New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Dovetail Marker/Saddle Recommendation

Posts

Dovetail Marker/Saddle Recommendation

#1

Dovetail Marker/Saddle Recommendation

Todd Nebel

I have this small brass dovetail marker in the ratios of 1:5 and 1:8.


I find it difficult to hold steady when marking and I would like other ratios. I would appreciate some recommendations on types and prices. I think I like the individual brass saddle types I've seen in background photos here, but I can't seem to find them at the usual online merchants.


Thanks in advance.

Todd

Re: Dovetail Marker/Saddle Recommendation

#2

That's because Derek Cohen made them *LINK*

Bruce, a MN Galoot

and they're pretty nice, too. Take a gander at his tools.

I have the LV saddle marker, the one with the 1:6 ratio. I've found that angle works well in the stuff I dovetail, mostly drawers and boxes, made from wood between 1/2" and 3/4" thick.


"In The Woodshop" shop-made tools

Re: Dovetail Marker/Saddle Recommendation

#3

David Barnett

Cheap solution *LINK*

David Barnett

I've made a couple from 1 3/4" 6063 T52 aluminum angle, which has a sharp inside corner, unlike 6061, which is rounded. Gave those away and made another set of brass, like Derek. Easy, quick, enjoyable. Hacksaw and a file.

You should have little trouble finding a piece of 1 1/2 x 1 1/2" to 2 x 2" scrap from a local metals recycler or hardware store. Failing that, there's eBay, of course, or OnlineMetals.com.

If you want the prettier and harder but pricier brass angle:

http://tinyurl.com/253tcxc

And there's aluminum or wood frame moulding, acrylic box corners, and so on. Now Derek's infill marker; not so easy, not so quick, not so cheap -- whole 'nother story.


Aluminum runs $2.68 for one foot.

Re: Dovetail Marker/Saddle Recommendation

#4

If you don't want to make your own  *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA


Lee Valley's offerings are similar

Re: Dovetail Marker/Saddle Recommendation

#5

Re: If you don't want to make your own

Todd Nebel

Hi Bill,

What's the verdit on the Veritas ones? Anyone like / dislike them?

Re: Dovetail Marker/Saddle Recommendation

#6

Anyone like Woodjoy's? *LINK*

Todd Nebel

Anyone have one of the these from Woodjoy?

- Precision Dovetail Template

- Dovetail Saddle Square

- Double Dovetail Square


http://www.woodjoytools.com/page9/page9.html

Re: Dovetail Marker/Saddle Recommendation

#7

Re: If you don't want to make your own

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I have the Veritas 1:6 saddle gauge and like it a lot.

Re: Dovetail Marker/Saddle Recommendation

#8

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Dovetail Marker/Saddle Recommendation

Jack Guzman from Maine

Lee Valley's are probably your best bet. You really shouldn't spend alot on a dovetail marker. You can do the job in many ways.Frank Klaus doesn't use anything. He just eyeballs the angle. I have a drawer full of different styles. I seem to be leaving them in the drawer alot more and just using a bevel. Just my opinion. I'm no expert.---Jack

Re: Dovetail Marker/Saddle Recommendation

#9

Re: Dovetail Marker/Saddle Recommendation

George in snowy Lowell, Mich.

Todd,

I had the same problem with the one shown by the penny. I took a small piece of aluminium and made a longer "fence". It's much easier to hold.

George

Re: Dovetail Marker/Saddle Recommendation

#10

Re: Dovetail Marker/Saddle Recommendation *LINK*

charlie belden

One of the shortcomings of most dovetail marking devices is that they only let you mark one face or end. A "saddle" marking gauge gets around that shortcoming. But even a "saddle" gauge has a shortcoming - it's opaque.

Here's one you can make that uses the "saddle" idea - and is transparent - so you can SEE where you are.


Transparent Dovetail Gauge

Re: Dovetail Marker/Saddle Recommendation

#11

Thanks for all the feedback.

Todd Nebel

I think I'll try to make my own set of saddles in the future.

Re: Dovetail Marker/Saddle Recommendation

#12

Re: Dovetail Marker/Saddle Recommendation

Phil Joines

If you have access to a sheet metal break you can bend them from 1/8" Polycarb.

Re: Dovetail Marker/Saddle Recommendation

#13

Yes, but...

James Watriss

Yep.

I have their double dovetail square, and the total square. It makes a nice enough set, and they work well. I don't like the dovetail layout gauge, with the pin shaped holes... but they've been making those for a while, so maybe that's just my own preference.

After doing this for a few years, I find the tool I usually reach for is a sliding bevel gauge for dovetail layout. I do like Derek's little saddle layout tools, though.