New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

How QS does white oak have to be for ray flecks?

Posts

How QS does white oak have to be for ray flecks?

#1

How QS does white oak have to be for ray flecks?

wilbur

I have some flat sawn 8/4 white oak, and I need some thin strips of QS white oak for a small project. I thought that I might be able to get away with ripping some strips of the flat sawn piece and using the edge face to get the ray flecks.

Of course, the very edges of the board are rift sawn, technically speaking, so there aren't any ray flecks to be seen. I'd like to preserve as much of this board as possible. Do ray flecks only really show up in white oak if you are real close to 90�? How far off can you be and still get ray flecks?

Re: How QS does white oak have to be for ray flecks?

#2

Re: How QS does white oak have to be for ray fleck *LINK*

Bob Lang

Technically speaking a quarter sawn board has the growth rings between 60 and 90 degrees to the face. But you still might see some flake if you're in the neighborhood of 60, say 45 degrees and up. You won't really know until you cut it though.


How they cut it at Frank Miller

Re: How QS does white oak have to be for ray flecks?

#3

Re: How QS does white oak have to be for ray fleck

Sgian Dubh

You'll start to see the ray flecks when the annual growth rings meet the wide face of a board at about 65- 70�. At these angles the flecks may be quite hard to spot, but they'll tend to appear as ribbony stripes. The closer the growth rings are to perpendicular (greater than those angle) to the wide face of the board, the more flamboyant and flake like will the medulla become.

Rift sawn usually refers to boards where the growth rings intersect the wide faces at between 30� and 60�.

Figured boards are generally described as those where the growth rings intersect the wide faces at between 60� and 80�.

'1/4 Sawn' or radially sawn generally refers to boards where the growth rings intersect the wide faces at between 80� and 90�: Americans quite commonly use the term vertical grain for this cut.

Of course, you may already know these definitions and I'm teaching you how to suck eggs. If so I apologise for that. Slainte.

Re: How QS does white oak have to be for ray flecks?

#4

Re: How QS does white oak have to be for ray fleck

wilbur

Right, like I'll ever get to the point where I won't have anything to learn from you Richard. ;)

Or Bob Lang, for that matter. ;)

Re: How QS does white oak have to be for ray flecks?

#5

Re: How QS does white oak have to be for ray fleck

Dave Mount

As indicated above, the issue is how defined the ray figure needs to be to meet your goals. The table pictured below (not mine, found with Google images) shows a range of what might be expected as one moves from 60-90 degrees. The left/rearward portion has to be very, very close to 90 to get that long (across the width) figure. However, rays in oak don't always grow in a dead straight line from pith to bark, they arc sometimes. When they do, you can get stretches of strong figure even when the grain is off 90 a little. The board second from the right is starting to come off 90, maybe 85 -- you can almost see the angle on the edge of the table. The middle is more like 80 degrees, and on either side of that you're getting down to circa 70 degrees.

As an aside, I find the mishmash of QS figure on this table pretty jarring.

Since you mention that you're making narrow strips, be advised that QS oak figure doesn't usually appear very strong on narrow strips. Even if you hit it perfectly at 90 degrees, you won't see those long undulating stripes, you'll just see a tiny piece of it which doesn't really capture the typical drama of high grade QS oak. So you may be worrying about it more than it is worth, depdending on the setting those thin strips are appearing in.

Best,

Dave


img

Re: How QS does white oak have to be for ray flecks?

#6

Re: How QS does white oak have to be for ray fleck

Sgian Dubh

Incidentally wilbur, rift sawn is also sometimes known as bastard cut, and the term isn't intended as a curse or in any way pejorative. Slainte.

Re: How QS does white oak have to be for ray flecks?

#7

Re: How QS does white oak have to be for ray fleck

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

If you've developed a neat, clean way to suck eggs, let's hear it. :)

Pam

Re: How QS does white oak have to be for ray flecks?

#8

Re: How QS does white oak have to be for ray fleck

Sgian Dubh

I'm not a grannie Pam. As far as I know grannies are the experts in the art of sucking eggs cleanly. My grannie never demonstrated the technique to me, ha, ha. Slainte.

Re: How QS does white oak have to be for ray flecks?

#9

Re: How QS does white oak have to be for ray fleck

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Yeah, if my crazy grannie sucked eggs I was never around her to see; but my other grannie was too busy reading mysteries and shopping for antiques and hand made furniture to engage me in egg sucking. She did happen to instill a love for the hand made, though.

Pam

Re: How QS does white oak have to be for ray flecks?

#10

As with many things...

Bob Hackett

It`s a figure of speech.

I think you`ll find it much easier to empty an egg if you make two small holes at each end and blow till you get enough pressure to force the now scrambled contents out of the intact shell.

And yes,my Granny is the one who showed me that trick. :D

Re: How QS does white oak have to be for ray flecks?

#11

Re: How QS does white oak have to be for ray fleck

James Watriss

Ripping by hand or with a table saw? Ripping that much white oak stock by hand would almost have me running for the lumber yard.

Remember, you can tilt the blade to get closer to the required angle for optimum fleck. I find that closer to 90 is better. The strip will be wider than 8/4, but you can always rip the edges back to square. Depending on how confident you are with this trick, it may be worth ripping a strip off of the board, using a plane to bevel the edge until you get closer to optimum fleck, and using that bevel edge to re-align your saw blade, and rip again.

Also depends on the piece of wood. Some boards are closer to the center of the tree, and 90 degrees to the rings will shift much faster, so you may get a lot less fleck as you progress through the board than you wanted.