New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

I guess my wife is right

Posts

I guess my wife is right

#1

I guess my wife is right

David Miller from Iowa

So our first grandbaby is coming to stay for a week over the holiday - crawling age. But we have a treacherous stairwell. So my wife tells me to go buy a baby gate at the store. They were all cheap and ugly, so I tell her I'll just make one. And she says there you go again, we just need a baby gate, not a huge cherry wood project that will be mission style to match all the cupboards (which I also made). Just go buy a cheap one, she says, you always make everything into a big deal. I hate it when she knows what i will do before I know myself.


Re: I guess my wife is right

#2

Yeah, but just for the record

Bruce, a MN Galoot

She was right, and you did a great job! It looks like it belongs there. Nice work.

Re: I guess my wife is right

#3

I'd say half-right

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

that one doesn't look like it took too awfully long a time - and it's way, way better looking than the cheap ones.

Re: I guess my wife is right

#4

Re: I guess my wife is right

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

Hey....if you are gonna do a job....do it right! BTW....I love those bullet hinges....nice touch.

Tom

Re: I guess my wife is right

#5

Moses Yoder

Re: Question

Moses Yoder

It looks great, I like the hinges. How did you attach the diagonal piece to the stiles?

Re: I guess my wife is right

#6

Re: Question

David Miller from Iowa

The hinges are lift-off boat hardware - I can lift the gate right off, although I put some tension in them so the child would have a harder time getting them off.

I just glued and nailed the diagonal brace on - it starts and ends in a mortise in the sides. Just put a spot of glue on the intersection, clamped it and shot it with an air pin nailer

Re: I guess my wife is right

#7

When my SO says that,

Chuck Nickerson

she's implying it won't get done in time. She's almost always correct.

Re: I guess my wife is right

#8

looks great but........

Larry Williams

I'm impressed David but there is one thing. I always do what I can to put diagonal braces in compression rather than tension. In tension you're depending on fasteners and compression uses the strength of the wood with the fasteners or joinery just playing a supporting role.

Re: I guess my wife is right

#9

Re: looks great but........

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Are you saying you'd have built the diagonal to go from top left to bottom right? And if so, how is it that would be compression, because the bottom right is stationary of sorts?

Thanks,

Pam, who thought she understood compression and tension, but maybe not

Re: I guess my wife is right

#10

Moses Yoder

Re: looks great but........

Moses Yoder

I think he is saying the pressure would go on the top left as you are looking at the gate picture, wich would pull the diagonal down, putting it in tension. If the diagonal ran from top left to bottom right and you put pressure on the top left it would put compression on the diagonal. I guess it is about the same thing as using yellow glue for veneering ;)

Re: I guess my wife is right

#11

That is beautiful work

Jay Samuels

Almost makes up for that picture of the 55.

Re: I guess my wife is right

#12

Re: I guess my wife is right

R Payne

I think if she was really ok with a cheap, ugly, plastic thing she would have bought one herself. Since she asked you to buy it, knowing you'd make it instead, she didn't really want a cheap, ugly, plastic thing. She's just giving you grief.

nice work.

ron

Re: I guess my wife is right

#13

Thanks, Moses, that's what I figured.

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Re: I guess my wife is right

#14

You're right Larry

David Miller from Iowa

I mocked it up both ways and, of course, you are right that wood is always better under longitudinal compression than tension, but it didn't look as good to me. Doubt that it will matter with this little 4 pound gate, but your point is certainly valid.

Re: I guess my wife is right

#15

Another question

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi David

That is waaay better than the one I built. I particularly like the posts on the corners - that is a great detail. One question: when the little tyke is not around, and you do not need the gate (it might be a pain to open/shut frequently) ... assuming that the construction stays ... is the gate left open (along the wall?), and if so, how is it held/kept that way?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: I guess my wife is right

#16

Re: Another question

David Miller from Iowa

The concept for this is to to install and remove as needed but,despite being somewhat massive, it did need a good anchor system. I originally was going to anchor each side pillar into the hardwood floor, but I just couldn't bring myself to screw into the ash flooring which would leave scars when the gate was put away.

Happily, there are some major structural beams behind the drywall in this location, and each side pillar is locked in with just one (quite substantial) screw horizontally through the middle attaching it to the wall. There will be a drywall scar, one on each side, but I'll make a cute little finial plug button to stick in there when the gate is put away.