New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Advice on replacing plane iron on very old #5

Posts

Advice on replacing plane iron on very old #5

#1

Advice on replacing plane iron on very old #5

DouginDenver

I have a Stanely #5 from the 1915-1920 era handed down in my wife's family that is in remarkable condition. Until I looked it up, I thought it was a well cared for 1960s era plane. I want to actually use it, not look at it. The original iron has a very slight curve about a half inch up from the cutting edge - picture a very mild ski jump ramp - that precludes accuracy, sharpening, and a solid feel. I see I can get a replacement from Stanley, but they are pretty thin. Yesterday I picked up an IBC/Pinnacle iron from Woodcraft. These look like very good quality and online reviewers concur. It was also $45. The price does not bother me if it cuts as good as it looks and holds an edge. The problem is that it is at least a third thicker than the orginal and simply will not work with the orignal opening in the base. I will need to file away some material from the leading edge so the thicker blade can clear the base. Before I take to filing on a 90 year old plane, I thought I'd ask here if others have had to do the same, and if it was worth it? Thanks.

Re: Advice on replacing plane iron on very old #5

#2

Re: Advice on replacing plane iron on very old #5

Neal in San Jose

Family ties aside, your plane is not a collector unless it is in pristine, unused, in the original box condition, and it doesn't sound like it is. As a user, however, it's just about the best version you can hope for. By the time that one was made, all meaningful improvements to the basic Bailey design had been made, and Stanley hadn't started cheapening up the manufacturing. They made about a bazillion of 'em, and many of them have survived, so supply/demand isn't pushing the price up, yet.

Have you tried moving the frog (blade support) back? Loosen up the two machine screws under the blade that holds the frog in place and slide the frog back (there might be a screw just in front of the back handle that you will have to adjust to accomplish that - easier to do than to describe). I have a couple IBC blades in similar planes and have not had any issues with running out of frog adjustment.

I wish I had a plane with family connections; I'm enviousl

Re: Advice on replacing plane iron on very old #5

#3

Re: Advice on replacing plane iron on very old #5

Rob Cosman

Doug, i will be in Denver on the 18th of December at the local Woodcraft doing a half day seminar titled "The Great Hand PLane Revival". I will be in the store on Friday afternoon just hangin out talking to customers and doing a few sharpening demos and the od quick dovetail. You will probably have finished it by then but I will gladly give you any pointers I can. Cheers

Rob

www.robcosman.com

Re: Advice on replacing plane iron on very old #5

#4

Re: Advice on replacing plane iron on very old #5

DouginDenver

I knew it wasn't worth too much, just making the point that it needed no restoration and was worth using. For what it's worth, I do have a 1950 #4 owned by the same relative still in the orignal box. Moving the frog back until the slope of the frog aligns with the slope of the base opening does not help. At that point the blade will just about clear the opening, but there is no room for shavings. No question the opening needs to be larger. Just wondered if people advised against that for some reason.

Re: Advice on replacing plane iron on very old #5

#5

What chip breaker are you using? (long)

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

The original or an after market one? Here's a little something that might be of help from Chris's blog:

"Woodworking Magazine" - 1 new article

When Your Plane Iron Won't Retract All the Way

Reason No. 50 that I dislike chipbreakers: They can prevent your iron from retracting all the way into the mouth of the tool.

Sometimes I think chipbreakers are a cruel joke on the woodworking community. Before chipbreakers (and the invention of pants) everyone was dandy. Nobody had a problem with setting their breaker (or with pantslessness).

But then somebody had to go and invent the breaker/cap iron/second iron/ whatever it is you want to call it. And now we are stuck with it in our Bailey-style bench planes.

It promotes clogging. It adds complexity to the tool. It can interfere with the way the plane's adjuster works. And the problems it causes can be difficult for beginners to diagnose.

Here's one I ran into this weekend. I had almost forgotten about this problem, but it happens a lot and flummoxes even veteran woodworkers who haven't encountered it.

Let's say you tighten up the mouth of your plane and then you can't get the tool's cutter to retract all the way. The adjusting wheel just bottoms out against the frog and won't budge. It seems like you are stuck and that it's time to send the tool back to the maker.

Nope. The fix is easy.

The problem is the chipbreaker is too long. You see, the chipbreaker engages the plane's iron assembly. If the breaker is too long it will prevent the iron from retracting, especially when the mouth is set tight. (There is some geometry involved here because the frog moves forward on an inclined plane.)

So if you grind back the chipbreaker's leading edge, you will fix the problem instantly. Do this on the grinder, just like you would grind the cutter. Most breakers will intersect the iron at 25�, so that's a good angle to begin with. With new-, very old- and infill-style chipbreakers (a flat piece of iron), this is just like grinding an iron. With the springy breakers on Stanley planes, you might need to re-bend the sucker a bit before you screw it to the cutter.

All this sounds difficult, but it's easy work. The steel in chipbreakers is soft, so it takes a minute at most. And you usually have quite a bit of leeway � you can grind away about 1/8" of the breaker without changing the way it mates with the iron. Note that some modern chipbreakers have a small land (flat area) on the underside. Don't grind all that away � that's where it mates with the cutter.

I usually grind away about 1/16" � that has fixed every problem so far.

Do this before you start messing with the dog that engages the chipbreaker or (egads) bending the yoke of the tool (which is many times made using cast metal and will many times break).

� Christopher Schwarz

That said, if I was in Denver I take to the Woodcraft and hook-up with Rob before any modifications were made to the plane.

Re: Advice on replacing plane iron on very old #5

#6

I have a Stanley #7, type 2, with family ties

Bruce, a MN Galoot

that is 50 years older than yours (patent dates 1867, I believe, without ducking out to look). It has an adjustable frog and accommodates a Hock blade very well. Just move the frog back a zillionth of an inch. The original blade was modified by grinding out the slot to the point where it was a quarter inch shy of the edge. It didn't work very well anymore. That was about 30 years before Ron Hock started producing blades.

Re: Advice on replacing plane iron on very old #5

#7

Re: Advice on replacing plane iron on very old #5

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

No particular reason why not. Be sure you move the frog back as far as it will go and still allow the iron to advance - no sense doing more filing than you need to do.

Re: Advice on replacing plane iron on very old #5

#8

Re: Advice on replacing plane iron on very old #5

Terry in Denver

Doug:

You may be able to move the frog a little further back than you have. The blade bevel should give you some clearance to do so. I have rehabbed many old Stanleys with thicker aftermarket blades and have never had to file open a mouth.

Terry

Re: Advice on replacing plane iron on very old #5

#9

Orignal chip breaker

DouginDenver

I'm using the original which in htat era were pretty thin. Not much to grind. But the chip breaker is not the problem - at least not yet. If I slide the frog back until its slope aligns with the slope of the sole opening - which is as far back as the frog can practically be moved - and I slide the blade on with no chip breaker at all, the cutting edge will rub or just barely clear the front of the base opening.

Re: Advice on replacing plane iron on very old #5

#10

Re: Advice on replacing plane iron on very old #5

DouginDenver

Good point. I'll try that.

Re: Advice on replacing plane iron on very old #5

#11

OT - another wonder o' the internet

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

For me, one of the extra joys of a forum like this is the advice received from people from all over - even from that faraway land, Ozstralia.

Here we have another example of that: someone in Denver receiving useful advice from someone...in Denver. I take it both of you guys are in the same Denver, and not one in Denver, Colorado and one in Denver, Pennsylvania (in which case, I withdraw my comment).

Re: Advice on replacing plane iron on very old #5

#12

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re:  Orignal chip breaker

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Actually, you can move the frog back just a bit further, since the thicker blade (iron) has a 30� bevel. The bevel will let it sit a bit - maybe 1/64" or so - further back without it hitting the back of the throat.

Gotta ask - you are installing the blade with the bevel down, aren't you? :\

Re: Advice on replacing plane iron on very old #5

#13

Re:  Orignal chip breaker

DouginDenver

Yeah, it's bevel side down. I need to seee tonight if the bevel gives enough room after I move the frog back a bit.

Re: Advice on replacing plane iron on very old #5

#14

Re: OT - another wonder o' the internet

Terry in Denver

I don't know about Doug - but I'm in Denver, CO. I just assumed he was too.

Maybe we should start a survey - who else is in Colorado?

Terry

Re: Advice on replacing plane iron on very old #5

#15

Didn't work

DouginDenver

Moving the frog back more to allow for the bevel on the iron to to give me extra room did not work. Although it should help in theory, by the time the bevel hits the actual plane body below the frog, the edge of the cutter has still not cleared the bottom of the plane. I cannot see any option but to file the opening larger. To bad I can't see a plane on which others claim to have made the IBC blades work without modification. Also wonder why IBC does not make it clear somehwere if planes need to be modified. I have seen a couple vague references online to it, so I'm not alone.

Re: Advice on replacing plane iron on very old #5

#16

Re: OT - nothing to add...just another Denverite

David Hay @ Denver

Re: Advice on replacing plane iron on very old #5

#17

Me too

John Pappas