New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Clamping a bench plane tote

Posts

Clamping a bench plane tote

#1

Clamping a bench plane tote

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

There are periodic discussions of how to repair a broken bench plane tote. Many of these breaks are clean, and most of the breaks I've encountered are roughly in the middle of the height of the tote (clearly a highly stressed area).

For these, I've found cleaning off splinters and gluing with yellow glue adequate (I use Titebond II, because that's what I have most often around the shop). I've repaired several without cleaning the wood surface, but have started wiping it down with acetone right before gluing, based on the statements that folks have made that the rosewood is oily.

I then clamp it with one of those trigger-type bar clamps, as in the picture below (I'm in the midst of cleaning up a Stanley 62 at the moment). This has worked fine. My hypothesis is that the soft plastic jaw pad, coupled with the flex in the plastic jaws, grips the tote well enough to transmit clamping force in a straight line through the length of the tote. You can see that it's pulled up the crack quite effectively, since it's no longer visible (it's roughly in the middle of the darker area halfway up the tote, the darker wood being wet from wiping off glue squeeze-out with a wet paper towel).

I apologize for forgetting a before picture to go with this after picture; I almost always seem to forget in-process pictures.


Re: Clamping a bench plane tote

#2

I hope you have better luck than me...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

Every broken tote I've repaired with yellow glue (titebond 2 & 3) has failed. I did the same as you did using acetone to clean and de-oil the parts, clamped them as you showed, or ran a long carriage bolt through the tote and tightened it down with nuts and flat washers. Same result, within a few days they broke at the glue line.

I've only had luck with epoxy. None of these have ever failed as of yet.

Re: Clamping a bench plane tote

#3

can't argue with what's worked for you

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

maybe you're a more athletic plane user than I am.

The bolt through the handle is a clever clamping idea - certainly, it tightens up in the right direction.

Re: Clamping a bench plane tote

#4

Dale Lenz

Re: I hope you have better luck than me...

Dale Lenz

Why not epoxy and clamp with plane's tote screw to the plane, worked for me once and still holding.

Re: Clamping a bench plane tote

#5

Lucky break

David Miller from Iowa

I've tried to do this several times and have never had a break geometry that allowed me to clamp it the way you show. Even if you can get the clamp to hold without kicking the piece out the side, it still would give uneven pressure.

Not saying it can't be done, just saying I gave up trying to do this and instead spend my time buying busted planes with good totes. Kind of funny that if you search eBay for a decent tote removed from the plane you are going to pay $20 and up, but you can buy a busted plane with a good tote for a couple bucks and ask the seller to just send that and save shipping. I do the same thing at auctions - buy the busted ones for a couple bucks even though it has decent wood.

I was hard up for money about 6 months ago and took some nice totes and knobs, sanded and spray lacquered them and got more than $50 a set on eBay.


Re: Clamping a bench plane tote

#6

Re:Nice labeling system

George in Lowell, Mich.

Re: Clamping a bench plane tote

#7

Dammit man!

Bob Hackett

You have alerted the masses to our nefarious plot!

Luckily we have enough in reserve between the two of us to tilt the balance in our favor.

What were you thinking???

I just hate it when Dave goes off his meds. ;)