New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Western Saw with Japanese Pull style teeth?

Posts

Western Saw with Japanese Pull style teeth?

#1

Western Saw with Japanese Pull style teeth?

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

Just out of curiosity....

I like the way you hold Westerns style joinery saws. But I much prefer the blades, teeth and pull set of Japanese saws. So does anyone make a good western grip saw with a Japanese blade?

Tom

Re: Western Saw with Japanese Pull style teeth?

#2

Re: Western Saw with Japanese Pull style teeth?

Joe Rogers, Northern Virginia

There was such an animal in an old Garrett Wade catalog I had. Given G.W.'s product line lately I don't have a clue if they still have it or where to look for one.

JR

Re: Western Saw with Japanese Pull style teeth?

#3

Re: Western Saw with Japanese Pull style teeth?

wilbur

I think that the main issue is that the mechanics of pulling a saw are different enough from pushing a saw that you can't just switch blades and keep the same handle, and expect that everything will work the same. Otherwise, we'd all be singing the praises of the straight handled dovetail saw.


Re: Western Saw with Japanese Pull style teeth?

#4

Re: Western Saw with Japanese Pull style teeth?

Frank D. in Montreal

I'M no saw expert by any stretch, but I've thought a little about this. I don't think that Western handles are meant to be used while pulling. If you look at the position of the hand with respect to the teeth on what seems like the closest thing to a Western saw (a Japanese carpentry saw), the hand still seems to be more horizontal and lower (see the LV saw below). The posture that a Western saw makes you adopt (the muscles and joints it forces you to use) could make it less precise than a Japanese-style handle on the pull (you'd have to use your bicep and fold your arm...). The horns on a Western saw would also become somewhat of a liability on the pull, just getting in the way instead of stabilizing the hand like they do on the push stroke.

FWIW


img

Re: Western Saw with Japanese Pull style teeth?

#5

Re: Western Saw with Japanese Pull style teeth?

charlie belden

Lee Valley carried a "Gent's Saw" that cuts on the pull stroke. Very fine teeth and great for sawing dovetails in softwoods, slow in hardwoods. Depends on your patience level. I think they also had a western handled pull saw.

Robin?