Wooden bicycle. *LINK*
Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA
I thought this was pretty cool...
Wired Magizne
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Wooden bicycle. *LINK*
Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA
I thought this was pretty cool...
Wired Magizne
You're right
Bruce, a MN Galoot
except that it's very cool! At that price the builder isn't even getting a couple bucks an hour. I don't think I'd like to crash it, though.
And they're not alone *LINK*
Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA
In fact, as the linky points out, wooden bicycles are reaching back to their historical roots.
I was trying to find the glue-laminated bicycle dating from the vicinity of World War II of which I've seen pictures before - but it wasn't surfacing.
For fun, google both "wooden bicycles" and "bamboo bicycles." There are some truly amazing machines out there, and apparently, in parts of the world, people are building them semi-routinely as daily runners, not frames costing $3,000.
Truly cool, all of them.
But, as always, give a gearhead a chance, and a motor will show up...Daimler just couldn't resist motorizing his velocipede...and then look where we wound up.
http://www.alternative-energy-news.info/wood-bicycles/
Re: And they're not alone
ThomD
On this framebuilding forum I contribute to, "real" bike frame threads get like 200 views. Bamboo bike frame threads get thousands, very trendy. There are some practical advantages to making these fiber frames. There is a lot of expense, etc... associated with undoing the damage to precision parts caused from welding or brazing heat.
I`m not following
Bob Hackett
Why would precision parts be exposed to heat from brazing,and if they were stressed by the heat then why wouldn`t they simply stress relieve them by one of the many proven methods available?
In everything I`ve ever done from cars to boats to motorcycles I`ve never had any problems with what you`re talking about.Why would a bicycle be any different?
Re: I`m not following
ThomD
Because the frames weight 6 pounds and the add on parts generally don't bolt on, and the metal is as little as .5mm thick. So the main parts of concern are the bottom bracket, the head tube and the seat tube where the seat post is inserted. All of these deform from heat, sometimes a little severely. Then they have to be recut, which requires about 500-1000 dollars of specialized tools. Many of the cheaper tools do not get the job done to a custom level. For the most part one can't finesse this stuff, there are some work arounds, but largely one needs to have the tools. One exception being composite manufacturing where heat does not get used.
So imagine it was a car frame, or a motorbike. The head tube on even an integral bearing motorcycle, weighs almost as much as a bike frame, the wall tubing is so thick it doesn't distort appreciably in welding. If bikes where car frames, the place where the seat and down tube meet would probably be a flat plate, and the BB would be a pillow block that bolts on, not a thin wall tube with very fine threads. 
Re: Wooden bicycle.
James Watriss
That is very cool, but he sissied out on the wheels.
There are still (I forget where) people making wooden rims for bicycle wheels. And I remember reading that they're really good at absorbing a lot of road vibrations.
Re: Wooden bicycle.
ThomD
Wooden rims are as stock item if not in most places. The road vibe idea sounds unlikely to me. By the way did you know a wheel stands on the spokes on the bottom, and doesn't hang from the spokes on top. Still trying to believe that one.
I think part of the point of these wooden frames is that they are good therefore they feel entitled to use whatever component parts will make the best bike using the wooden frame rather than choosing other components based on their woodiness.
There was a small story in Epoxyworks on this subject:
http://epoxyworks.com/
Once again I`m not following
Bob Hackett
Are you saying a spoke is used primarily in compression rather than tension?
If you are then I would have to respectfully disagree.
Re: Once again I`m not following
ThomD
Who wouldn't disagree, but yeah, that is what I am saying. The more or less recognized expert in these maters is Jobst Brandt. There is a lot of argument about whether he is right or not, normally by people who wouldn't know either way. The argument seems to rely on the idea that a tension member (in this case a spoke) can be loaded in compression. It would seem to me that must be a simple mater of fact. If it is possible, then what Jobst is saying is possible.
What he says happens in a wheel (I hope) is that when it is loaded, all the spokes in the wheel remain additionally relatively untensioned, except several on the bottom that experience a loss of tension. Ergo then it is standing on it's spokes as would a wagon wheel with solid spokes. What most people want to think is happening, is that as the wheel rolls around there is tension on all spokes, but the load is carried by the upper spokes, more than the others. Therefore the lower spokes are simply being relaxed and the upper spokes are taking up the slack. But what about the case where relatively speaking there is nothing like that amount of deformation possible, and the readings show only the lower spokes are changing their load?
As mentioned not everyone agrees, but given JB's expertise, I would be pretty shocked if the basic principle he describes isn't even present in engineering. However it is a complicated subject to get past the clutter on in a google search, and I couldn't ferret out a compressing a tension member result.
Re: Better answer
ThomD
Actually the obvious reason for not using wooden rims would be if one prefers clincher tires. Wooden rims are better adapted to sew ups, which are a not much fun to fix flats on, or otherwise service. Clinchers are the tires we are all familiar with that one needs tire irons to remove. They require a c section that can take massive outward pressure.
Re: Once again I`m not following
CJ in MPLS
"But what about the case where relatively speaking there is nothing like that amount of deformation possible, and the readings show only the lower spokes are changing their load?"
The spokes are still loaded in tension even if a bit of compression lessens the amount of tension. We can intuit that the few bottom spokes aren't supporting the entire weight (or 1/2 half the weight of the bike and rider) by simply asking someone to remove all the other spokes from their wheels and get on the bike.
The kind of pre-stressing that spokes are put under is the flip side of the pre-stressing that concrete beams are placed under, i.e. tension v. compression.
It would be kind of cool to coat each spoke in a piezoelectric material and wire up an LED to see what kind of energy the changing stress levels might create.
CJ
Re: Once again I`m not following
ThomD
"The spokes are still loaded in tension even if a bit of compression lessens the amount of tension. We can intuit that the few bottom spokes aren't supporting the entire weight (or 1/2 half the weight of the bike and rider) by simply asking someone to remove all the other spokes from their wheels and get on the bike."
By the way, that presumably wouldn't work either with a wooden wagon wheel where the individual spokes presumably work like columns. Take away all the other spokes and it would collapse. So I don't think that example is clean enough. It's certainly counter intuitive with spokes because anyone who has built wheels knows they are strung in place, and there isn't even a point of mechanical purchase that would support a compressive load being passed through, at least to the layman. My brain definitely screams he is pushing on string.
Re: Once again I`m not following
ThomD
This stuff is above my pay grade, but Brandt uses the concrete example in support of his point. He says you can do exactly the test you suggest by sitting squarely on the bike, while having someone pluck the same spoke while it is positioned in different points around the clock face. What he says and others have confirmed, while others still have denied, is that the pitch varies only in the 6 o'clock position. While the standard view would suggest highest at 12, medium at 3 and 9 and lowest at 6. What I don't know is whether the pitch at 12 varies with a person on or off the bike. But it is still claimed that under load the 6 o'clock position is the only one with a relative pitch variation. This is one of those huge flame generators in cycling.
"
Topic : Bicycle Wheel Loading (1999) : Eric Salathe initially wrote : "The Bicycle Wheel is beautifully written, but the persistent lack of acceptance of this idea among its readers, as well documented on this list, shows that the 'wheel stands on its lower spokes' slogan does not accomplish its function."
JB's reply : "I chose not to condescend and state anything other than what is engineering fact, explaining why and how the wheel works. I know that many people have great difficulty visualizing this and I believe that is why the wire spoked wheel remained misunderstood and not analyzed until "the Bicycle Wheel" was published. Previously many authors wrote extensively about what they believed took place. None of these recognized that the top spokes or, for that matter, any other spokes of the wheel were affected by the vertical load except the bottom few in the tire contact zone. That loads only unload spokes was also not understood. When a wheel is overloaded or crashed to destruction, none of its spokes are overloaded (other than possibly being kinked after becoming slack).
I am fairly sure that the whole subject is still a mystery to most people who should understand it. I overhear conversations and see postings here that reveal these misconceptions. Even people who seem to grasp the concept have said as much as "I crashed my wheel and have to get all new spokes". Progress is slow in coming.""
See the whole interview here:
http://cozybeehive.blogspot.com/2010/03/learning-jobst-brandt-part-iii.html
Interesting that one educated critic of his work sited does not question the standing on it's spokes issue.
Sounds like...
Bob Hackett
This may be another case of "In theory there is no difference between theory and practice.In practice there is."
At the 6 oclock position there is nothing to hold the spoke in compression except the pressure of the inflated tube pushing on the end of the spoke nipple.There is no solid mechanical connection that allows the spoke to be loaded in a compression mode.
You could argue(and I`m sure some have) that the reason there is only a marked change in tone at the 6 oclock position is due to localized flexing of the rim in contact with the road or ground surface.
Seems to me that someone has confused a diminishing of tension forces with loading by compression.
Quick way to test this theory;If you release pressure from the top most spoke(loosen the nipple and relieve the tension) what happens? now if you put the bottom spoke into a neutral (neither tension nor compression) mode what happens?
Unless you are using spokes that vary greatly from the ones I have been using the results speak for themselves regardless of theory and no matter how much and where the tone changes.Without a close tolerance, solid mechanical connection between the rim and the nipple that allows for the spoke function in compression this theory doesn`t hold water where the rubber meets the road(literally).
And I thought hand plane users were experts at complicating seemingly simple things. 
Re: Sounds like...
ThomD
"Sounds to me" isn't going to cut it. His book has been out there for over 20 years, and he is a highly public figure in this small field. If there was a knockout punch, someone would have landed it long ago. As I said above, The guy who did that interview tried to dredge up a critical voice, another engineer, and so called legal expert in bike maters. The guy's only quibble was a misinterpretation of one of Jobst's graphical representation of lateral loads on spokes. The stand on its spokes thing is known to everyone and very prominently placed in the book. No comment.
I have no opinion one way or the other on the issue, Beyond me. Jobst is obviously a prominent and possibly brilliant engineer, but he doesn't have the credentials to drive a stake through the heart of the opposition. No Paul Krugman like CV, OK bad example...
Actually, in the review, the reviewer takes a novel approach. He doesn't question the truth of the standing on spokes thing, probably isn't an engineer, but he asks why bother since so far, nobody has seemed to get it. It has obviously contributed nothing to the understanding of wheels. Jobst's response is that he just tells it like it is. But it is an interesting point. Jobst presents the idea about a dozen pages into the book, thereby guaranteeing universal vapour lock early in the discussion.
Re: Once again I`m not following
CJ in MPLS
I don't check the website often so I apologize for bringing this thread back from the dead. The wagon wheel would support the wagon on only a couple of spokes loaded in compression. They'd just fail if the wheel was turned so that the few spokes were loaded in anything other than compression. That is how a wagon wheel works, by transferring the load from the rim to the axle in compression. I'm not aware of any joints in a wooden wagon wheel that would be capable of maintaining any significant tension though I must admit that my sum total of experience with wooden wagon wheel construction comes from watching The Woodwright's Shop.
In any case, this would be a good candidate for an engineering student's thesis. My own experience with FEA ended with an old 2D version of ANSYS back in the early 90's and I still haven't learned how to build 3D models in CAD programs. But them I'm an attorney now and no longer an engineer. 
CJ
Re: Once again I`m not following
ThomD
"I'm not aware of any joints in a wooden wagon wheel that would be capable of maintaining any significant tension though I must admit that my sum total of experience with wooden wagon wheel construction comes from watching The Woodwright's Shop."
Yeah me, too. As a non-engineer or lawyer (I'm guessing what kind of law you do
), I'm guessing the argument, if one was required would be if a wheel had to hang from a spoke (areal cartway or something), that the preload from shrinking the rim would compress the spoke in it's sockets to the degree that so long as the hanging loads were well under the compressing loads, it would all be fine. An interesting example of that, well maybe, is when the Windsor institute people came to the conclusion that windsor rungs actually operated in compression and not tension. Well, at least similar in it's capacity to generate arguments... 
"In any case, this would be a good candidate for an engineering student's thesis. My own experience with FEA ended with an old 2D version of ANSYS back in the early 90's and I still haven't learned how to build 3D models in CAD programs. But them I'm an attorney now and no longer an engineer.
"
Yeah well the thing there is that Brandt isn't just a student, he is an engineer who has had roles with Porsche, The Standford Linear Accelerator Center, HP, and Avocet the bike tire people; He didn't just write a thesis, he published a book on the subject, and it has had 20 years of "peer" review, not all of it supportive, but watcha going to do; The Book included FEA analysis of the wheel structural system, I think he designed his own software to do that, or he may have done it "manually".
I think people who are interested should read his book, particularly those with the appropriate technical background. Reading Jobst's book isn't making me any smarter, but for technical people who don't read it, the same is the case.
No thanks
Bob Hackett
I think I`ll just keep riding on those wheels and be happy they keep my butt off the pavement in whatever manner they choose to be appropriate.
Theory isn`t near important enough to wade off into a thick,dry,complicated engineering book,especially when a new episode of Dexter is on. 
Dexter's back?! Can't wait for the dvd.
Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX
Re: No thanks
CJ in MPLS
"Theory isn`t near important enough to wade off into a thick,dry,complicated engineering book,especially when a new episode of Dexter is on.
"
There are those who would state that 90% of the threads on this website involve wading off into thick, dry, complicated engineering.
But then, I love arguing/discussing this stuff (and arguing/discussing in generally for that matter).
And I must say that I've never seen Dexter but season 5 of Doctor Who just came out. The new Doctor is pretty good.
Here's hoping you don't fall off the bike.
Cheers,
CJ
Too late
Bob Hackett
Fell off,landed on head,ouch!
Good thing I was wearing my DOT approved helmet, reflective vest,Hand,elbow,shoulder and knee guards as well as protective footgear with lights in the heels(powered by rechargeable batteries) and a huge CAUTION sign strapped to my butt.NOT!!
That would explain the summons I got.
Unfortunately someone lifted my wallet while I was unconscious and now all my credit cards are maxed out so I`ll have to throw myself on the mercy of the court and do at least 2 years more time than a coke dealing murderer who`ll get out on good behavior after ratting out his cellmate.
I should have just downed a few quick drinks and took the car. 
Re: Too late
Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX
Or pull a Dexter, go out and murder someone society would be better off without and make the crime invisible. Then you can feel good while serving your now fee-based crime time. 
Pam