New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

soft arkansas oil stones

Posts

soft arkansas oil stones

#1

soft arkansas oil stones

les winter

In a post, below, I got good information on using an intermediate stone between my Norton medium india and my black hard. I found a soft arkansas at Dan's Whetstones for a good price. It is sucking up the oil I spread on it in a few places. I had been using straight kerosene. Lately I have tried water with some dishwashing liquid mixed in per some info I found by Adam Cherubini.

Do I need to soak the new soft arkansas in honing oil? Can I use water and soap on it? Thanks for any responses.

Les

Re: soft arkansas oil stones

#2

Re: soft arkansas oil stones

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Usually Arkansas stones are somewhat more aggressive when new or newly resurfaced. As the surface is used they become better at smoothing the bevel (removing scratches) and less effective at removing great amounts of material. So I would expect it to act like a finer stone as time goes on. I don't think you will hurt the stone with any of the liquids you mention, but I like to have a liquid that is viscous enough to suspend the iron particles. I don't think plain water or kerosene do this very well.

Re: soft arkansas oil stones

#3

Re: soft arkansas oil stones

les winter

Hi Warren. What do you use?

Re: soft arkansas oil stones

#4

Re: soft arkansas oil stones

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Les, I used a mixture of motor oil and kerosene for many years. When I switched to full time work I had throat irritation from the constant exposure to kerosene. Since then I have used either honing oil or thread cutting oil. I like the honing oil better, but the other is much cheaper. I think honing oil is more highly refined, not so much of a mixture of different weight oils. A mixture of oils can have its volatile portions flee leaving behind more gummy stuff. Stones used every day are not so vulnerable to gumming.

Re: soft arkansas oil stones

#5

Re: soft arkansas oil stones

Kevin Adams

Les,

I've also recently added a soft ark to my sharpening process and have been very pleased with the results. I still have my fine India, but I think the soft ark does a better job refining the edge and working the burr. Btw, I noticed mine was really sucking up the oil, too, so before it got loaded up with steel particles, I did soak it in honing oil for a day or so. It seemed to help.

Kevin

Re: soft arkansas oil stones

#6

Re: soft arkansas oil stones

les winter

where are you going to get good info like this?

thanks all.

lw