New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Lap-Sharp

Posts

Lap-Sharp

#1

Lap-Sharp

Larry Williams

We looked for some time for some way to lap freshly heat treated irons flat faster than what we were doing. There are several options out there including modifying a lapidary machine. One lapping machine seemed to have the features we were looking for. We wanted one that had a big enough platen, was reversible, was operated by a foot switch, and could be used wet without making a big mess.


After a few phone calls and a little research we ordered a Lap-Sharp machine with the splash guard accessory. It basically does what we need but it has what I think is a major design flaw and another problem. The day it came in I e-mailed the company about the dubbing I was getting and asked how to remove the platen so the machine could be cleaned. We process enough steel that I knew cleaning would be an issue.

The dubbing was the result of the aluminum disks one attaches the abrasive to not being flat. I believe this is a recent change because earlier disks were anodized and during one earlier phone call was told they were now able to have the disks stamped rather than machined. We've been mounting the disks with the convex face up and that seems to pretty much take care of the problem for the time being.

I was also told in the e-mail not to remove the platen or turntable because I wouldn't be able to get it properly aligned when I put it back on. Even with an effort to keep the machine clean we were having problems with the drain system plugging up in just a couple weeks. I had been told to just use compressed air to blow back into the machine. We use it enough that we get a lot of steel swarf building up. Without removing the platen, I removed the back/bottom of the machine to see what could be done. The drain port is just a plastic elbow with a 3/16" ID. That's not enough and the drain system is just flat inadequate. I think it would have been simple to taper the arbor and platen hub to removal and alignment of the platen easy.

Here's a photo of the elbow and some of the swarf build-up I cleaned from the machine just a couple weeks after receiving the machine:


What I need to find is a long thin brush like a bottle brush about 1/4" in diameter and around 12" in length with a brush that's somewhere around 6" long. Does anyone know where to find a brush like that?

Re: Lap-Sharp

#2

Re: Lap-Sharp

John Veerkamp

Larry,

Try a scientific supply house. Lots of small tubes in lab experiments. They should have something that will work for you.

John

Re: Lap-Sharp

#3

Re: Lap-Sharp

Ron in Sterling, CT

Larry

Go to Torringtonbrushes.com and look under "tube & hole cleaning brushes". No afilliation on my part.

Good Luck.

Ron

Re: Lap-Sharp

#4

Thanks

Larry Williams

It looks like they have some that will work.

Re: Lap-Sharp

#5

craigd

Re: Lap-Sharp  *LINK*

craigd

You might look at CamelBak clean kits. CamelBaks are water backpacks for bicycle riders and have a long hose that needs cleaning if you drink sugar water.


CamelBak brush

Re: Lap-Sharp

#6

Try a gun-cleaning brush (.25 caliber)

Patrick Gibbons

Re: Lap-Sharp

#7

Re: Lap-Sharp  *LINK*

Ron Hock

Hi Larry,

I was impressed by the quality and functionality of the Lap-Sharp machine that Don loaned me to evaluate for my book. And several times I've relied on Don for his vast knowledge of abrasives.

Which abrasive discs do you use and how do you like them?


BTW: Lap-Sharp website is here.

Re: Lap-Sharp

#8

Re: Lap-Sharp

Larry Williams

Ron,

We're using 80 and 120 mesh Regalite and 80 and 120 micron Regal abrasives. The abrasives seem pretty good but the tenacious adhesives make changing abrasives a little difficult. Overall the machine is built like a tank and does what we need pretty well. Don was very helpful when I talked to him before the purchase and even sent sample abrasives so we could get a good idea about what we wanted.

I do wish the disks were flat and I hope installing them convex side up will be a permanent solution. We'll see. Don seemed unaware that the disks weren't flat. My guess is it's an artifact of the stamping operation.

This was supposed to result in time and effort savings for us and it has. I just wish simple modifications to the design had been incorporated to help overcome the drainage/cleaning problem. The machine is a good one but has some nagging issues that make it less efficient than it could be. You really need to be able to easily clean machines like this.

Re: Lap-Sharp

#9

Caught it on fire, yet?

Neal in San Jose

I think I even have a 50 Regalite; I'll have to check when I get home tonight. The shavings that accumulated around the platter actually caught on fire once when I was doing some heavy duty grinding. Now I don't let it accumulate so deep. None of my platters are noticably non-flat, and I know several people that have Lap-sharps, and no one has ever mentioned that problem. How far out of flat is it?

Re: Lap-Sharp

#10

Re: Caught it on fire, yet?

Larry Williams

No, no fires. We use it wet.

The disks used to be machined and I think those were an anodized gold color. The new ones are just mill aluminum finish and are somewhere around .020" different from the perimeter to the center, just guessing because I never measured it. That's enough to cause a lot of dubbing if the disks are used with the abrasive on the concave face.

Re: Lap-Sharp

#11

That has potential to be a very serious problem

Bruce, a MN Galoot

On one of the knife forums I read (KnifeDogs), there was a warning posted about not using the same grinder, either wheel or belt, to grind steel AND aluminum. Those are the ingredients in thermite and will burn exceedingly hot and flash very quickly. I recall a demonstration in infantry training of thermite grenades burning through the exterior of a tank.

Re: Lap-Sharp

#12

Re: Lap-Sharp

ThomD

For wooden boat building we used these 8" disc grinders with really aggressive papers to freehand a lot of stuff. Very effective, but they were terrible to change the papers on. Later was schooled by a pro, to just find some raw wood somewhere and hold them down hard, and let the heat build up to the point where the papers where easily lifted off. Probably wouldn't work in a wet operation, but a heat gun or torch might.

Follow up, now the discs are all twice the cost, and the pads are velcro, and not really an improvement as far as I can see, since the adhesive worked better once you got the hang of it.

Re: Lap-Sharp

#13

Re: Lap-Sharp issues...

Joe Rogers, Northern Virginia

I should think the manufacturer would heed your comments on a non flat platen and a clogging drain. The drain should be a non issue and easily corrected with a part upgrade. The platen should be flat. If the intended use is to flatten the backs of edge tools (or one of the advertised uses) the manufacturer should make it flat however it has to happen. Just my opinion.

You seem to have a lot of patience here. :\

JR

Re: Lap-Sharp

#14

Not really

Neal in San Jose

I've seen the same thing happen at bench grinders in a tool room. The grinding residue builds up under the tool rest and the hot sparks are enough to start a small fire in the iron filings. It is just something to be aware of and not let the grindings build up. Obviously, if you are using it wet, it would not be a problem.

I would NEVER use my Lap-Sharp with aluminum. I've seen what happens when someone tries to grind aluminum on a bench grinder, so I'd guess that it would clog up the abrasive on a Lap-Sharp in nothing flat (pun intended).

My platters are all different collors. It really helps in keeping the grits organized: the red 20 micron abrasive goes on the red platter, blue 10 micron on the blue, etc. Now you have me wondering about the flatness, tho. I'll measure mine when I get a minute and check back in. Getting old abrasives off isn't required very often, and fairly easy with a hot-air gun. Not exactly fun; maybe up there with emptying the dust collector bag, but not a big issue. Oh, wait, are dust collectors allowed on this side?

Re: Lap-Sharp

#15

"...are dust collectors allowed on this side?"

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Only organic ones.


img

Re: Lap-Sharp

#16

Re: Lap-Sharp issues...

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Yeah, I'm with you, Joe, no way I'd pay $800+ and accept warped platters. In fact, being frugal, I'd yell at a $200 price point, below which I'd probably try to fix it.

Pam

Re: Lap-Sharp

#17

Re: Lap-Sharp

Don Naples

It looks as though you may have a bad disc.

I grabbed a few from stock and measured them on a granite reference plate. The run out was typically less than �.001 of an inch on the top side across the entire width of the disc from center to edge. The bottom of the punched side was greater, but still pretty small. We initially cut the discs with a laser and had round holes. I later moved the process to a compound press that holds the disc flat and then does the punching action. When I made that change, I also added a square hole to the discs so there could be no unscrewing of the locking knob caused by the reverse rotation of the platen. You can see a sample disc measurement of flatness on Youtube www.youtube.com/watch?v=enYoTT5Fi00. I have never before had anyone report an issue with the drain. I did see a demo unit that had heavy use and had not been cleaned that had a plugged drain. I blew compressed air in the hose to clear the fitting and blew and washed out the residue. As you mention, the Lap-Sharp is built like a tank. It has a cast aluminum housing with a ��NPT thread drain hole to which we screw a nylon drain fitting that has been modified to increase drain clearance. You can certainly install a larger fitting to increase the diameter of the drain and install a larger hose. We designed a system that really worked well and then did our best to reduce cost without reducing performance so we could achieve a reasonable price point. There are still woodworkers who think the price of the Lap-Sharp is too high. We did our best but it is made in the USA and has a direct drive, right angle sealed gear motor that is custom made for us with a fan, hardened steel shaft, and needle bearings. It is used commercially at two car company�s pattern shops and also at least by one other plane maker. You can return any discs that do not meet your performance requirements and I will replace them.

Re: Lap-Sharp

#18

Re: Lap-Sharp

Larry Williams

I measured the disks today. One is .007" out from rim to center (over 4"), one .008" and two are .009". That doesn't seem like much but it's quite a bit more than I allow my stones to go out and Don McConnell is more diligent about keeping stones flat than me. The resulting dubbing makes switching from the machine to stones more work than we had anticipated. By putting the disks under tension with the concave side down, we've reduced the error to an acceptable amount and can live with that. It would have been helpful to not have to worked this out and found some indication of this in the instructions.

The cleaning issue is bigger. Yes, I can bore and tap a new drain hole but I shouldn't have to. Machining mating tapers in the hub and its arbor would make everything so it can be easily disassembled, cleaned and reassembled. If a machine is designed to abrade away metal, there's obviously going to be some swarf to deal with. Why not make this easy instead of an awkward work-around with long brushes and little visibility? We'll have to do this each time the machine is used and I think it's an unnecessary inconvenience and loss of time.

I don't object to paying the price for a well made machine and that's what the Lap-Sharp is. It just has a couple flaws in the design that keep it from being what it could easily be. I was a little disappointed that my e-mail about these problems seemed so casually dismissed. I'd really like to have the kind of machine I could, without reservation, highly recommend. As it is, it will serve our needs but with some nagging issues.

Re: Lap-Sharp

#19

Re: Lap-Sharp

Don Naples

Larry: I was surprised at your comment: �I was a little disappointed that my e-mail about these problems seemed so casually dismissed.� I thought I had missed something, so went back to reread your message about this issue.

You wrote: �It's possible the dishing of the aluminum disks is a good thing as long as I mark which side is the bottom with some permanent way. When the knob is tightened it seems to rigidly tension the disks against the turntable. I like the idea of this tensioning as long as the rubber on the face of the turntable doesn't eventually start to compress and take on the dished shape.�

Maybe it is my mistake, but it seemed to me you were satisfied you had a solution for the warp of the discs you have. As I showed in the video clip, this is not normal and the discs I sampled are flat.

Our next and last communications were about providing information about your hand planes at a woodworking meeting where I was a presenter. I never received another message from you and was told by a friend that this posting had occurred. I am proud of the support we provide our customers and appreciate comments from them which help us to improve our products. Your feedback about enlarging the drain is appreciated. While it has never before been a reported problem, I will certainly consider a design modification when we run our next batch of castings. If you want me to modify your machine to fix the drain issue, please let me know.

Re: Lap-Sharp

#20

Re: Lap-Sharp

Larry Williams

Don,

If I knew of a better machine, I would have returned the Lap-Sharp and bought the better one. I don't and didn't. At some point we may make disks of hardened and surface ground 3/16" tool steel. These, I think, would stay flat and allow removal of the abrasives without concern about warping the disks. I certainly understand what this costs and why the machine isn't equipped that way.

Even with the machine being as good as it is, I'm still left with the problem of how to clean it. Without being able to remove the turn table, platen or what ever it's called; cleaning is difficult and time consuming. Finding a solution to that is what I was looking for in my first post. I also wanted to explain why we selected the Lap-Sharp and other things we ran into. In the past others here have mentioned having one and I thought it was likely they'd found solutions to these things.

Re: Lap-Sharp

#21

Re: Lap-Sharp

Don Naples

Larry:

I have some ideas on how to increase the draining capacity of the Lap-Sharp.

I will order some parts and let you know when I have a better solution.

Re: Lap-Sharp

#22

Re: Lap-Sharp

Mark

Although I have lately not participated in this sort of on-line discussion I would like to comment here. I have had and used a Lap Sharp for several years. Don has been more than helpful sorting out issues. I�m sure he will fix these as well. As well I�ve spoken to Larry several times at meetings. His knowledge is amazing and his interest in teaching is much appreciated. Now, I have had the same dubbing that Larry spoke of. My disks are not flat either. However this dubbing is subtle. It can be seen at the corners when flattening the back of especially a wide blade. I have found that holding the blade directly in line with the center of the disk seems to minimize this. That said, I have lately gone back to diamond stones and water stones for the final flattening of the back. The Lap Sharp is still the best tool for rapidly initially flattening a blade back - especially an old one. I also at times will quickly improve the bevel edge - freehand - on the machine so I can get back to work.

The Veritas system uses a laminated disk. This appears to be layers of aluminum over a resin (plastic) center. I have checked these. They are flat. When I get around to it I plan to use some of the Veritas disks on the Lap Sharp - - - after I cut the square hole in them. Don should probably move to this sort of laminated disk. Bottom line - the Lap Sharp wet grinder is still the best at what it does but it does have some issues.

Re: Lap-Sharp

#23

Questions for Don

Bob Hackett

It seems to me that if your plates are not of as high quality and as close tolerance as the drive then the trouble you have taken with custom building that drive is pretty much canceled out.If you are having problems from the 2 of your customers that post here with quality control and dubbing issues on these plates then that`s not just a small thing when presenting a machine like yours.

The bigger question is why would someone build a machine like this that is a bear to clean?One of the first things I learned in building and maintaining machines is if you want to have good end results and hold to tight tolerances then start with clean gear and keep it as clean as possible.

The machines used for faceting gems have been around for quite a while and these have been made to stay flat and can still be disassembled to be cleaned.Perhaps if you adapted some of the technology already in place there it would help solve your problems.

I wish you luck and hope you can work these issues out and move forward with your machines.

Re: Lap-Sharp

#24

Re: Lap-Sharp

Don Naples

Hi Larry:

A larger drain and hose is on the way to you now.

It will fit the thread size in the casting so no need to drill and tap a larger hole.

I hope the suggestion I made about using a pivot arm with a magnet held near the surface of the abrasive helps.

I know this will catch a lot of the abraded steel so it does not make its way to the drain area.

This combination should solve the issue, but if not please let me know.

Don

Re: Lap-Sharp

#25

Thanks!

Larry Williams

Looking forward to trying it.