New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Method of attack?

Posts

Method of attack?

#1

Method of attack?

Edward in Vancouver

Making some butcher-bock style cutting boards for christmas, basically 64 blccks of 11/4" hard maple

I currently have 8 strips of maple glued up, with the intention of cutting thse strips crosswise and glueing them end-grain up.

A rank beginner, I am at the stage where I can put some kind of an edge on my irons and clean up my blocks of strips without any tear-out, and keeping the block fairly flat--no more than 1/64" of light peeking out when I place my straight-edge across.

My "challange" is cleaning up the block when it is all glued up and ALL end grain.

My weapons available are: a bu smoother, a bu jack, a #6, a #80, a handyman #4 set up as a scrub, and various scrapers.

Of course a belt sander would do it nasty quick, but I don't own one, I wouldn't mind getting a toothed iron for my bu jack though...

What is the best method of attack for cleaning up all-end grain?

Thanks,

Edward

Re: Method of attack?

#2

Re: Method of attack?

ThomD

The best is a plane with a lot of edge curvature. I have one that uses an ECE blade as sold by LV. I made it up sorta Krenov style. But you could camber an iron for your low angle plane. It is just hard work on the end grain, but with enough camber you can really move some wood. Once you have it clean and level but with lots of ruts from the plane, switch to the heaviest cut you can take with an uber razor sharp blade in the low angle. A fraction of curve is still nice. Get the ruts out and just keep refining the cut and surface in turn - finer cuts, sharper, less curvature.

Re: Method of attack?

#3

Stephen Shepherd

Re: Method of attack?

Stephen Shepherd

Always good to add a tool to your arsenal, like a toothed blade, works great on nasty grain and end grain and for gluing. Tooth off the surface then use card scrapers to finish off.

However I am not sure how well it will work bu?

Stephen

Re: Method of attack?

#4

Moses Yoder

Re: Method of attack?

Moses Yoder

Sorry to say this here but the best method is to take it to a local cabinet shop that has a wide belt sander. It would take them about 5 or 10 minutes per board and cost you peanuts compared to your sore arms and hours of planing. Then take it home and smooth it with your low angle jack. I would bevel the edges first so it does not tear out the grain around the edges.

Re: Method of attack?

#5

Stephen Shepherd

Re: Method of attack?

Stephen Shepherd

This subject came up on the Hand Tool Chat this week. I recommended Not to sand cutting boards. First it puts grit into the wood that can dull hand tools used for further work, sanding should always be done last.

And never sand a cutting board as any impregnated grit will forever dull your knives used on the cutting board.

Stephen

Re: Method of attack?

#6

Re: Method of attack?

John Walkowiak

I have used the LN jack with the toothing blade to level a walnut crotch board. It worked very well, was fast, and there was no tearout. Drop the blade down for an agressive cut to level it then go one or two more, retracting the blade each time. It will then have just fine scratches that can be easily scraped or planed with a finely set and razor sharp plane.Unfortunately, the blade for the LN LA jack won't fit their LA smoother. It could with a bit of machining in the slot area, I don't know why they don't do it.

Re: Method of attack?

#7

Re: Method of attack?

Edward in Vancouver

Thanks for the replys.

I'd love to make a Krenov style plane, but probably won't get around to it for quite some time.

I should have thought about belt sanders before. I've been cooking and baking professionaly for almost 30 years now. Never stopped to think why my knives dulled after processing root vegetables or lobsters.

Toothing iron would make sense, and would fit both my smoother and jack, gives me an excuse to go to LV too. So, toothed iron and copious amounts of alcohol to wet the wood. Whiskey, vodka, or gin?

Stephen, I have your book. Been using hide glue alot for other christmas projects like mini "treasure chests", arched lids with rubbed joints. Whole lot easier than futzing aound with cold glue and masking tape and clamps. But for cutting boards I have to choose another glue.

However, I have found an excellent item to determine whether hide glue was used on old furniture though. It's called a "dog". Couple months ago I was "gifted" (fobbed off) an old mirror frame. Ungratefull beast would only gnaw on the joints, bit through I-don't-know-how-many layers of paint and varnish to get at the glue. Wonder if hide glue ages like fine wine?.....

Re: Method of attack?

#8

Re: Method of attack?

ThomD

If you have a bandsaw, you can put together a Krenov style plane in 45 minutes. It's a very simple job. That said, I was suggesting a similar blade for one of your planes. I'm assuming your initial problem will be getting down to flat, and getting rid of glue and unevenness. Any plane with an adjustable mouth, you need a large one. Just heavily camber the blade.

The main uses for toothing planes are the roughening of the surface for glue, and planing very easily torn wood. you aren't glueing this wood but even if you were, end grain abundantly absorbs glue, and end grain is not normally prone to tear out, unless there was rot.

I have to say I wouldn't worry about sanding the end grain either, it is obviously how they do it in factories. It is rather easy to burn end grain sanding, but there is always a seed, touch and grit that will get it done. A very versatile tool, though it takes some skill, is a 7" disc sander. Very fast. It would be particularly difficult to get a surface level with, but would easily get it to where one could use a finish plane. Not something you will buy, but if you do boats or autos, you might have. Stick on some 40 grit....

Re: Method of attack?

#9

Re: Method of attack?

ThomD

Here is a little clip. Would have been easier if the end of this beam had been in a normal planing attitude.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-tHCxu0PF0k

Re: Method of attack?

#10

Re: Method of attack?

Edward in Vancouver

Thanks for the link. I've got some stratedgies to think about.

In all there'll be three 10" x 10" cutting boards.

Re: Method of attack?

#11

Re: Method of attack?

ThomD

Not too big you could knock those off with a block plane. I tried one of those on my endgrain piece but the plane needed sharpening so I didn't include it.