New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

If you had to pick between a 10 & 10-1/2...

Posts

If you had to pick between a 10 & 10-1/2...

#1

If you had to pick between a 10 & 10-1/2...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

My main New Years Resolution is to simplify my life. This means getting rid of anything I hardly every use and even some things I do but have duplicates of or don't like for one reason or another.

So, if you had to choose between a 10 and a 10-1/2, which would you pick and why?

Also if'in you don't mind, the same question with a 40 and a 40-1/2?

Thanks!

Re: If you had to pick between a 10 & 10-1/2...

#2

Wouldn't that be 10 1/4?

Neal in San Jose

Re: If you had to pick between a 10 & 10-1/2...

#3

It's your mileage...

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I have a No. 10-1/2; have never held a No. 10. Very few of us nowadays are doing joinery-scale rabbets by hand, so I'm not altogether sure that either one can be justified in a pure "you need this" sense for most folks. I personally find the 10-1/2 a bit small - I can't hold the tote by wrapping my fingers around it; but this is a matter of my hand, may vary for yours.

I guess the question there would be, if you do use them, which one (a) feels more comfortable and (b) fits the scale of your work better.

Between the 40 and 40-1/2, I guess it's a question of which one feels most comfy in use. Their function seems pretty nearly identical.

Re: If you had to pick between a 10 & 10-1/2...

#4

There's also a 10-1/2

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

The No. 10 was the size of a No. 5 jack plane; the No. 10-1/2, in Stanley's ever-consistent numbering system, was roughly the size of a No. 4 (actually a bit smaller; the tote crams right up against the back of the frog). The 10-1/4 had the cool tilty knob and tote.

I suspect Stanley's numbering system was developed by the same people who made the decisions about thread size/pitch for the planes.

Re: If you had to pick between a 10 & 10-1/2...

#5

40 1/2,for sure

Bob Hackett

Even with my arm I can handle the 40 1/2 so you have no excuse. ;)

I just like my 40 1/2 better.I gave away two 40`s so far and still have one I fit with a planer blade for an iron (HSS).I`ll probably give that one away too sooner or later but never my 40 1/2. :D

Re: If you had to pick between a 10 & 10-1/2...

#6

Yep, The 10-1/4 had the nifty tilting knob.

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

If I had had one of those I wouldn't be asking this question.

Re: If you had to pick between a 10 & 10-1/2...

#7

Traction on the slippery slope?

David Miller from Iowa

We all make crazy resolutions sometimes, but getting rid of planes? Go clean out your closets and throw away all your old clothes and shoes, then clean the pantry and get rid of the cream of asparagus soup that has been there since Y2K, then go lie down a while until this urge passes.

Re: If you had to pick between a 10 & 10-1/2...

#8

Second that!

Bob Hackett

Re: If you had to pick between a 10 & 10-1/2...

#9

Oh come on now...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

I have planes that I haven't touched in decades. Why keep them around?

Needless to say I hate caned vegies and will be ridding our pantry of all #5 and #7 plastic among other nasty items as well.