New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Sprung joints

Posts

Sprung joints

#1

Sprung joints

Craig, Anchorage, AK

The way I understand a sprung joint, the gap between two boards being edge joined should be able to be closed with only finger pressure for glue up. I'm joining two 6.5" wide, 45" long cherry boards into a 13" wide panel. Would a sprung joint be inappropriate for this application due to the high clamping pressure required to close the joint? Should I make the gap smaller or just try for a perfect edge with no gap? Right now I've got a gap just big enough to slide a small piece of notebook paper through at the center.

Thanks for any help,

Craig

Re: Sprung joints

#2

Moses Yoder

Re: Sprung joints

Moses Yoder

A paper thickness will work fine. See how much pressure it takes with clamps to push it together. If you can press it together with clamps without really wrenching on it the boards will stay together when glued. Sprung joints are really not necessary but I usually take about 2 or 3 shavings kind of tapered toards the center with a smoothing plane. The idea is just to keep the ends from splitting if they shrink faster than the center.

Re: Sprung joints

#3

Re: Sprung joints

Patrick Gibbons

Be careful not to spring the joints too much. (How much is too much, I don't know). I glued together a panel a few months ago and had splits towards the ends of the panel, presumably because of the pressure caused by the sprung joint and exacerbated by weather change. I believe the dryness of the wood, or lack thereof, and weather change were the main culprits but who can say.

Re: Sprung joints

#4

Re: Sprung joints

Adam Cherubini

If you are using PVA (white or yellow glue), you should spring your joint such that you need a fair bit of clamp pressure to close the joint.

So how much is a fair bit? With a normal Pony pipe clamp, you've got to hang on it pretty hard to produce the manufacturer's recommended bondline pressure. I don't recall the exact amount, but a good, near-wood-crushing grunt is really what the manufacturer is looking for. So you want less than that on the clamp in the center (to close the joint). That should define the amount of "spring" you plane in. For it to matter, it's got to be more than hand pressure.

The idea with the spring joint is that you preload the end such that the bondline pressure is greater there than elsewhere. As the wood shrinks, the preload is diminished prior to a crack opening. My feeling is that if it takes you a good amount of force just to close the gap, you've achieved that.

Only trick is to avoid starving the joint at the end. When you actually clamp the joint, you need that near crushing force on each clamp. If you are worried about starvation, you can actually (I know this sounds strange) skip the end clamps altogether. Just make sure you see glue extruding out when you put on the clamps.

Adam

Re: Sprung joints

#5

Stephen Shepherd

Starved joints

Stephen Shepherd

You can lessen the problem of starved joints if you tooth the edges receiving glue.

Stephen

Re: Sprung joints

#6

Re: Starved joints

Adam Cherubini

That's a great idea for hide glue. I think the old timers notion of roughened surfaces providing better adhesion is based on the fact that hot hide glue extrudes out of tight joints or joints where smooth surfaces are heavily clamped.

So clamping a toothed surface, for example, works great. The top of the surface provides contact. The reduced surface area allows a good clamp up and the grooves (from the teeth) provide a place for the glue to go. In a mortise and tenon, a rough sawn tenon provides alignment and fit and the recesses provide a place for the glue to go.

In PVA, these sorts of joints would be disastrous. PVA, unlike hot hide or epoxy for example, relies on high bondline pressure to develop mechanical properties.

Adam

Re: Sprung joints

#7

Thanks

Craig, Anchorage, AK

Thanks for the input. Sounds like I'm sorta on the right track. I was actually planning on trying hide glue for the first time on this project, but I've got enough other "first for me" things going on that I'll stick with what I know for the glue.

Re: Sprung joints

#8

Can you explain starved?

Bob Lang

I don't get this idea of a "starved" joint. Are you saying that pressure from the clamp is capable of moving all the glue away from the area where the wood surfaces touch each other? That seems to me what "starved" implies. How does that work with a sticky liquid in between two relatively porous surfaces? Or does all the glue squirt out the edge, leaving no glue behind?

I think glue starvation was made up by the guys selling glue, who would be happy if you used several times more than what you need to stick two hunks of wood together. In a well fit joint, there isn't much room for glue in between the wood. You can have enough in there to form a bond without it squeezing all over, and I don't see how you could generate enough pressure to move the glue away from the joint line.

Bob Lang

Re: Sprung joints

#9

Moses Yoder

Re: Can you explain starved?

Moses Yoder

Where I work we have a glue press that is tightened with an air wrench. The guys in the shop like to have the air pressure high so the wrench works a little faster then they hammer down on the clamps until the pressure is probably several thousand pounds per square inch. We had problems with our glue joints coming apart from not having any glue left in the joint until we got the person running the clamp to ease up on the pressure. Even with hand tightened clamps the only pressure necessary is enough to push the two pieces of wood snugly together until the glue dries; any more pressure is wasted. You want to minimize the glue line but you do that by edge jointing the boards with a sharp plane instead of just gluing together right off the power jointer.

Re: Sprung joints

#10

Stephen Shepherd

Re: Can you explain starved?

Stephen Shepherd

Bob,

It is very easy to squeeze all of the glue from the joint with excessive clamping pressure, a nature of glue not glue salesmen.

A friend was making some 2 inch thick maple counter-tops, the highly machined edges were clamped with large iron panel clamps and all of the glue was squeezed out of the joints. He started using a toothing plane and the problem went away.

All of the technical books on Adhesive Technology mention starved glue joints.

Stephen

Re: Sprung joints

#11

Re: Can you explain starved?

Bob Hackett

Sounds like you`r saying that a smooth finish on the edge and a joint planed to mate perfectly are counter productive to a durable and lasting joint.

Why then do you hear all this hype about plane qymnastics that lead to tolerances measured to 3 digits to the right of the decimal point?

This may be some of the proof of what I had long suspected,our brain is so in love with over complicating and over engineering things that it gets in the way of what our hands know to do.One look at 100+ year old furniture will tell you that today it`s more about the tools,gadgets and process than it is about producing a usable and durable final product.

Re: Sprung joints

#12

Stephen Shepherd

Re: Can you explain starved?

Stephen Shepherd

Bob,

'Why then do you hear all this hype about plane qymnastics that lead to tolerances measured to 3 digits to the right of the decimal point?'

You are spot on this one. The only time I am concerned about shavings is while using a spile plane, I can sell those, the ones on the floor I can not. In the nineteenth century and earlier the only person who could even measure to those tolerances were clock makers and machinists. My rulers are marked in 1/8" hash marks and I know a 1/16th is half way in between, and my furniture is square and the joints fit just fine.

The authorities on the subject say that intentional roughing [toothing] a surface increases the glue bonding strength from 5 to 30%.

Stephen

Re: Sprung joints

#13

Moses Yoder

Re: Roughing

Moses Yoder

When you "rough" a joint, do you rough it all the way out including the outside edges or do you just rough the center of the board? It seems to me that if you took a toothed plane and roughed the whole edge you would end up with a glue joint that looks about 1/16" wide.

Re: Sprung joints

#14

Re: Can you explain starved?

Adam Cherubini

"Are you saying that pressure from the clamp is capable of moving all the glue away from the area where the wood surfaces touch each other?"

Yes indeed. Depending on what glue we are are talking about, it can be shockingly easy to do. I recall fitting cylindrical tenons that were so tight I had to twist them in to place dry. A joint that tight will have practically no hot hide glue in it. And that was my experience. My beech saw horses use tapered tenons and they too routinely come apart. I initially attached them with PVA and set them in with a mallet blow. The amount of glue that remainined was insufficient and they have since come out. Pretty obvious that the glue extruded out of the high pressure areas and there wasn't enough in the gappy areas to withstand seasonal movement and rough duty.

PVA loves high bondline pressures. I don't think woodworkers clamp their boards anywhere near the manufacturers' recommendations. So for these folks, glue starvation isn't a likely eventuality. But as we start to tighten the clamps and apply more of them, the added (and localized) pressure of a spring joint could indeed cause glue starvation. Franklin's recommendations are 150-300 psi of joint pressure. I would speculate that a spring jointed board could see as much as twice that at the ends (where you most want a good glue joint)

Regarding surface conditions, the science is clear and the history agrees with it. For PVA, you want as much surface contact as possible since it only develops properties with pressure. So smooth boards carefully fit are a must. PVA is not stiff so it cannot transfer load across even tiny gaps so fits within a few thou (.001-.005) are not at all excessive. Gaps of a few thou might as well be an inch.

Stiff glues like hot hide and epoxy require a bond line gap (.0025-.005" or so). These glues work better on roughened surfaces. In industrial applications where parts are to be structurally bonded, a thin open mesh called "scrim cloth" is used to maintain the bondline and prevent glue starvation.

"I think glue starvation was made up by the guys selling glue, who would be happy if you used several times more than what you need to stick two hunks of wood together."

Just in case anyone believes this, you can't prevent glue starvation by adding more glue. Glue starvation is caused by over clamping, poor quality fits, and the like. I've spoken with Franklin's engineering department several times on the phone and I've found them to be open, honest, and helpful about their products.

Woodworkers probably aren't getting the published properties from PVA and in most instances they probably don't need it so I can see why guys just don't care about this issue. That said, I carefully sprung several joints for furniture in my house and glued the joints with PVA and have never seen problems. Other joints in my house have popped, so maybe I'm doing something right.

Adam

Re: Sprung joints

#15

Stephen Shepherd

Re: Roughing

Stephen Shepherd

Moses,

I tooth the entire surface of both faces of a glue joint. I only use animal glues. I have no real way of measuring the depth of the tooth but I am sure if you add them both up it would be less than 1/64th inch. The glue I use also shrinks as it dries, so the joints are tight enough to pinch a hair.

Stephen

Re: Sprung joints

#16

Re: Can you explain starved?

Bob Hackett

I just have to ask Adam,what is a colonial type such as yourself doing with PVA and epoxy on his hands and in his shop?

Re: Sprung joints

#17

Re: Can you explain starved?

Bob Lang

So let me get this straight. If I'm gluing two pieces of wood together with PVA, I want to use a tremendous amount of clamping pressure, because science tells me that's what it takes for an "optimal" joint. But I better be careful because if I ate my Wheaties that morning and twist the clamp just a little too much, all the glue will disappear and my joint will fail.

I'm not arguing about a joint where it's possible to squeegee the glue away during assembly, as in your example, but two edges coming together to form a panel or a table top. I would maintain that if you're able to scrape the glue off as the joint comes together the glue is on the wrong surfaces to begin with.

Then if I want to use hide glue, I want a raggedy surface and a visible gap because the glue requires it.

Sorry Adam, but I think you're being extreme in both directions. Science and theory can be fun to delve into, but practical experience holds more weight for me. With either glue, I want two nice surfaces that fit close. If the two pieces fit intimately then excessive pressure isn't needed, and I don't have enough muscle to squeeze two pieces of wood together so tightly that the glue disappears. PVAs work very well with moderate pressure, and a hide glue joint looks better if the surfaces are smooth.

Bob Lang

Re: Sprung joints

#18

Stephen Shepherd

Toothed rub joint

Stephen Shepherd

This is a small cedar panel which will be gessoed and prepared as a painting panel, so I wasn't to concerned about the joints. I shot the edges then toothed them.

I applied liquid hide glue and assembled them as rub joints. Four pieces, I rubbed a pair together and let them sit overnight, then I rubbed those together and it was ready the next day.

The photograph is of the worst part of any of the joints I could find. And no clamps were involved.

Stephen


img

Re: Sprung joints

#20

Re: Sprung joints

Craig, Anchorage, AK

Thanks for the link. I've gotten quite a bit to think about out of this thread.

Re: Sprung joints

#21

Re: Can you explain starved?

Adam Cherubini

Bob,

Imagine you have a 4' long glue up and apply three pipe clamps, spaced one foot apart. When you tighten the clamps, you'll see glue extrude from the joint just under the clamps at first. As you tighten the clamps more, you'll begin to see glue extrude out between the clamp heads.

That tells us that the pressure in the bondline is not consistent. It's higher under the clamp heads and lower between them. Likewise, we can tell just by looking that there's less glue under the clamp heads and more glue in the joint between them. Do we care? No. We have enough spots where the bondline pressure is just right to make a good joint. But you probably also have spots where you've staved your joint. Do you care? No.

In this thread, we're discussing sprung joints. These joints are unique because by nature of their shape, they force more pressure to the ends of the joint. That's the point of a sprung joint. So absolutely, you need to be careful not to starve the ends (where you most want a decent bond) by applying too much spring OR tightening your clamps too much.

In the example above, imagine you planed in so much spring (imagine 1' wide boards) that you had a 1/2" of gap between them. Depending on the species, the pressure to close the gap alone could starve the ends.

Adam

I agree that there are things too complicated for science to explain, but this isn't one of them.

Re: Sprung joints

#22

Re: Sprung joints - real answer

ThomD

Sprung joints have two convenient aspects:

1) planes produce them as their default shape, and the reason jointers exist is to produce a reasonable amount of spring, little other reason. You can produce exactly the same amount of spring with a shorter plane with less blade projection, but then the work goes very slowly. Of course if you get spring, you can then back it back out, by changing from scrubbing from the center out, to cutting from the ends in. Once you have the feel for it, it can all be done without explicit attention.

2) With spring you can use less clamps so it is like the old rubbed joint, in that you can glue up a mess of boards without clamps, or in this case without a lot of clamps

The best joint is a perfect joint, two coplanar surfaces. Does not mater whether you are using white glue or hide glue, or epoxy. The only problem is producing perfect surfaces. In the extreme where the boards are essentially unbendable and the joint needs to be invisible, one has to employ special methods. But with a perfect joint, you can do a rubbed assembly and have the joint pull itself together, and disappear while using white glue. Hide glue works also, but white is just fine.

I don't think the idea that the ends need to be sprung passes the smell test. The degree of spring is so small it isn't going to get you anywhere, building a lot of stress into panels is never a great idea. The fact is one needs to build with moisture in mind, and one needs to provide an appropriate environment, if you do that you can float even your wooden boat, but relying on heavy handed methods is not the answer. it's like the mechanic who reaches for a bigger hammer.

Re: Sprung joints

#23

A 19th century solution

Patrick Gibbons

was to use splined joints. There's much more glue surface and the splines are not under clamping pressure, they are fitted into the groove. I put some panels together this way but they haven't been together long enough for any meaningful evaluation. Maybe 9 months together. I have read that splined joints could be rubbed together- no clamping. This assumes hide glue of course.

Re: Sprung joints

#24

What is the difference between ....

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

.. a joint that is rubbed and a joint that is clamped?

Bob wrote, "PVAs work very well with moderate pressure, and a hide glue joint looks better if the surfaces are smooth".

This is my experience as well.

My logic (always a little suspect ;) ) says that the high pressure clamping with PVA is really about creating a bond fit with the smallest possible gap, and that this is no different from a shaped fit that ensures a small gap - in other words, two boards jointed with smooth faces and coplanar in all the important areas. Rubbing these joints simply causes surface tension, which attracts the two edges and draws them closer. High clamping pressure is unnecessary. I would imagine that this is the very opposite of glue starved.

How does this relate to a spring joint? Only insofar - by extrapolating from the above posts - as a poorly made spring joint is one that encourages a high degree of clamping pressure to pull it together. A very little pressure at the ends is all that is desired.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Sprung joints

#25

Re: Sprung joints

Barry

Sprung joints aren't worth the trouble. With modern adhesives, all you need to do is get a good flat butt joint. The joint will be stronger than the surrounding wood. Dowels or biscuits or splines serve only to keep the joint in alignment until the glue sets. If you have stock that has been properly prepared, straight and flat, this should is not be a problem. Spend less time on joints and more time on other aspects of woodworking techniques.