We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
For anyone wanting to try diamond honing, the Norton Polishing Kit (SKU: NO02462), which includes four 5-gram syringes of diamond lapping compound, lubricant, and four MDF sharpening substrate blocks is selling for $41.11 at NotJustKnives.com. Jamestown sells this same kit for $87.55.
A five gram syringe of diamond compound lasts a long long time. You can try other substrates beside MDF, of course; maple, phenolic, acrylic, cast iron, copper and so on.
I've not purchased from NotJustKnives so this isn't an endorsement. Just thought someone might benefit from the low price.
Hardwood substrates for diamond paste honing *LINK*
David Barnett
You're welcome, Tom. I see they have one left in stock.
I neglected to mention this kit is equivalent to 600, 1200, 3,000 and 8,000 mesh/grit.
More thoughts...
Although MDF has been recommended as a passable substrate for diamond, particularly because it's readily available, cheap and reasonably flat, several hardwood species excel at holding and presenting diamond. While maple is usually suggested in woodworking magazines, there are better choices. I've included a link to a Lapidary Journal article aimed at gem carvers (who make their own rotary polishing points) that discusses pros and cons of several species.
Like the author, I had long ago adopted Henry Hunt's recommendations when I began carving aquamarine, tourmaline, sapphire and so on, and later added a couple other species, as well, such as Brazilian peppertree (similar but superior to holly, IMO, and I have a whole backyard of this invasive species). I still mostly use pink ivory, but briar and boxwood are close seconds. Tight-grained wood is far better and a whole helluva lot easier to shape than cast iron for the highly concentrated diamond compounds I make for my own use.
For sharpening planes and chisels, thin boards of Gabon ebony (sold for guitar fingerboards by online luthier suppliers, eBay, etc. ) make great hones. You can get three 2 3/4" - 3" wide by 7" - 8" long hones from one 3/8" thick fingerboard. The secondary, less cosmetically desirable grades are inexpensive and work fine. Planes and scrapers will get them totally flat and smooth.
While I still favor grey cast iron laps for honing and polishing woodworking tools with standard concentration commercial diamond pastes, they're more expensive to make and maintain than wood substrates.
I thought the general view on this board is that one should not use wood, but rather use cast iron. There are a lot of options there particularly with all the cast iron junk riding the waves in this direction these days. Maybe aluminum...
Using fingerboards is kinda a low end use of those gems, and it isn't as though they are straight, or stay straight.
Wasn't thinking so much of using fingerboards as I was of making slips. Imagine the possibilities for making different slips to sharpen combination and moulding plane blades. I do have a pretty good stash of pink ivory scraps. MDF and maple have been mentioned on this forum, as I recall, but I think the info on the best woods could be quite useful (and it's new to me). I haven't gotten around to hunting down an old tablesaw for the iron yet, although that will certainly come one day...
... to stay flat, right. But at less than ten USD from LMI* or Allied they're cheap enough, and I don't consider these to be instrument grade -- I surely wouldn't put one on a handmade classical. I suppose I was rambling on about different species because it's interested me for years and makes a difference in the way I work outside of woodworking. I also suppose species is far from critical where woodworking tools are concerned.
"I thought the general view on this board is that one should not use wood, but rather use cast iron."
I think you're right about that, but a fair number of woodworkers do employ wood and I have seen it at Boston's North Bennet Street School and One Cottage Street in Easthampton (now the New England School of Architectural Woodworking). If I remember correctly, the fingerboard rejects came from Bill Cumpiano, just down the road in Northampton (where I lived).
I see Garrett Hack seems happy with cherry:
"My final honing surface is a strop, diamond paste on a cherry block, about 12,000 grit."
-- Kelly Mehler's website
"There are a lot of options there particularly with all the cast iron junk riding the waves in this direction these days."
Good point. But while scrap iron is ubiquitous, it's not always easy to get into convenient sizes and shapes for someone trying diamond for the first time. (Cecil Pierce used recycled plane soles, but wouldn't you know all the dead ones I came across were corrugated.) And buying new dimensioned grey iron, Meehanite, whatever from MSC is a bit pricey nowadays, and requires hand scraping and a surface plate if you don't have a Blanchard grinder handy. I started out (years before WoodCentral) with the Harris lapping system but later made laps from dimensioned plate when it was still surprisingly cheap. Thing is, back then I'd just about buy iron to have an excuse to scrape it flat.
At any rate, while iron may be ideal, wood does work in everyday practice. And as you note, other substrates abound: aluminum's good, copper's excellent, acrylic, Corian, phenolic, old 78rpm records, even wax for specialized applications.
*WF2ASX fingerboard, West African Ebony, 2nd grade, standard
Thanks for that, David. I got the impression that the author was interested in using such woods to make stone carving tools, and that he embedded diamonds in the wood tools. Right? If so, the implications are that such wood could also work as a sharpening base; but at what expense? Boxwood? That's pretty dear stuff.
I love your recommendation of using ebony fingerboards. They're pretty cheap on ebay and hard as nails (are nails cast or ductile?
" ...the implications are that such wood could also work as a sharpening base; but at what expense? Boxwood? That's pretty dear stuff."
While I do have logs and half-logs of our beloved buxus sempervirens, as you might expect, Pam, you'll find no boxwood hones in my shop. The hoard is not only well-guarded, it's sorted from king to pawn should I outlive my unfulfilled ambitions and procrastinative tendencies. Only the scraps become gem carving points and wheels.
As for the fingerboard blanks, they also make drawer fronts for machinist-style tool chests, jewelry boxes and hobby, parts and collector's chests (fly tying, and so on), and with appropriate metals, great cabinet hardware, too. Some of the better scraps become jewelry components when sandwiched by or inlaid with silver. Also, lamp, luminaire and tool components, knife scales, and on and on. Ah, the joy of repurposing.
Oh... a bit of oil eventually evens out and further blackens the less-than-perfect lower grades, which naturally happens when oily digits play in fingerboards used for their intended purpose.
In the June 1996 issue of American Woodworker, in the feature Getting the Edge -- four experts share their sharpening solutions, Barry Biesanz, in Lapping and Sharpening Plates , describes the Harris Tool system used in his shop.
The 2002 July/August FWW Sharp and Sharper -- nine honing systems are put to the test, Aim� Ontario Fraser article on page 40, endorsed maple as a viable diamond substrate, which is the first time I recall hardwood suggested as a diamond lap in a major woodworking publication. Her conclusion? "Maple was the winner, with the steel plate producing the roughest results. MDF was hardest to use."
"I grow old. I grow old. I shall wear the bottoms of my trousers rolled."
I've been using a maple strop (curly maple, no less) for decades now, since the early '80s at least. I used to charge it with slurry that I made up with a nagura stone on an 8000-grit waterstone. The wet slurry caused the surface fibers to swell a little, but that goes down with the first few strops of a tool on the surface. Nowadays, I am using 14,000-grit diamond paste as the abrasive, and it raises a flat, mirror polish in no time flat after routine honing with 2000 and 8000 grit stones. I hardly use my 10,000 grit stone at all anymore.
I have not tried other woods for stropping, but I don't see why there would be a perceptible difference, as long as the wood is hard and non-abrasive in its own right. I don't think I'd use teak or another mineral-laden wood. The trouble with other strops, leather in particular, is that they are too soft. Normal stropping pressure forces the tool into the strop and dubs the edge slightly (or not so slightly, depending on the pressure and the abrasive used).
Ellis
PS, that was one of my favorite AW issues. Thanks for the flashback. My editorial is on page 2.
My maple strops from the '90s are still in use. I agree hardwood is best for planes and chisels. Narrow chisels, gravers, and the like need even harder substrates, as their concentrated sectional densities will easily deform even the hardest maple. For gravers it's more a polishing than a stropping thing, though.
"The trouble with other strops, leather in particular, is that they are too soft."
Generally true, but for thin hand forged carving gouges (inside and out), bookbinding knives and turning skews, I actually do prefer hard horse butt (and not just any horse butt). I can tell you that properly tanned and calendared horse butt has amazing stropping qualities in its own right. Gouges can be kept going a truly long time without returning to stones or coarser grits.
"I have not tried other woods for stropping, but I don't see why there would be a perceptible difference, as long as the wood is hard and non-abrasive in its own right."
I do prefer other woods for lower diamond mesh pastes but it's not critical by any means. For rotary carving points on gem material, yeah, big difference. Maple needs frequent recharging on medium and lower mesh pastes and gives up the ghost pretty quickly surfacewise on my fixed arbor at even low to medium speeds.
"PS, that was one of my favorite AW issues. Thanks for the flashback. My editorial is on page 2."
That issue of AW is from what I consider the Late Golden Age of woodworking magazines.
Here is a link to a good article about diamond sharpening from the "Articles" section of this forum:http://www.woodcentral.com/articles/powertools/articles_776.shtml