New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Just a question/thought about tool trays

Posts

Just a question/thought about tool trays

#1

Just a question/thought about tool trays

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

There's a discussion over on Sawmill Creek right now about wall-mounted vs. freestanding benches, and a thought occurred to me as I was posting my response: if I had a freestanding bench, I'm sure I'd regularly knock small stuff off the back side of the bench as I worked. Do those tool troughs at the back of some traditional bench designs serve to catch stuff that would otherwise take a dive, as opposed to being a place to put tools intentionally?

Re: Just a question/thought about tool trays

#2

Jesper, Denmark

Re: They primarily serve to.....

Jesper, Denmark

collect all sorts of debris, flotsam and jetam that you need to remove before you can use the bench. :(

Re: Just a question/thought about tool trays

#3

Well, with a free standing bench...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

There is is no front or back, that's what's nice about them. Other than that, I see a tool tray as trash bin.

Re: Just a question/thought about tool trays

#4

Re: Just a question/thought about tool trays

ThomD

I think trays are like a lot of things in life, they are defined by either a singular advantage or disadvantage. In this case most people agree there is a disadvantage of clutter collecting, but there are a lot of advantages. They aren't long term storage, but they are a good place to put a few things while working on the surface. There are times when you don't want stuff walking off from the vibe, or you need to put something wide on the bench that will cover the surface. I think one also has to look at this from the perspective of multiple benches in a shop where one didn't have a wall to oneself etc... Other advantages are that they allow one to have a reasonable size (cost and weight) beam along the bench front where it is useful, without the cost or movement issues associated with a full width beam. The stuff that falls into the tray was only going to fall somewhere else, possibly down the gap with the wall, not necessarily easier to get to. There are tactics for making the tray easier to clean out.

Re: Just a question/thought about tool trays

#5

Re: Just a question/thought about tool trays

Bob Hackett

What you may find much more useful is something like I like to use,a tool cart.That way the tools are exactly where you want to put them when you need them to be there and that means anywhere in the shop.

If space is at a premium in your shop then make a tool tray like a butler`s tray and one of those folding stands like is used to support a suitcase.Both stand and tray can be hung up on the wall or slipped between rafters overhead when not in use.

Never underestimate the value of any wide,flat,continuous surface.Most trades can`t get enough of a surface like this so why compromise it by interrupting that surface with anything other than what is needed to hold the work to it?Once you do you are stuck with working around that compromise.

If you have room for a tool tray in your bench it means you built your bench too big.

Re: Just a question/thought about tool trays

#6

Jack Guzman from Maine

Depends

Jack Guzman from Maine

Bill,

If you are particular in your neatness, picking up after yourself and keeping organized a tool tray would work for you. But if you are like me and you're constantly finding the clutter getting ahead of the cleaning,a tool tray is only another hole to fill/clean out.

I used to have my bench against the wall. Since I moved it to the center of the room,I find myself working on both sides of the bench-very handy. Now,the right side of the bench(face vise is on the left) is where the clutter ends up.---Jack

Re: Just a question/thought about tool trays

#7

Re: Just a question/thought about tool trays

Paul M.

I made my bench narrow, only about 30" or so. It's up against a wall but there is about a 12" gap between the bench and the wall.

I have an awful habit of not putting things away when I'm done using them. This means that I'm frequently relocating things on my bench and I've sometimes used my workpiece to shove detrius out of the way. The shoving is often towards the back of the bench. Yeah I know that's stupid but it happens. There are many occasions where that tool tray on the back has saved a prized tool from taking the 3 foot fall to death on concrete during one of these space reallocations. I'm really glad I put a tool tray on my bench for that reason.

I don't do a lot of case work (mostly working on guitars now), so the bench is quite overkill for what I'm doing. But when I used to do more casework, I would want to clamp to both the front and back of the bench and the tool tray would often get in the way. I have some 36" 2x3 radiused cauls that I under the bench so that I can use these as clamping points. But it's rather fiddly to hold these in place under the bench while placing the clamps when I do want to clamp to the back of the bench. Luckily that's rare anymore.

Re: Just a question/thought about tool trays

#8

"space reallocations"

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

What a great way to say it. Makes it sound planned and all.

Re: Just a question/thought about tool trays

#9

Re: Just a question/thought about tool trays

ThomD

"If you have room for a tool tray in your bench it means you built your bench too big."

If you need a bench 24 inches wide, I'm a big believer in making the near side twice as thick and the far side can by a piece of plywood in a tray. Huge savings in cost and you get that useful tray. I built my most recent bench just like that except I dispensed with the tray and placed a second beam where the tray would be, and had two sets of dogs and vices so that I could clamp pieces both western and Japanese style. Guess which half of the bench just gets used to hold clutter. I'm happy because I think it looks cool and I didn't pay much for hard maple at the time, it was 2 dollars a bft, though that price is way up these days. But practicality wise there is something to be said for the tray. Not to say that it's right for everyone.

Re: Just a question/thought about tool trays

#10

Re: Just a question/thought about tool trays

RogerT

This subject is very timely for me. On my current bench, just 2x4's and ply, I cobbled together a tool tray, but made a sliding dovetail along the length of one edge so that it could be removable. Does it collect detritus, yes, does it hold tools, yes. Small items, tend to get lost in the bottom of it, especially when hand planing and making lots of shavings. Mine tends to get overfilled, with items sticking above the top of the tray. That in itself is enough to make me crazy.

I am in the process of making a new and proper bench. I am still undecided if it will have a tray or not. If it does, it will be removable. It will likely not be in the center of the bench, but that option is especially appealing when you fabricate covers so you have a total flat surface to work from. The current tray I use, is not full length to the bench, but quite a bit shorter. This allows it the option of moving it further down the bench to free up space to run clamps or do other things.

To sum things up, some days i really like a tray, but most days its just a pain in the rear.

YMMV,

Roger

Re: Just a question/thought about tool trays

#11

Re: Neat freaks?

ThomD

Just wondering. Those of you who don't like your trays because they hold a mess, how would your friends describe you neat freak wise? I'm no neat freak, closer to the opposite, but it does annoy me a little to have something that is hard to keep clean. But at a practicality level it isn't a big deal just scoop the worst of it out and leave it at that. A secondary factor would be how much the bench is a tool vs how much it's a showpiece.

Re: Just a question/thought about tool trays

#12

the tool tray stays...

Scott in Montana

I've been thinking about a new bench for some time and after seeing this post I've done quite a bit of pondering regarding whether I would put a tool tray in this new bench or not. I've decided that I will.

I'm happy with my bench size but want a thicker top with more mass and different vises this time. My current bench is an old Diefenbach with a 24" x 84" top, not including a full length 7" wide tool tray. I have modified the tool tray so that I can lift the bottom out should I need to attach clamps along that edge.

My bench is away from the wall three feet so I can walk around it to address the piece I'm working on from all sides. I do this a lot and the tool tray never seems to hinder me even when working across it. I have also noticed that when my bench top and tool tray is covered by a Masonite sheet I use to protect it during messy glue-ups that I miss the convenience of the tool tray.

The only thing I don't like about the tool tray is cleaning out the saw dust and small pieces of debris. The removable bottom panel has even made this easier; I just flip it up and give it a rap.

Scott in Montana

Re: Just a question/thought about tool trays

#13

Re: Neat freaks?

James Watriss

That's an interesting point.

I'm definitely NOT a neat freak. But from a practicality standpoint, I can see where it would become annoying to lose things like brass screws and the like in a tray full of shavings. That sort of event leads to having to clean out the tray by hand, shaving by shaving. I'm not a neat freak, in part due to expediency and impatience. So, for the sake of expediency and impatience, I'd rather not lose screws and the like in a pile of shavings.

So, maybe you're on the right track...

Re: Just a question/thought about tool trays

#14

Interesting thread

James Watriss

This has been an interesting read. If nothing else, it makes Chris Schwartz' tool tray in the stretchers make a little more sense... but that last minute tool catching feature is definitely something to consider in a shop with concrete floors.

Re: Just a question/thought about tool trays

#15

Re: Neat freaks?

ThomD

Well, not being a neat freak, I loose most of my screws before they reach the bench. :)