New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Completed Halfback saws

Posts

Completed Halfback saws

#1

Completed Halfback saws

Dominic in Buck's County PA

Hi Gang,

Well it's been a while since I last posted an update to this project. I had ruined 3 or 4 handles right in a row and had allowed this project to languish for several months. After a pep talk from my assorted mentors (Klaus, Pedder, Jack & Marv W) I decided it was time to try again.

One thing I should mention is that I started out with three halfback saws but finished only two. The formed spine turned out to be less than perfect and caused the saw plate to kink. So I ditched it. I will probably order a formed spine from Mike W, or make another slit spine once my buddy gets him milling machine set up (friend gloat!)

As you can guess, my main problem were the handles. First it was getting a nice straight saw slot, then it was mortising in for the spine. Once I actually got it all right only to have the handle crack while I was putting the saw together (there is a reason you don't see saw handles made from Gonsalo Alves!).

First off, let's take a look at the problems I had sawing the slot. Hopefully someone can learn something from my MANY mistakes! These are two new handles totally made from scratch. One was apple, and the other is walnut.

Sawing the slot

One of the jewels Klaus passed along was how to improve my chances of sawing a straight slot. I usually saw the slots by blocking up my back saw with an appropriately sized piece of wood. Then I secure it to the bench with some holdfasts. Well, Klaus' tip was to only allow about 3/8" of the saw plate to extend from the "block". That way it was better supported and would not deflect. Thus giving me a nice start on the cut.

After the cut was established, I switched to holding the handle in my vice and continued to carefully deepen the cut.

Deepening the saw slot

After that was completed I followed up by using the saw plate destined for this handle to finish the cut. This ensured a perfect fit.

Deepening the saw slot

And all that careful preparation paid off! I ended up with a perfect saw slot in both handles. After that I mortised in for the spine (for some reason I have no photos of that.) and then moved onto drilling the holes and then shaping the handles.

These handles were a bit more complex than the open handled dovetail and carcass saw handles I've made. These called for some carving at the lamb's tongue. Something I have never done before. But some layout work with a sharp exacto, and some careful use of a 3/8" fishtail chisel I got from John Payne allowed me to pull this off.

Carving the lambs tounge

After that was completed I used the chisel to clean up as much of the edges as possible, and went to work with a rasp to shape the handles. Once I was done with the rasp, I went to work with my scrapers to remove what was left of the template paper as well as the rasp marks

Scraping the handles

After that I spent some time sanding up to 200 - 300 grit.

Sanded handles

I'd like to point out one set of clamps I use that had proven to be invaluable when shaping handles. These are el-cheapo 10" wooden clamps I got from HF about 12 years ago. One clamp is held on the bench by hold fasts, while the other is held upright by that clamp. I recently added a set of padded leather jaws to each and have been amazed at how much better they perform. I also added a set of 1/2" thick spacers under the bottom clamp to lift it up away from the bench top so I can grip the handles better. That way I can tighten and loosen the bottom clamp easier.

Updated Clamps

Now that the handles were sanded, it was time to transfer the holes to the saw plates, drill the holes and test the fit. Here I am transferring the hole location using a transfer punch I got from HF.

Transferring the holes

Since I had done it before, drilling the holes was easier this time. I spot annealed the locations and drilled them at low speed, being sure to quench the bit frequently with WD-40. I also got to use my new Drill Doctor to touch up the bits after each session. That is one power tool purchase I don't regret!

Now that the saw plates were set, it was time to apply a finish to the handles. Like the split nut driver I just made, I decided to use TruOil for the finish. I applied the first of three coats and allowed both handles to dry overnight.

Finished handles

The next night I buffed out the finish with synthetic steelwool (looks like a fine gray scotch brite) cleaned the handle off and re-applied the TruOil. I repeated this once more for a total of three coats. After that I buffed out the finish with 000 steel wool and wax followed by buffing at a Beall Buffing Wheel (Tripoli/White Diamond/Wax). And I got a super gloss finish! Dang, I really love this TruOil!

Tonight was the moment of truth. I cleaned up the saw plates and then assembled the saws. After all that hard work they went together flawlessly. And without further ado here they are.

The finished Halfbacks

Finished Halfback saw with walnut handle

Finished Halfback saw with apple handle

I will probably sharpen them some time this weekend and then give them a test run. Look for more photos soon.

See ya around,

Dominic

Re: Completed Halfback saws

#3

Outstanding job, Dom!

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I have an embarrassingly crappy Disston backsaw that I acquired many years ago that is destined to look similar to one of your halfbacks. Every since you posted the beginning of the project last summer I've been waiting for the denouement.

Thanks for the tutorial - both the process and the tips are muchly appreciated.

Re: Completed Halfback saws

#4

Re: Completed Halfback saws

Bob Hackett

Sweet lookin` saws Dom!

Glad you posted pics of them,thanks for that.

One tip that may help with the handle splitting problem is to drill thru where the kerf for the plate will terminate.The square bottom of the cut leaves 2 corners that act as stress risers which are the ideal place for cracking to start.Drilling the end point leaves a radius which is far less likely to crack.

Same idea as a machinist or maintenance worker stop drilling a crack in a casting to keep it from progressing.

Hope this is of some help.I know you want to try again with the Goncalo.Pretty wood should be shown off at every opportunity.I have some really nice figured Purpleheart I`m trying to get up the nerve to work with.Now that stuff knows how to crack!

Re: Completed Halfback saws

#5

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Nothing Half About It!

Jim in River Oaks, Ont.

Hey Dom,

Stunning is the only word that comes to mind, I love half back's, I am not sure what it is about them, but I have a few and reach for them always... I almost wonder if I need a third!! :-)

Beautiful work my friend, wonderful!

Take care,

Jim

Re: Completed Halfback saws

#6

Really nice work Dom!

Stuart Hough

Thanx also for the tutorial. Your posts always educate, and highlight the challenges (and solutions) to the creating tools by the craftsman for his personal use and satisfaction. I always learn from your endeavors, if only vicariously!

Re: Completed Halfback saws

#7

The cow skulls live!

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

Well done Dom. I was wondering when you'd get the nerve (so to speak) to take another stab at them. Thanks for all the pic & tips on your saw making excursion. The handles turned out fantastic IMHO.

Re: Completed Halfback saws

#8

Re: Why the half back?

George in snowy Lowell, Mich.

Re: Completed Halfback saws

#9

I had wondered the same thing myself

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Do they give a little more stiffness than an unbacked saw while preserving the infinite depth of cut of an unbacked saw? And, if you cut past the depth of the back, do you risk pounding the wood with the front of the back?

Please enlighten those of us who've never even seen one of these in the flesh, much less used one.

And, a small point: given the ratio of back to blade, aren't they properly quarterback saws? :D :D :D

Re: Completed Halfback saws

#10

Re: Completed Halfback saws

Andy Lincoln,in Dearborn MI

Way too cool Dom!!!You did an outstanding job on the saw as well as the write up and pictures.

My halfback plate is still sitting in the box you shipped it in waiting patiently until I can provide the attention it requires.

Your post and tutorial is very helpful keep 'em coming.If mine turn out 1/4 as nice as your I'll be thrilled.

Andy

Re: Completed Halfback saws

#11

Why not?

Dominic in Buck's County PA

Re: Completed Halfback saws

#12

Re: I had wondered the same thing myself

Dominic in Buck's County PA

I made it because I've always liked the overall design and looks. Plus I am a fan of panel and tool box saws. So if you are asking why did I make a Halfback saw,....I say "Because I could!" :D

BUT if you are asking what's the point of a Halfback saw, here's the scoop from the Disstonian Institute

"The No. 8 half-back saw was a hybrid design. It was a bench saw designed for cabinetmakers and other woodworkers requiring the accuracy of a backsaw with the depth of cut and pointed toe of a short panel saw. The No. 8 model was made in lengths of 14 to 20 inches, according to all the catalogs quoted at the bottom of this webpage. The No. 8 is rarely found, despite being manufactured from the 1850's until the early 1920's. This one was made between 1871 and 1876, the H. Disston and Sons period when the saws had "split" or spanner-head nuts"


img

Re: Completed Halfback saws

#13

Re: Completed Halfback saws

Dominic in Buck's County PA

Thanks for the compliments everyone. As with any project that takes so long to complete, it's somewhat anticlimactic once the work is done. :D

In case you were wondering why I started off making three; One of these saws is destined for my little brother, one is for my older brother, and one is for me.

I think it would be nice that each of them has a tool I made so in later years they can pass it down to their sons and continue the tradition.

Re: Completed Halfback saws

#14

I didn't intend my comment to sound critical

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

more a matter of curiousity about its benefits vs. an unbacked or fullbacked saw.

Re: Completed Halfback saws

#15

Re: I didn't intend my comment to sound critical

Dominic in Buck's County PA

No problem!

One of the pitfalls of comments on WWing forums like this is they can be interpreted in several different ways. I included responses to both of the ways I interpreted your comment as well as George's

One was to explain what motivated me to build such an esoteric saw, and the other was an explanation of the saw's intended use and it's "niche" in the hierarchy of Disston Saws.

Re: Completed Halfback saws

#16

Jim in Burlington Ont.

That's What I thought  :-)

Jim in River Oaks, Ont.

Re: Completed Halfback saws

#17

Re:Dominic, I didn't intend my comment to ...

George in snowy Lowell, Mich.

be critical either. Being an inquiring minded guy, I wondered what prompted this. Now I see there was a historical precedent. Two saws for the price of one. The craftsman of old must have had to have many toolboxes to hold all the tools that he needed to work his "magic".

Re: Completed Halfback saws

#18

Sharpened Halfback saw

Dominic in Buck's County PA

I sharpened one of the halfbacks yesterday so I could have it ready for my brother when he comes up this weekend.

Halfback in vise

I lightly jointed the teeth and then shaped them. That was a piece of cake. Then I got ready to sharpen.

marking the teeth

I usually use a sharpie to darken the teeth. This way when I run the file across them I can see where I've been by looking where the color "isn't". However, the sharpie I have out in the shop has seen better days and I decided to try something else. I got a rag and dampened a spot with Dyechem. I then dabbed along the top of the teeth and was able to color them a lot easier and more consistently than using a sharpie.

With the marked teeth all ready I proceeded to sharpen and set the 9 tpi teeth to cross cut. I was then ready to take this saw for a test run.

At first I attempted to use this like a panel saw at my saw bench. But the hang is all wrong (at least I thought so) and it felt uncomfortable. I then switched to working at the work bench and the saw felt a lot better. I believe that I read somewhere that these saws were meant to be used at a bench anyway.

sawing rip

sawing cross cut

As you can see is was tracking right to the line with very little effort. It was a little "grabby" at first. But it seemed to mellow out after a couple dozen cuts. I still may go back and increase the set a bit. But all in all I was pretty happy with the performance.

Now I have only one more problem. I don't have enough room in my tool cabinet for all my saws! Guess what my next shop project may end up being? If you said "saw till", you're right!

See ya around,

Dominic

Re: Completed Halfback saws

#20

Re: Sharpened Halfback saw

Mike

Man Dominic, you blow me away with every project you post. Not only are those saws nice to look at they're functional as well. Great job (as usual).

Re: Completed Halfback saws

#21

Re: Sharpened Halfback saw

TomD

Is there is blog for the whole build?