and promoting enhanced cutting action and longevity of the diamond grit.

Depending on your application, how much extender you need and how often, you could use commercially prepared product or conjure your own from any handy source of double alcohols, such as antifreeze (propylene glycol -- I'll assume you can manage the caveats; no pets, etc.). Add distilled water and there you go. If water is a problem for the workpiece or machinery, just leave out the water and use it standalone as an alcohol-based extender. If your machining does not generate much heat and is not high-speed, you might try a silicone extender fluid. These are often popular with lapidarists.

If you do choose commercially-made products, Beuhler, Leco, Ted Pella, MetLab, and Ocean State Abrasives all have various kinds.

Re: A new low in diamond sharpening... *LINK*

#16

David Barnett

Professor Ignatius Brand "SNAKE OIL" *LINK*

David Barnett

I forgot to add Professor Ignatius Brand Snake Oil, Jon Rolfe's (aka Gearloose) new and amazing (and what snake oil isn't?) lap lube and cleaner. I use this on my favorite 1/8" Japanese DT chisel (not HG, btw).

And there's also Jon's innovative stick diamond, DIASTIK�, now in 3,000, 14,000, 60,000 and 100,000 grit:

http://www.battlap.com/diastik.html

Canadians can order both from Lisa Elser, a custom cutter in Vancouver:

http://www.lisaelser.com/index.html

We now stock BATT Laps, Darkside and Greenway polishing laps, Snake Oil and Oxide/Diamond sticks from Jon Rolfe for shipment to Canadian customers. Prices are US list, converted to Canadian dollars.


Ignatius the Great

Re: A new low in diamond sharpening... *LINK*

#18

David Barnett

Oh, great... *LINK*

David Barnett

... another one of those sites where I have to look at absolutely every picture.

I wouldn't want anyone to think I'm a catist, although I pretty much am, so here's a multispecially diverse neonatal-to-neoteny site that puts a serious hurtin' on my insulin intake.


Cute Overload

Re: A new low in diamond sharpening... *LINK*

#19

Re: Professor Ignatius Brand "SNAKE OIL"

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

BTW, do you have good sources for that Herb Dunkel's yellowstone?

Thanks,

Pam

Re: A new low in diamond sharpening... *LINK*

#21

Re: Here's three sources

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Many thanks. I went with Klingspor to send Ellis a few pennies and save on shipping, got some cool sandpaper as well.

Pam

Re: A new low in diamond sharpening... *LINK*

#22

David Barnett

Re: Here's three sources

David Barnett

Makes sense to me. There's always good stuff to buy from Klingspor. I like their yellow sanding belts.