New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

deglazing oil stones

Posts

deglazing oil stones

#1

deglazing oil stones

david in indy

What's the best way for me to "de-glaze" my hard black arkansas stone?

Re: deglazing oil stones

#2

Re: deglazing oil stones

Bob Hackett

I would think the first step toward getting your stone working again would be to focus on what the "glaze" really is.

If the stone is clogged with swarf from sharpening then you need to just remove that metal from between the stone particles.I use either a vinegar bath or a mild acid bath and scrubbing with a stiff brush to get rid of the metal yet not harm the stone.DO NOT try this on anything other than a natural oil stone as even mild acids can destroy the bond on some man made stones.Once you have removed the metal then you need to reconsider what you are using on your stone as It`s not doing the job of carrying the metal away and keeping it from clogging the stone.

Now if the stone is relatively free of metal but the surface is composed of flattened particles that your edge skates over rather than being abraded by them then you need to get rid of those flattened grit particles and get down to a surface that will do the job again.This is where restoring the surface with a diamond plate or another hard surface such as ceramic or SC comes in.

From what I understand one of two things happen.Either the tougher particles fracture the old,flat particles and make them sharp again or the impact breaks the flat particles free from the natural bond of the stone.Either way a new,fresh,sharp,flat surface is what you want to end up with.

One of the drawbacks of natural oilstones is they have an excellent natural bond and tend to hold on to the grit particles after they become flat and ineffective.Water stones have a weaker bond and shed the particles to form a slurry which constantly exposes new sharp surfaces.That slurry is a close approximation of what loose diamond or other loose abrasives on glass or other matrix/backing is doing.The trade off is water stones wear more quickly.

Some folks like Scary Sharp or loose abrasives on glass or other backer because when the grit stops cutting you just add new or remove it completely and start fresh.Others feel it`s messy and time consuming.

Every system requires the proper lubricant/swarf remover and periodic maintenance as well as proper storage.There is no magic bullet that will cut all steels well and quickly forever with one grit and leave a polished surface.

As others have said in the past,it`s a matter of matching what kind of steel you have in your hand with the appropriate abrasive system.

That`s a rather long winded reply which tells you probably more than you wanted to know yet still is not comprehensive enough to cover the stone debate in depth.

I invite all comments to the contrary and corrections of any flaws in my thinking as I believe we about to go down the very well traveled "oil vs water vs (fill in the blank) system" road yet again.It`s looming on the horizon like a tsunami and I just can`t wait to beat that dead horse yet again.

Don`t we have articles posted somewhere that cover all this? ;^)

Re: deglazing oil stones

#3

David Barnett

How I do it... *LINK*

David Barnett

I use diamond compound much in the way Norton recommends using diamond to enhance hard Arkansas bench stone performance.

From the 2008/2009 Norton Professional Sharpening Products catalog:

Diamond lapping compound can be used to �turbo charge� oil stones. Use a Grade 9 with medium India stones and Grade 3 with Norton Hard Translucent Arkansas stones to improve the cut rate and finish on tough/hard steel. Grade 1 used on a piece of hard maple or MDF will provide a highly polished finish.

For black Arkansas, rub a dab of 2-4 micron diamond compound in little circles over the glazed stone with your fingertip. Wipe down the stone with a paper towel and repeat if needed. Charge the stone with a final dab or two and your glazing days will pretty much be a thing of the past. If the surface gets sticky, extend with oil or water as appropriate, depending on whether you're using oil or water-based versions of diamond compound. Five grams will last a long long time, by the way, so it's cheap.


Above TIP from page 29, Norton sharpening catalog

Re: deglazing oil stones

#4

Question Dave

Bob Hackett

If you follow Norton`s advice aren`t you basically turning a rather expensive natural stone into a substrate for the diamond?

Re: deglazing oil stones

#5

Re: deglazing oil stones

Warren in Lancaster, PA

As Bob mentioned Arkansas stones are nearly immune to solvents. I think only HF (hydrofluoric acid) which dissolves glass and sand etc. would harm it. The stones are somewhat metamorphosed, not held together by a binder. Some stones are clogged with oil residue also and detergent with hot or boiling water is helpful here.

A coarse oilstone that is glazed can be improved by abrading as suggested by Bob and David. However abrading a fine Arkansas stone will scratch the surface and cause it to work like a coarser stone. A new or resurfaced hard Arkansas will cut like a soft Arkansas for quite some time. If polish is what you want out of a hard stone then I think it best not to abrade.

Re: deglazing oil stones

#6

David Barnett

Hell yes! *LINK*

David Barnett

And it does NOT damage the stone. If anything, it simply improves it. Let me explain. Novaculite is nothing more than a recrystallized chert, which is nothing more than microcrystalline quartz. Novaculite has a bit of feldspar and iron and a few other geological odds and ends. When you abrade the surface of hard novaculite with the appropriate diamond grit, you fracture some of the underlying microcrystalline matrix in a very polite way and substitute some of the diamond between the quartz crystals. Now, the size of the crystals in novaculite ranges from the microcrystalline to the cryptocrystalline, which means you can make out most of the crystals under an optical microscope. The crypto (Gr. for hidden) crystals are not resolved by optical microscopy.

At any rate, the diamond partners with the crystal matrix to perform a better, that is to say, quicker and smoother honing action upon the steel.

You can further enhance the hard Arkansas stone by adding a friable 1 micron diamond compound or loose grit to the process. BTW, I have cut several wonderful stones from other micro and cryptocrystalline quartzes, charged them and used them for years with astonishingly fine results.

Another point, your Arkansas stones will last forever with the regular addition of diamond.

Warren says: "abrading a fine Arkansas stone will scratch the surface and cause it to work like a coarser stone", but my experience and others who make a living from this sort of science would respectfully disagree. Think of it less as abrading but rather as charging.

And you still have that overall hard Arkansas feel and ease of honing. But faster. And better, especially on steels like A2.

Garrett Hack has used diamond on his bench stones even longer than I have. Read DC's blog for a mention.

Hope this helps.


David Charlesworth's blog

Re: deglazing oil stones

#7

As always David...

Bob Hackett

You are a goldmine of information.

I knew as a gem and stone worker extraordinaire you would be able to shed some focused and unique light as well as wit upon this subject.

Thanks for that.

Re: deglazing oil stones

#8

David Barnett

You have never honed...

David Barnett

...until you've honed on a jasper bench stone with 1/2 micron (60,000 grit) diamond or 1/4 micron (100,000 grit). And a slab of chrysoprase leaves an insane polish on gravers when rubbed with 1/8 micron diamond (200,000 grit) in Crisco, but that's getting almost homeopathic.

Your praise makes me blush.


img

Re: deglazing oil stones

#9

More info please

Kevin Adams

David, very interesting info here. I remember reading about Garrett Hack using diamond paste on his stones several years ago. I'm going to give this a try, but a couple of questions if you have a minute:

1) I currently use a soft ark, followed by hard white, and then black (these are from Hall's and I've been very happy with their stones). I also will use my lily white washita (Norton), especially with carving tools. What grits of diamond paste would you recommend for these stones?

2) Where's the best place to get oil-based diamond paste in different grits? I see several places carry the Norton in 1, 3, and 6 micron. Other places (particularly the shaving sites) just carry the water-based.

Thanks for any further advice you can provide. I have used Larry Williams' idea of flattening/deglazing stones with a diamond plate and leaving the slurry on the stones as a way of "turbo-charging" them so to speak, but the use of diamond paste is intriguing to me.

Kevin

Re: deglazing oil stones

#10

David Barnett

Okay, but this could get longish *LINK*

David Barnett

Kevin, let me firstly clarify that I'm far from expert on sharpening stones for woodworking tools and explain that my knowledge and praxis is entirely idiosyncratic. My use of Arkansas stones has narrowed to, well... narrow tools, mostly, and a few carving gouges of simple steel and thin bevels. By narrow I mean chisels 4mm and smaller, down to #36 flat gravers (0.2mm). Whether honing with a jig or freehand, hard Arkansas stones excel where pointy or narrow tools of high sectional density are involved.

Secondly, I rarely use the softer novaculites, the so-called Washita stones, and see little advantage adulterating them with coarser diamond and have no experience doing so. Personally, I'd be disinclined to go anywhere near your Norton Lily White with loose diamond. While these soft stones are mismatched for harder more heavily-doped modern steels, the steels they do work on yield very nice results indeed*. The scarcity of Lily Whites further argues against diamond. I'm told that coarser diamond in the honing action grit range of soft Arkansas would leave deep scratches in the steel and could deleteriously fracture the more loosely bound (than hard Arkansas) mineral matrix.

One reason I prefer charging hard Arkansas is that fewer gravers are manufactured in simple carbon steel (which I prefer on silver and softer golds). Most are now HSS, and some are extremely hard versions with cobalt, and so on. The diamond lets me touch them up freehand on my hard stones.

I suppose I can't avoid addressing hard Arkansas, translucent hard, and black stones. There are hard opaque stones, hard opaque black stones, and translucent hard stones which may include hard translucent black stones. Without sinking into distinctions of nomenclature and lore, let me mention that the proper grading of these stones is by texture and specific gravity rather than by color, so navigate this quagmire with reputable dealers is my best advice.

There are multicolored hard translucent stones that kick butt on many so-called surgical blacks, reputed to be finer than other Arkansas stones. I have a nearly colorless translucent (like a clear Gummi bear) that is as fine as my translucent black, which is exceptionally fine. The search for that perfect stone can be engaging and costly. While translucence isn't an absolute guarantee of fineness, it's a good indicator you're in the right zone.

I started to get into this in my previous post, but desisted:

"Now, the size of the crystals in novaculite ranges from the microcrystalline to the cryptocrystalline, which means you can make out most of the crystals under an optical microscope. The crypto (Gr. for hidden) crystals are not resolved by optical microscopy."

I abruptly left off further explanation in a quixotic stab at uncharacteristic brevity and to avoid reinforcing my image as a wordy and pompous factotum, which, alas, not only does this reply but this very sentence utterly fails to refute.

Anyway, as I understand these mysteries, as Arkansas novaculites drop impurities during formation and migrate from the microcrystalline to the cryptocrystalline, they become more translucent, and as there is denser packing of crystals, harder and less friable. The preponderance of crystal sizes leans hugely toward the microcrystalline in novaculite. When the larger crystals are rather evenly distributed with the smaller, the interstitial spaces between these crystals approach densest packing, supporting and presenting the larger crystals that perform the cutting action on steel. When the proportions are optimal, fractures in the crystals occur evenly, presenting fresh cutting apexes with even distribution and wear. This is intuitive. What is not necessarily intuitive is that loose diamond, whether in water, oil, or entirely medium-free, performs in at least four ways to enhance honing.

First, the diamond rolls about dislodging partially fractured quartz crystals, to present fresh cutting surfaces at a somewhat quicker rate. Secondly, some of the diamond will find purchase in pits, cracks, and fissures in the multiplicity of quartz crystal sizes and presentation angles, increasing the number of fine cutting crystals. Thirdly, some of the diamond will embed in metallic debris leftover from prior honing operations, further increasing the cutting apexes where quartz apexes have been glazed over, restoring some cutting action to stones with a more challenging wear history. Fourthly, some of the loose diamond scratches away at the steel, of course.

What might initially and intuitively appear to more quickly wear down the stone is eventually overcome by the surface reaching a sort of sustainable parity through additional diamond charging. At this point, there is enough embedded diamond to diminish the rate of surface wear, and that embedded diamond has been fractured and contoured (diamond has perfect cleavage, which enables this) to approximate the natural scratch pattern of the quartz with the advantage of less wear and faster cutting (more cutting apexes).

I suppose if there is a heuristic for diamond and hard honing stones, it would say "the more densely packed the crystal matrix with a greater proportion of cryptocrystalline quartz, the greater the advantage gained by adding diamond, and at smaller grit sizes relative to that proportion of the cryptocrystalline to microcrystalline." Or maybe not.

BTW, one should check flatness of any stone before charging with diamond. Any cupping should be corrected (ground or lapped flat).

Lest I leave the impression that my own sharpening is not only eclectic but over-complicated, bizarre, and Byzantine, for most woodworking tools I grind on a Baldor 7" 1800-rpm model with friable white or blue Norton wheels, followed up by a 600-grit diamond plate (I totally prefer well-broken-in polycrystalline EZE-laps -- when most people think their lap has given out, that's when it's broken*in, IMO), or a diamond-charged medium India stone. Next I lap with diamond on grey iron. Lastly, I strop on horse butt with a mixture of chromium oxide and 1/2 micron diamond. Fast. Damned fast.

Here's a link to MSC for oil-based diamond compound in several concentrations. I also use LapidaryPro High Grade Friable Diamond Compound and loose diamond from Rob Kulakofsky at ColorWright Lapidary & Gems. Good people, good prices.

http://tinyurl.com/LapidaryProFriableDiamond

While this is intended for gem faceters, I use it on tools, as well.

*Those buttery-honing high-carbon fine-grained water-quenched simple tool steels of yesteryear.


oil-based diamond compound from MSC

Re: deglazing oil stones

#11

Arkansas stones

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Our traditional western tools were developed with Arkansas stones, or Turkey stones, or the like in mind. You could say they were designed for these stones. We use the finer Arkansas stones to polish and finish the edge; abrasive removal of material is not really important at this stage. We use these stones in concert with the softer Arkansas stones.

If you are using tools that were designed to be sharpened with diamonds or other brash abrasives, or if you are using tools which were designed with no thought at all as to how they might be sharpened, you are playing a very different game. It could well be that these stones make a nice substrate for diamonds.

I think your suggestion that the addition of diamonds improves the longevity of a fine Arkansas stone is short on science and experience. You admit that the diamonds fracture the quartz crystals. The diamond is significantly harder so it is reasonable to assume that periodic additions of diamond abrade the surface also. I don't know if such wear is significant. I doubt that you have ever measured the wear on a translucent or black stone. My black stone was a sold as 1 inch thick when new in 1976. I has not been adulterated with abrasives. I never measured it carefully before, but this morning it was 1.000 inches thick.

Re: deglazing oil stones

#12

David Barnett

Much of what you say makes sense, but...

David Barnett

"I think your suggestion that the addition of diamonds improves the longevity of a fine Arkansas stone is short on science and experience."

You're welcome to your opinion, Warren, but what I said is supported by materials scientists and solid state physicists, primarily in France, Germany and Switzerland. Supposedly, diamond has been used to prolong the cutting qualities on stones used in small-scale knife manufacturing in Thiery and on the traditional gem grinding wheels of Idar-Oberstein. Saint-Gobain Abrasives, of which Norton is a subsidiary, has spent R&D time and money on this very subject.

Although Norton does not say in their literature that diamond extends the life of their stones, I am given to understand that is indeed so, and that eventually, the diamond needed to maintain the enhanced cutting action becomes minimal. At any rate, we are talking about minute amounts of diamond at all stages, akin to the low-concentrations of spray diamond on ceramic laps for polishing rubies and sapphires.

If I have been deceived and have hereby misinformed others, please forgive me. As I clearly stated, I am not an expert nor do I have a commercial interest in such practices. I am repeating what I have learned from others.

You should also note that I did not support the use of diamond on soft Arkansas stones, as the same experts who convinced me that diamond works with hard Arkansas stones do not support its use on soft.

"If you are using tools that were designed to be sharpened with diamonds or other brash abrasives, or if you are using tools which were designed with no thought at all as to how they might be sharpened, you are playing a very different game."

Many of the tools I use are of older and often antique tool steel formulation, as alluded to in my footnote, and I value my Arkansas stones for honing these. However, I have found that both the diamond-charged and unaltered versions of these stones produce very fine patterns under the microscope (I have several), and that the edge in refinement goes to the charged, both in speed and fineness of polish. You are free to believe I am entirely misguided in my assessment or worse.

I should also add that diamond properly used is entirely compatible with antique tool steels as well as many Japanese steels. It need not be brash, as you say. Diamond, and especially the friable diamond grades favored by many lapidarists, can produce highly refined tool surfaces and edges.

"It could well be that these stones make a nice substrate for diamonds."

My experience says this is so. Please remember that I limit my interest in charged hard Arkansas stones to sharpening tools that would otherwise damage softer substrates. I prefer to sharpen wider tools and most modern steels on stones and laps other than Arkansas.

"I doubt that you have ever measured the wear on a translucent or black stone."

If you knew me better, you'd be less likely to think so, but in this case you're absolutely right. I'm entirely going on the hearsay of others whose opinions I respect. If I am wrong, however, at the rate my stones seem to be disappearing, they will long outlive my ignorant albeit unintentional abuse.

To be fair and balanced, while you have offered your opinion, Warren, I must note that you have offered no evidence to the contrary as regards surface attrition due to diamond charging.

Please do not think I am disrespecting the historical and practical use of Arkansas stones. I offered an alternative method for deglazing hard Arkansas stones and further elaborated my experience with diamond when asked to do so.

Works for me, but then my Sun, Mercury and Neptune are conjunct, so your mileage may vary. :)

Re: deglazing oil stones

#13

Re: Okay, but this could get longish

Kevin Adams

David, wow, my head is hurting! Seriously, thanks for taking the time to provide all this info.

First, don't worry, my lily white is one of my guarded possessions. If I could only have one stone, that would be the one. So I would never put anything on it except honing oil!

I could understand about not putting any diamond on the soft ark (vs. an India, which is man-made), but any thoughts on using diamond on the hard white? This is a pretty hard stone, which I use as an intermediate step between the soft ark (or India) and the surgical black. I was thinking about a 6 micron on that?

Thanks for the links. From MSC, any idea what's the difference between light, medium, and heavy diamond concentration with the Norton paste (I guess it's pretty self-explanatory) and which one would you recommend? I was going to get 9 micron for the India and 3 micron for the black, and maybe trying 6 micron for the hard white depending on what you think here.

I appreciate all your assistance.

Kevin

Re: deglazing oil stones

#14

Re: thanks for answers and G Hack honing

david in indy

Thanks for the answers. I seemed to have unwittingly triggered some very passionate responses.

One of the responders mentioned hearing that Garrett Hack used dimaond paste on his oilstones. I just finished a class with Garrett and he was the person who suggested that my surgical black stone was glazed. He does use 2 micron diamond paste as his final honing step but on a hardwood substrate - Vermont cherry - but hard maple works too.

Re: deglazing oil stones

#15

Re: thanks for answers and G Hack honing

Kevin Adams

Thanks, David. No worries on stirring up passion...it's good for the soul!

So Garrett no longer uses diamond paste on his surgical black? There was an article in FWW from several years ago (I found it over the weekend) where it shows him putting the paste on his black stone and he did mention it was his "secret weapon" (or something to that effect). Did he happen to say anything about using it on his stones and why he stopped? More importantly, what advice did Garrett give on unglazing your stones? He would know as well as anyone.

Kevin

Re: deglazing oil stones

#16

David Barnett

I used to be passionate...

David Barnett

...about scraping metal flat, too, but the three brain cells allocated to my tool surfacing and sharpening issues don't leave much room for passion, nowadays. I just try to get the job done as quickly as possible with the least fuss. I enjoy what I do and what I use to do it but there are so many ways of accomplishing satisfactory and satisfying results, so many styles and approaches, that I'm often amused and enlightened by what others choose.

I especially enjoy expanding options rather than limiting them, so I retain curiosity and eagerness to try new ideas. Novelty doesn't threaten me. I like to mix it up a little. Life's too short and most things are too unimportant to dogmatize.

Sharpening has been an important part of my life in craft, but over the last two decades it's lost most of its pizzazz, as has, quite frankly, woodworking. They've both become more chores, these days, but chores I still enjoy.

As I caveated early on, my choices are idiosyncratic, which is, to say, highly personal and personalized. I claim no particular expertise and have little to no investment in what others do, but am willing to share my experience, especially while I'm waiting for the bread to bake or the epoxy to set or the glass in the kiln to reach the fusing point.

Hope I provided some fun and another option or two.

Re: deglazing oil stones

#17

David Barnett

Two quick answers

David Barnett

"... which I use as an intermediate step between the soft ark (or India) and the surgical black. I was thinking about a 6 micron on that?"

I would not interpolate diamond mesh sizes to a similar linearity in novaculite, but would likely use the same grade as recommended for hard translucent for your opaque hard stone. Remember, stones vary significantly, so go slow and carefully observe your results.

Actually, it wouldn't hurt to go to 1 micron on the black, which equates to around 14,000 mesh, which is the compound (ivory color) I most often use. I have used 8,000 mesh, about 4 microns, on stones to good effect, so try 3 microns if you like. My suggestion is to use the coarser diamond (the Norton recommendations) to deglaze and the 1 micron to charge, at least until you see whether or not it's for you.

On a stone that does not need deglazing, try it on an end or side before committing the entire surface. Baby steps.

As for concentrations, I prefer low to medium for honing, but that's me. I formulate my own high-concentration compounds from loose diamond in various media for gem carving at the fixed arbor. I've learned to appreciate lower concentrations for non-carving tasks such as honing. Spreading thinly and evenly gives best results.

Re: deglazing oil stones

#18

Re: I used to be passionate...

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

I certainly thank all of you, you've provided an excellent use for my ancient (I've had it 30 years) black Arkansas that I more or less hate (maybe dislike would be a better word, not much passion about this any more). Best thing about it is the box I made to house it. But now, as a diamond substrate, marvellous idea.

Pam

Re: deglazing oil stones

#19

Re: thanks for answers and G Hack honing

david in indy

Garrett didn't say anything about no longer using diamond paste on his oilstones (for all I know he may still be doing it) and I wasn't aware of the practice. He only explained that honing with 2 micron paste on a piece of wood was his final step.

Unfortunately, it didn't occur to me to ask him how I should de-glaze my stone. I'll let you know if I find out.