transitional repair
Bruce, a MN Galoot
I have a 24" Stanley transitional, but the cheek of the insert (unsure of the terminology here) is cracked. Can this be welded, or should I just look for a replacement?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
transitional repair
Bruce, a MN Galoot
I have a 24" Stanley transitional, but the cheek of the insert (unsure of the terminology here) is cracked. Can this be welded, or should I just look for a replacement?
Re: transitional repair
Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio
It can be welded, brazed, or silver soldered, but it'll take a pretty good welder to do it.
I`d braze it
Bob Hackett
Thanks, Guys
Bruce, a MN Galoot
I've got a couple friends who are good at that. Mostly I needed to know if it could be done. This one was my grandpa's and it's good to keep in the family, rather than turning that plane into 24" of beech repairs for other things.
Re: transitional repair
David Miller from Iowa
Since it is an heirloom, the equation changes.
However, in my opinion, I wouldn't think it diminishes the heirloom quality if you just found another donor plane and swapped the top frame - I personally would like that better than a noticeable brazing. I have a number of family heirloom tools and have done small swap outs - blades, lever caps, totes, etc. - works for me, but maybe not for you. If you braze or can get a free job through your network, great. If you hire it done, a frame swap from a donor plane would be about the same money and would look way better
The 24" would be the Stanley #31, and donor planes #28, #29, #30 and #31 would fit it. Just have to watch whether it says Bailey in front of the knob. Either way it would still fit, but if your grandfather's plane says Bailey in front of the knob (slightly larger in the logo area) and you put a non-Bailey marked top frame the replacement would be noticeable by the wood color. Not so in reverse - you could put the Bailey marked frame on an older plane and one could not tell. I probably would just find the same one, whether it was Bailey logo or not.
David
Does it affect use?
Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA
I was quite pleased, a few years back, to score a Stanley No. 71 router plane for $5, until I got it home and found it was cracked through the sole just next to the cutter post. I gave it to my son, who welds, and he's been using it intermittently without repairing the crack, and reports that it works fine.
Is the crack in a place that will cause bad things to happen if you don't fix it; or someplace that has minimal stress?
Re: Does it affect use?
Bruce, a MN Galoot
I don't have a blade for it, but that's a minor detail, so I don't know whether the crack affects the function. However, the casting is fastened front and back, and the crack is about halfway forward on the right side and goes all the way from top to bottom, i.e., all the way through.
My grandpa wasn't particular about mixing and matching parts. I have a #8 with a Bedrock lever cap on a plane that is clearly not a Bedrock. If he didn't care, I won't.
Re: Does it affect use?
James Watriss
Well, be aware that some parts are not compatible. You need a transitional specific chip-breaker and lever cap: The hole for the yoke is cut in a different place, (about 1/4" higher) and the lever cap is designed to reach down a little farther to hold the blade more securely, deep into the block.
At this point
Bruce, a MN Galoot
I feel a little bit like "if we had some eggs we could have bacon and eggs if we had some bacon." 
This plane started out with a good body, a cracked casting, and a lever cap, but no blade or chip breaker. I wasn't aware that the lever cap, blade and chip breaker are transitional-specific. That's good to know. Thanks.
Re: transitional repair
Bruce, a MN Galoot
In the long run, what you suggest is probably easier and more likely to happen. I'll hold out until the next cabin fever meet at Medina and do some scrounging there.
George Washington vs Cherry Tree
David Miller from Iowa
My Dad has the axe that George Washington used to to cut down the cherry tree. It has had only 3 new heads and 5 new handles.