New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

"New Old " Jack Plane

Posts

"New Old " Jack Plane

#1

"New Old " Jack Plane

Thomas Norton

Well took some time today and finished flattening the sole of a #5 Stanley/Bailey plane that I got on eBay.

Waxed it up and put in my new Hock blade and chipbreaker. Put some hard maple then cherry and then poplar in the bench vice.

And SWEET is all I can say!

Re: "New Old " Jack Plane

#2

Fun, yes

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I'm in the midst of cleaning up a couple of "upgrade" No. 5s I got this Fall, taking a break from the job (work on house). One's still in process, but I've tried out the other with my LV iron. Yes, it is a sweet feeling.

Re: "New Old " Jack Plane

#3

thick chip breaker

Jerry Gibbs

This has probably been asked before, but do I need it? I rehabbed a similiar plane and installed a Cosman blade and old breaker. I balked at a chip breaker that cost as much as the blade. Plane seems to work well, but I have little experience for comparison.

Re: "New Old " Jack Plane

#4

Re: thick chip breaker

Bob Hackett

It`s my understanding that a chip breaker really only does two things.First and probably most important,it stiffens a thin blade/iron and second it causes the chip to curl and in theory makes it less likely for the plane to jam up.I`ve heard the theory that curling the chip makes it less likely that the chip will act as a lever and split the wood ahead of the cut making it more prone to tearout if the plane has a less than narrow mouth.The jury is still out on that subject as well as most esoterica surrounding edged tools.

In my experience,if you have an iron in the plane that is thick enough to resist chatter on it`s own then there is little to be gained by using an expensive chip breaker on top of it.

The 2 piece chip breakers are supposed to negate the need to remove and reset the chipbreaker when sharpening time comes around.From what I`ve seen they are just another high priced gizmo that falls short of the mark.The remaining piece and retainer screw interfere with some sharpening jigs and after a few sharpenings(like 2 if you set the CB close to the edge of the iron) you have to reset the chipbreaker anyway.

Once you drop one of them in the shavings the time spent looking for the missing piece more than eclipses the time saved by using one.

I say go with a thicker iron and use the standard chip breaker.According to some folks it really only functions as an index point for the depth adjustment anyway.

Irons that are too thick can cause their own set of problems.Those problems have been discussed in depth here before.

Re: "New Old " Jack Plane

#5

Re: thick chip breaker

Jerry

I was glad to see that Lee Valley has a new line of Cap Irons for $24 to $30 depending on size. I have several Hock cap irons that seem to do a good job of stiffening the blade and I have a couple of the overpriced Clifton 2 piece cap irons but I don't plan to buy any more of those.

Jerry