Re: Can you explain starved?
Adam Cherubini
"Are you saying that pressure from the clamp is capable of moving all the glue away from the area where the wood surfaces touch each other?"
Yes indeed. Depending on what glue we are are talking about, it can be shockingly easy to do. I recall fitting cylindrical tenons that were so tight I had to twist them in to place dry. A joint that tight will have practically no hot hide glue in it. And that was my experience. My beech saw horses use tapered tenons and they too routinely come apart. I initially attached them with PVA and set them in with a mallet blow. The amount of glue that remainined was insufficient and they have since come out. Pretty obvious that the glue extruded out of the high pressure areas and there wasn't enough in the gappy areas to withstand seasonal movement and rough duty.
PVA loves high bondline pressures. I don't think woodworkers clamp their boards anywhere near the manufacturers' recommendations. So for these folks, glue starvation isn't a likely eventuality. But as we start to tighten the clamps and apply more of them, the added (and localized) pressure of a spring joint could indeed cause glue starvation. Franklin's recommendations are 150-300 psi of joint pressure. I would speculate that a spring jointed board could see as much as twice that at the ends (where you most want a good glue joint)
Regarding surface conditions, the science is clear and the history agrees with it. For PVA, you want as much surface contact as possible since it only develops properties with pressure. So smooth boards carefully fit are a must. PVA is not stiff so it cannot transfer load across even tiny gaps so fits within a few thou (.001-.005) are not at all excessive. Gaps of a few thou might as well be an inch.
Stiff glues like hot hide and epoxy require a bond line gap (.0025-.005" or so). These glues work better on roughened surfaces. In industrial applications where parts are to be structurally bonded, a thin open mesh called "scrim cloth" is used to maintain the bondline and prevent glue starvation.
"I think glue starvation was made up by the guys selling glue, who would be happy if you used several times more than what you need to stick two hunks of wood together."
Just in case anyone believes this, you can't prevent glue starvation by adding more glue. Glue starvation is caused by over clamping, poor quality fits, and the like. I've spoken with Franklin's engineering department several times on the phone and I've found them to be open, honest, and helpful about their products.
Woodworkers probably aren't getting the published properties from PVA and in most instances they probably don't need it so I can see why guys just don't care about this issue. That said, I carefully sprung several joints for furniture in my house and glued the joints with PVA and have never seen problems. Other joints in my house have popped, so maybe I'm doing something right.
Adam