New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Method of work - Squaring up stock

Posts

Method of work - Squaring up stock

#1

Method of work - Squaring up stock

Al R.

Just a uick poll for you folks - I am making a picture frame 11 by 18 inches. I have a nice piece of pine that I will be ripping down to provide three of the 4 sides of the frame.

Would you flatten the face of the whole piece first and then cut the lengths needed out of it or would you cut it to rough length first and then flatten the faces of the three resulting pieces of wood?

In the past I have flattened the entire board first and then cut what I needed out of it, but I'm thinking that I'll have more accurate joinery if I flatten the smaller pieces individually. Since the ends of the pieces that create the joint will surely be out of wind if worked individually, wheras there may be some slight wind left if they were flattened as part of a larger whole.

Thanks.

Al R.

Re: Method of work - Squaring up stock

#2

Re: Method of work - Squaring up stock

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Rough size first, then flatten.

Re: Method of work - Squaring up stock

#3

Re: Method of work - Squaring up stock

JimG

Agreed. Much easier to deal with any winding or warp.

Re: Method of work - Squaring up stock

#4

Re: Method of work - Squaring up stock

Jerry Gibbs

What do you mean by rough length. 12" is too short. 36" is ideal for me to joint and plane.

Re: Method of work - Squaring up stock

#5

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Method of work - Squaring up stock

Jack Guzman from Maine

If a 36" board has alot of wind you have to remove quite a bit of material to get it flat.If you cut it into 12" lengths(assuming that's close to what you need) there is less material to remove to get it flat.This is alot easier to see in a badly twisted board. You are trying to get one end of the board even to the other end 36" away.If you cut it, the first end doesn't have to relate to the last end because it is on a different board.I think I'm starting to confuse myself. Maybe someone else can say it better.---Jack

Re: Method of work - Squaring up stock

#6

Re: Method of work - Squaring up stock

Bob Hackett

If there`s a lot of distortion cut it to rough length and then square it.

If you`re using relatively stable wood and the long board is close to flat then square it as one piece.That`s been my experience.

I think we may be trying to wander off into the trap of one answer fits all applications again.

The important thing is to remain flexible in your approach to the work.Use experience and your own judgment as only you have the material in front of you and can see what happens as you work it.The rest of us are just guessing based upon what has worked for us.

Having had completely different experiences with lumber taken from different areas of the same tree.I can tell you that nothing will go exactly as the book says.

That`s just part of the challenge of woodworking.

Re: Method of work - Squaring up stock

#7

Re: Method of work - Squaring up stock

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Generally it is faster to true up the smaller pieces. As others have said there is less wind to deal with in narrower or shorter pieces. In cutting to narrower widths, the cupping is also reduced. When cut to length, the planing strokes are short and quick. There are some benefits to precision also, because a board can distort when a significant portion of the width is cut away.

Here are some exceptions. For pieces with moulding, the moulding is more uniform if it is done in one long run rather than piecemeal. For very short pieces planing is awkward and it is best to make several pieces together. For me 6-8" long is fine, 3-4" long is awkward.

Re: Method of work - Squaring up stock

#8

Re: Method of work - Squaring up stock

Roy Anderson

I think the advice you've been getting here is right on the money. Therefore, I should just be quite. Not!

I've always said the best truing tool is a cross cut saw. Since wind and warp are progressive flaws, you stop it by cutting the piece off. Then you have less to take off and the next piece starts from zero. Same works for cup, so ripping to rough width helps in the same way.