New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Thinking of Scrapers

Posts

Thinking of Scrapers

#1

Thinking of Scrapers

Terry in Denver

I'm wondering wether it is worth waiting for the next production run of the Hamler scraper insert (no idea when that might be) or trying out a LN 90 degree scraper blade for the #62 LA Jack (which I already have) OR getting the LV #112 - which I has tried out at a WWing show and rather like.

Has anyone used the LN blade or have/used the Hamler insert? Any thoughts to share?

Thanks.

Terry

Re: Thinking of Scrapers

#2

Re: Thinking of Scrapers

David Miller from Iowa

I tried a Hamler at my brother's shop - it was nicely made and worked fine, but not exceptional. Noting he had his in a #6 which was just too long for a scraper plane I thought. It probably would do much better in a 4 1/2. I haven't tried the lee valley but have the LN 112 and it is awesome. The extra width (over the Hamler) and shorter sole makes a really big difference, IMHO.

Re: Thinking of Scrapers

#3

Moses Yoder

Re: Thinking of Scrapers

Moses Yoder

The #62 jack is a nice plane and seems like it would get a lot of use. Switching back and forth all the time seems like more hassle than I would like. I have a Stanley #112 with a Hock scraper blade and I like that plane, although for some reason most of my scraping ends up getting done with hand held scrapers. I normally only scrape a few small areas on a project. I would take advantage of any excuses to buy new LV tools in a heart beat.

Re: Thinking of Scrapers

#4

Well...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

I have a Stanley 112. I didn't like the thin blade that came with it. It was a bit of a PITA to set set up. I put a Hock iron in it and it works a lot better IMHO because you don't have to put any bow on the blade. I get great results using it with out burnishing a hook (or burr) on the Hock blade. I do wish the 112 was a bit heavier.

Re: Thinking of Scrapers

#5

Re: Thinking of Scrapers

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

I'm very fond of the Japanese scraper planes that come in all different sizes.

Pam

Re: Thinking of Scrapers

#6

Re: Thinking of Scrapers

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Terry

I agree with others that a #62 may be too long for a scraper plane. I tend to use cabinet (card) scrapers mostly, and for me the advantage of these is that you can focus on a localised area of tearout. This would be difficult with a long plane - like trying to use a jointer as a smoother. In any event, if you want to try out a #62 with a scraping blade, it seems to me that all you need to do is flatten/square off the end of one of your blades - all you need is about 1 mm of face. You do not need to reshape the entire bevel face. Then then is not must to do when you want to return it to normal.

I have had a Stanley #112 with a LN blade for a number of years. This does not get much use. It works well - see ...

Thick verses thin � blades for the #112 Scraper Plane: http://www.inthewoodshop.com/WoodworkTechniques/Thick%20verses%20thin%20112%20Scraper%20Plane%20blades.html

I do use a small scraping plane, the Veritas Small Scraper Plane ..


I thought I had written a review on this one, but it appears not so. Must remedy that. This is a great little user, ideal for working small areas.

The other point is that you have a #62. Frankly I would be looking at getting another blade for it, which you can hone at a high angle, say 50-55 degrees. That will give you a cutting angle of 62-67 degrees. I cannot imagine much in the way of tricky grain out tricking you then! :)

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Thinking of Scrapers

#7

Re: Thinking of Scrapers

Terry in Denver

Thanks for all the feedback everyone - lots of good suggestions. I think for the short-term I'll try a new scraper blade for the 62 I have just to see how it goes. I can also regrind it to a high angle per Dereks advise and be able to try two different scenario's with one blade. I think in the long run I'll aim for one of the various 112's. Dereks photo's of his different blades thicknesses in the Stanley 112 are impressive!

Thanks!

Terry

Re: Thinking of Scrapers

#8

Re: Thinking of Scrapers

Scott in Montana

Hello Terry,

I have the small and regular sized LV scraper planes and a Stanley #6 fitted with the Hamler scraper. I use them all. I graduate through the sizes just like you would with handplanes.

The Hamler is great for table tops on all kinds of grain. I'd get on the waiting list.

Scott in Montana