New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Stanley 6" Try Square

Posts

Stanley 6" Try Square

#1

Stanley 6" Try Square

Barry

My beloved Stanley try square is gone! I'm still hoping it is just misplaced, but I can't find it anywhere after days of searching.

No problem. I'll just buy another. Not so easy! Mine has a ruler along both sides of the blade. It seems most of the new squares do not have a ruler scale at all. Any ideas on where to purchase a new square that is most like my old one? It seems the Stanley try square is no longer made.

Re: Stanley 6" Try Square

#2

Can't help, but

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

what are the benefits for you of a try square over a combination or double square?

Re: Stanley 6" Try Square

#3

Re: Can't help, but

Barry

I think its more accurate, and I like having the ruler on the square.

Re: Stanley 6" Try Square

#4

Jack Guzman from Maine

Ebay

Jack Guzman from Maine

Barry,

If you keep a watch on ebay I'm sure one will come up. You could set it up to email you when one comes up for auction. I believe ebay offers that option.---Jack

Re: Stanley 6" Try Square

#5

Re: Ebay

Barry

Thanks. There are a couple much like mine on Ebay right now. I really just want my old try square back. LOL

Re: Stanley 6" Try Square

#7

Re: What about something like this?

Barry

That might do it. Of course a combination square might work really well, too. I just like the idea of a fixed-beam try square. I think they may be more accurate, but this is probably just a silly notion on my part. I have stayed away from combination squares for the same reason. I feel they are not as accurate as a fixed beam square. For me, this is probably true because I continually forget to lock down the beam with the adjustment screw.

What we are really dealing with here is a sentimental attachment that I have to my old square. It was one of the first things I bought when I started woodworking. It's the right size. It is spot-on. I like the ruled beam. I've had it 35+ years and I just want it back. (Where in Hell is it?) I don't want some Chinese-made replacement or even a high-tech replacement from a modern company like Incra. Does that make any sense? Probably not!

Re: Stanley 6" Try Square

#8

Makes all the sense in the world

Joe

Barry, your old try square was comfortable, accurate, familiar and it was YOURS. As we age, certain things become mainstays in our life. Not every mainstay is a financial treasure, but many are personal comfort treasures, filled with warmth & memories. They are as familiar as your old dog, not of much use to others, but priceless to you.

Unless your shop is open to the public, your try square is in there somewhere. Take the afternoon to clean and organize your shop and I'll bet your old, trusty tool shows up (along with that missing brown sock).

Good luck, Joe

Re: Stanley 6" Try Square

#9

The other reliable way to get it to show up

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

is to get a new one.

Re: Stanley 6" Try Square

#10

Re: Stanley 6" Try Square

Dean Lapinel

" It seems the Stanley try square is no longer made."

It isn't but I heard they are coming out with a new line to go with their new planes. I think they are being called "succeed squares" as the worried about the old term.

Re: Stanley 6" Try Square

#11

In a book titled, "Tools of the Trade," *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Jeff Taylor, who worked (and may still) as a carpenter, talks about getting into a competition with his boss and coworker over whose square was most accurate. His boss' try square and his own combination square were beaten out by his coworker's speed square (if you're not familiar with these, see linky below). My son uses a speed square in his carpentry. I own one, but have yet to see its virtues over my combination square, which I can make shorter to fit where I'm marking square up against a wall, use as a depth and pencil-marking gauge, etc.

And they'll be ice fishing in Hell before I apply a speed square to any kind of fine work.

A combination square's rule registers against ridges running along the bottom of the groove in the square's head. These are milled into the head to make it easier to adjust the head for square - you file them with a narrow file, test, file again, etc. (side note: an auger bit file, using its toothed edge/safe face end, is the ideal file for this purpose). It's possible that some of the perception that combination squares aren't accurate stems from these ridges wearing and not being maintained, or not being set right at the factory; or from dirt building up in the grooves, nicks on the rule, etc. The wear problem would be worse with the aluminum or plastic heads used on some cheap squares. A combination square head should be cast iron at a minimum; forged is even better.

It's true that a try square, if truly square to start with, doesn't have any of these problems; but it's a harder tool to adjust for square if it is or goes out of square.

For an amateur like me - and, I suspect, like you, Barry - emotion counts, too, though. If you feel most comfortable with a try square, see if you can find a new one. If you do buy sight unseen, though, insist that the seller test it and guarantee it for square; and, if you happen to find a retail or used outlet near you, take along a piece of wood or even heavy cardboard* with a straight edge to test for square.

*It never occurred to me until just now that the cardboard that backs notepads would probably be ideal material for this: the edges seem dead straight (I'd test one before relying on it), and a notepad is a lot less strange when you walk into a store, and easier to carry, than a chunk of plywood or maple.


Wikipedia words on speed squares

Re: Stanley 6" Try Square

#12

I assume marketing nixed "try, try again square"

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Will the square in the more expensive Yoda line be called the "do square?"

Re: Stanley 6" Try Square

#13

just be sure to keep the receipt

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Re: Stanley 6" Try Square

#14

I sent you an e-mail

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Re: Stanley 6" Try Square

#15

Re: In a book titled, "Tools of the Trade,"

Barry

I'm sure a combination square is plenty accurate, especially for the kinds of woodwork that I do. But I tend to forget to lock down the blade by tightening the knob. I know this messes with the accuracy.

Part of this is sentimentality. Part of this is being old, cantankerous and reluctant to change.

But I'm with you, a speed square is a carpenter's tool, not a woodworker's tool; I don't care how accurate it is. Thanks for the comments.

Re: Stanley 6" Try Square

#16

Re: Makes all the sense in the world

Barry

I agree and I hope you are right. Actually, my shop has been sort of open-to-the-public. I've been working on it and have had a drywall crew in several times, along with electrician's and painters. Along with every outside person who has been in my shop, there has been an opportunity for my beloved try square to leave with that person. But, I hope that's not the case and that it will eventually turn up. I had a Swiss Army knife that I lost once. It stayed gone for almost two (2) years. It was found by my mother-in-law when she flipped a recliner over to clean under it. Out fell my knife. It had been resting quietly out-of-sight on the frame underneath the chair.

Re: Stanley 6" Try Square

#17

Re: Makes all the sense in the world

Barry

I agree and I hope you are right. Actually, my shop has been sort of open-to-the-public. I've been working on it and have had a drywall crew in several times, along with electrician's and painters. Along with every outside person who has been in my shop, there has been an opportunity for my beloved try square to leave with that person. But, I hope that's not the case, and that it will eventually turn up. I had a Swiss Army knife that I lost once. It stayed gone for almost two (2) years. It was found by my mother-in-law when she flipped a recliner over to clean under it. Out fell my knife. It had been resting quietly out-of-sight on the frame underneath the chair.

Re: Stanley 6" Try Square

#18

Re: Stanley 6" Try Square

Barry

That's nice to know. Thanks.

Re: Stanley 6" Try Square

#19

In defense of the speed square

Neal in San Jose

I actually have two of them. I sometimes use them during clamp-ups to assure dead-on square corners. The hole in the middle allows it to be used with a pair of clamps to hold two pieces at exactly 90 degrees. Try that with your try square or combo square!

Re: Stanley 6" Try Square

#20

(almost) every tool has its place

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

even a battery-powered C clamp, which I imagine would be much appreciated by those with limited hand strength.

Re: Stanley 6" Try Square

#21

I think, just maybe, Dean was joshing

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Re: Stanley 6" Try Square

#22

Re: I think, just maybe, Dean was joshing

Barry

I missed that..........a little slow today. I won't wait for them to hit the store shelves.

Re: Stanley 6" Try Square

#23

OK Barry, here's the deal...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

You need to go buy a new one. Keep the receipt, this is important.

after you come home with your new tool, just leave it the wrapper for a day or two. If your square hasn't fount you yet (or you it) take the new one out of the package. Don't use it, just touch it a bit. Your old square should start to feel jealous about now.

Continue to fondle your new square for a few more days. Now, you really need to use that square so go ahead and do so. Carefully, as not to mark the new tool.

Do some good work in the shop and god have a good nights sleep. When come to your shop the next day SHAZAM! your old square will be sorry it ran off and you can take the new square, carefully put it back in it package and return it to it's place of purchase.

Scott, The only thing I can say is to not let your tools get jealous.

All they need is to be picked up every now and then and be fondled a bit :D

Re: Stanley 6" Try Square

#24

Here's a really nice one

Sandor in Middletown, DE

http://www.gladstonetools.com/302-1000.html

These are really nice and are available individually too. Plus they won't break the bank.

Sorry to hear about your tool. I misplaced my dozuki saw for about a year. It was in the bottom of my nightstand along with the 2 cherries 12mm chisel I couldn't find. I had used them while installing some trim molding in my bathroom and wasn't finished but had to get it out of the way as company was coming to visit. So when I got back on the project I couldn't remember squirelling them away. Found them about a month ago.

Cheers,

Sandor

Re: Stanley 6" Try Square

#25

Re: Here's a really nice one

Barry

Those are nice.

I broke down and bought myself a new Crown 5" try square today at Woodcraft. It's nice, but has no ruler on the blade. Now, all I have to do is sit back and see if my purchase will make my old square come out of hiding.