New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Speaking of saws...

Posts

Speaking of saws...

#1

Speaking of saws...

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

I keep reading left and right that Japanese saws have the blade in tension in the cut, and because of that they can be made thinner, thus making for a faster cut.

I can accept that. But somehow, I don't think this applies to backsaws.

With the spine holding the saw plate, it doesn't matter at which end the handle is. The spine will prevent buckling. Only if the spine is flimsy could a backsaw buckle, I think.

In my limited experience, I have buckled large handsaws, but never a backsaw. Then again I use mostly Japanese saws, but for some reason I get irritated whenever I see the "blade in tension" claim made...

Thomas, I'd be curious to see what would happen if you used a dozuki on the push stroke...

DC

Re: Speaking of saws...

#2

Re: Speaking of saws...

wilbur

Hi Denis,

At the last WIA, there was some talk about the thin bladed western backsaws that have been coming out from some of the saw makers. Those backsaws can be kinked if being used with too much of a heavy hand.

Even so, the plates on these saws are still thicker than the Japanese equivalents. For example, the Lie-Nielsen thin plate dovetail saw is 0.015" thick. The Kondo dozuki at Japan Woodworker has a plate that is 0.008" thick. Ryobas tend to have a plate that is in the 0.015" range.

Taking all this into account, I'd say that there is something to the "blade in tension" concept.

Re: Speaking of saws...

#3

Is there a body mechanics issue at play here?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I wonder if the natural motions involved in pulling something closer to you are softer, somehow, than the natural motions involved in pushing away? If so, kinking a thin Western-model saw might be a product of the force applied, not whether the saw was in tension or compression.

We need an engineer with a lab and a dozen graduate students to explore this...

Re: Speaking of saws...

#4

Stephen Shepherd

Biceps v triceps

Stephen Shepherd

Re: Speaking of saws...

#5

Chris Scholz

Western framesaws are under tension, too.

Chris Scholz

Re: Speaking of saws...

#6

Re: Biceps v triceps

Frank D. in Montreal

Actually I'D guess mostly the triceps, pectorals, and deltoids for Western saws, and the triceps and teres for Japanese saws. Biceps are probably used as stabilisers, but not much by efficient sawyers.

Frank (half tongue-muscle in cheek muscle)

Re: Speaking of saws...

#7

Re: Speaking of saws...

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

I'd be curious to see what would happen if you used a dozuki on the push stroke...

Well, nothing really, maybe a little stabbing by the points, there's no cutting edge on the side of the teeth facing away from the user.

Pam

Re: Speaking of saws...

#8

Re: Is there a body mechanics issue at play here? *LINK*

wilbur

I took some pictures to illustrate what I see happening in terms of body mechanics, and put them on my blog. But I don't see that there is much difference in the forces involved. Either way, you can put more force into the sawing stroke than is necessary, and enough force so that the blade can kink.


Mechanics of sawing with western and Japanese saws

Re: Speaking of saws...

#9

Re: Speaking of saws...

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

I meant by attaching a handle at the other end, in case I wasn't clear enough :)

Re: Speaking of saws...

#10

Did you mean for it to cut on the push stroke?

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Re: Speaking of saws...

#11

Yes

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

But now I'm thinking that the spine on a dozuki might not be strong enough for that...

If I can find in the shop a saw that I'm willing to sacrifice, I might just try it, just out of curiosity...

DC

Re: Speaking of saws...

#12

Re: Speaking of saws...

Rob Lee

Denis -

A pull saw is in tension - but only from the point of contact with the wood... the unrestrained blade end would be free to flop and vibrate. A thin saw plate still need to be presented to the wood at a consistent angle when pulled (or pushed). For many saws -the saw plate thickness affords suitable stiffness. If not, a back can be added. Don't forget the saw blade has to travel two directions - and a thin plate still has to be pushed back (against friction) to reset for another stroke.

A push saw is in compression - again, from the point of contact with the wood, back towards the handle. The plate has to be thick enough to resist the compression, and smaller side loads resulting from variabilty in the stroke. Again, thickness handles much of the load, but if not, a back can be added.

Either saw (push or pull) can be set up so that the blade is in tension (frame saws, bow saws) - which is really just a special case of a pull saw - whether it cuts on the push or pull stroke.

As far as design goes try this simple visualisation - picture a rectangular saw plate, filed either crosscut or rip. a force has to be applied for the saw blade to cut. Draw the force vector. Translate the force vector to the end of the plate where you want your handle (one end is push, one end is pull). Design the grip to best apply the force vector.

Straightforward eh?

Cheers -

Rob

Re: Speaking of saws...

#13

Well...

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

I get what you say, but...

Picture this: imagine a push backsaw where the only place where the back is holding the saw plate is at the end (toe) of the back, the rest of the saw is a loose fit in the back (and handle). The force vector is applied from the handle to the end of the back, which in turns "pulls" the saw plate. There's no way the saw can kink or buckle in this scenario.

Now, if the plate is secured to the saw back over the whole length, what I'm saying in the above paragraph should apply even more so, and at the same time it takes care of the return stroke friction issue you mentioned.

I seems to me that, for a backsaw to kink, the back would have to be flimsy and/or the depth capacity very large. I understand that thin plates are more fragile (which is the reason these saws should be used by more experienced people), but has anyone actually managed to kink a push backsaw, or read or heard from anyone who has?

Nothing like actual experience to debunk theory :)

DC

Re: Speaking of saws...

#14

Re: Well...

Rob Lee

Denis -

Don't have to image that scenario... we've built it, and tested it.

One big problem with theory is.... it's not reality ;) :D :D !

I'll toss out another generalization for you... if the strength of a beam varies proportionally with width, but with the square of the depth, isn't a saw plate a sideways beam with respect to kinking .... and a plate twice as thick (i.e .016 vs .008) would have 4 times the bend (kink) resistance????

Cheers -

Rob

(who works with theories... but always buids models!)

Re: Speaking of saws...

#15

Re: Well...

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

So you got backsaws to kink?

If that does not constitute a trade secret, what's the minimum thickness that's reasonably safe from kinking?

Just curious,

DC

Re: Speaking of saws...

#16

Re: Well...

Rob Lee

Hi Denis -

Not a trade secret - just not sure of the answer... other than "I know it when I use it"!

Cheers -

Rob

Re: Speaking of saws...

#17

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Re: Well...

Jim in River Oaks, Ont.

Where have I heard that before??

;-)

take care,

Jim

Re: Speaking of saws...

#18

Re: Speaking of saws...

Adam Cherubini

DC, you can buckle any saw, independently of the spine. I made several thin plate prototypes of my DT saw. I kept everything the same except the plate thickness. Saws with plates under .012, buckled in use and generally weren't great to use. The plate might move sideways on the initial stroke.

You can change the form factor and get thinner plates to work just fine. You may be limited to 1" depth or less. You also have to make the teeth match the blade thickness.

I liked what Rob wrote above. I think I too have the theory figured out, but I had to make prototypes. My thing is, I was looking to optimize saws for specific cuts in specific woods. DT saws behave differently in QS than plain sawn stuff for example. One minor point of clarification- moment of inertia is depth cubed not squared, so what Rob was saying about saws being sensitive to plate thickness is even more true than he stated.

Thin saws don't necessarily cut faster. That's a myth spread by Japanese saw merchants. Generally, longer saws cut faster.

Re: Speaking of saws...

#19

Plate thickness

Bob Hackett

One thing that hasn`t been brought up yet is that a saw plate can also be made in an inverted V shape with the teeth being the widest point.This is basically what a taper ground plate is all about.Leave the plate thick at the teeth where that will help with strength and require little or no set and then put an applied back and you have a strong yet thin saw.

Why go to all the trouble to make thin fragile saw plate and then increase the kerf by cranking set into the teeth?

I understand that making a plate like this would be labor intensive but if you want max strength and are making a one off for yourself then why not sharpen up the sen and get to work?

Re: Speaking of saws...

#20

Re: Speaking of saws... and pulling

ThomD

"Thin saws don't necessarily cut faster. That's a myth spread by Japanese saw merchants. Generally, longer saws cut faster."

I'm surprised you could come up with a Japanese Saw Merchant who could think of only one reason a Japanese saw would cut fast/faster. i would have thought several would have tumbled out at once. The whole using two hands rather than one, seems obvious. Or the deep gullets that allow small teeth and thin steel to not bog down, in the cut... Etc... Etc...

It is an interesting point though. I mean why would anyone prefer to use a thin bladed saw?

Moving along...

The pull stroke has one geometric nicety that has nothing to do with body mechanics or holding the steel taught. A major factor is the way the teeth are positioned relative to the handle, allowing them to hook into the wood. Picture an anchor, the harder you pull on the stock the deeper the flukes want to bury themselves into the ground. When you push a western plane or saw, you have the geometry of a shovel, not an anchor. This causes the engagement to be much less positive, and leads to stuff like planes that weigh 9 pounds rather than under a pound in the same use. The weight is there to hold the stuttering western plane or saw in the cut. Should you ever need a plane for use on a desert island with no resharpening possible, choose the pull plane. It will keep cutting long after the edge is heavily rounded over, the geometry is that aggressive.

Back to the OP, there are a number of saws that use Japanese teeth on the push. There are the German bow saws that have rather abruptly changed over to Japanese blades, not that successful in my mind, though they could be. I bought several push Japanese saws from LV at one point. A dreadful looking plastic handled job, a backsaw, that works beautifully. Incongruously paired in my shop with my Independence dovetail saws. I also have a gents style saw, I think came from LW. The push combo saw was quite popular at a transitional point when the tooth style, if not the pulling, had gained acceptance. A lot of toolbox saws where built that way.