I need a new #5 Plane
Thomas Norton
I need to replace and old Craftsman plane and the size would be a #5. I would not mind refurbishing a plane but ebay did not have much.
Any thoughts?
Thanks!
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
I need a new #5 Plane
Thomas Norton
I need to replace and old Craftsman plane and the size would be a #5. I would not mind refurbishing a plane but ebay did not have much.
Any thoughts?
Thanks!
A few questions
Neal in San Jose
Budget? Intended use? How is the Craftsman missing the mark? The number 5 is a very versitle plane that can see use as a small jointer or a large smoother or a scrub. Sometimes all three. As far a cost goes, you could consider a $5 flea market woofer up to a Holtey that cost more than my car. Regular poster and sponsor Rob Lee offers at least two models that may fill your bill, and would be a good place to start looking, but I you need to give us a little more information to help you narrow the field. Also remember, if you get two woodworkers talking about which plane is best, you are likely to end up with at least three opinions!
I sent you an e-mail
Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA
two, actually.
Re: A few questions
Jerry Nicholson
I initially decided old Stanleys were the way to go and got carried away, of course. That resulted in having several Stanley #5 planes in good working condition, some with Veritas irons and Hock chip breakers. However, the Lee Valley Veritas Bevel Up jack plane is my "go to" plane when I need to do something. Likewise the Lee Valley Bevel Up Smoother. My 40 or 50 Stanleys look great on display in my workshop but I would have saved a lot of money by just buying the Lee Valley planes in the first place.
Jerry
Re: I need a new #5 Plane
scott grandstaff
A #5??
A?????
Brother you need at least 3, number 5 planes. At the barest minimum!!
One #5? fuggitaboutit!
I'd as soon chew salted razor blades!
It fits in neatly between scrub plane and smoother. It can't hog as much wood as a true scrub, but it will knock down the furrows the scrub leaves faster than anything. A rank cambered blade and heavy duty hardware/wood. You need to reconfigure your old Craftsman for this service.
You do need a small jointer for smaller work and there is nothing better for less money. Barely cambered blade. I keep a Stanley 605 for this.
You need one for a large smoother for larger panel work. Set very fine and true. I keep a Sargent VBM, with custom carved wood and a massive blade for this duty.
You could theoretically reconfigure the same plane for all these jobs, but you won't, trust me. It takes too much time.
Better to keep a harem already set up.
A 4th for knock around rough exterior work is not out of the question (you going to take your fine smoother out into the dirt after the garden gate??)
and a dogmeat "loaner" in case a neighbor or relative hassles you?
Contrary to popular conception and trend, its the jack plane that separates the wood -worker- from the poser.
You want jack!
yours Scott
Re: I need a new #5 Plane
Jerry Nicholson
My loaner is a 50 year old Craftsman. I don't know who made it but I have two old Craftsman plane that were made with short frogs - the bottom 3/4 inch of the blade is unsupported unless the frog is backed up to the point where the blade bevel presses on the sole. Then, of course, the mouth is really wide. One of these was my dad's and is well over 60 years old so I keep it around for sentimental reasons. The other I loan out and I don't care if it comes back! They are useful only white pine. Before I got my first Stanley #4, I just assumed that I would never be able to hand plane hardwood.
Jerry
P.S.
Neal in San Jose
If you go over to the classifieds and look down a little, Dominic has a pretty nice looking Stanley #5 for sale that appears to still be available.
Re: P.S.
Dominic in Buck's County PA
Nope! That one went the same day I posted it. It was a sweet old Type 17 No5 that looked AWESOME. And I recently just sold a very very nice Type 19 No5C that came with a box. I even gave it a nicely cambered blade.
But that went yesterday.
If I had know anyone here was looking for one,......
ebay
James Watriss
I just hit up eBay, and entered "#5 plane" as a goof. Over 2000 hits, not all of which fit the criteria as being an actual jack plane.
"Stanley #5 plane" returned 147 hits. Not all of them were actual, complete #5 planes, but most were. And many were under $20.
I know you were looking to replace a craftsman. I don't know enough about the brand, but my suspicion is that the Stanley will work better.
Broaden your search. It's not too hard.
Re: ebay
Thomas Norton
Thanks all. I got one off eBay this AM!
Re: Tuning
Moses Yoder
I found David Charlesworth's directions for tuning a plane to be pretty useful. I would suggest finding a copy of the book with this article in it and tuning the plane accordingly.
The trouble with Craftsman (rambly)
Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA
"I don't know enough about the brand, but my suspicion is that the Stanley will work better."
In the early years - don't know exactly which years - Sears contracted out to the major makers for their planes: Stanley and Sargent probably at least, maybe also Millers-Falls (I owned a Dunlap No. 5 for a bit that showed signs of M-F construction features, and I still would if I didn't have too many No. 5s and needed to thin the herd); don't know about Union. I have a very early, first-logo, Craftsman No. 6 that's quite a substantial plane.
At some point, and certainly by the 1970s when I bought my first woodworking tools, from Sears because I didn't know any better, they were contracting out to someone, but not someone with good quality control. I struggled for years with my Craftsman No. 5 before learning enough to look at the sole and to discover that there was a hollow in front of the mouth deep enough to render that part of the sole useless (just shy of "you could fit a Siamese cat in here"). I gave it away to someone who liked the principle of having woodworking tools but never actually uses them; we both felt better.
I have seen a Craftsman block plane that appears to have been made as a first project by a group of junior high school students learning iron casting from a shop teacher who really should have retired ten years ago, thank you, but was placed in the assignment by a principal who has no respect for shop, and who read the book on how to do metalwork the week before class started*.
That, in my opinion, is the problem with Craftsman woodworking hand tools: their inconsistency. If you're educated enough about what to seek to identify the planes made well by a good maker, you can get some pretty good older Sears tools for less than the Name Brands. But by the time you're smart enough for that, you probably have good tools already.
OK...I'm avoiding my work because it's outside, and it's cold and drippy (rained, a little, but all night) and, even though I'm protected by a tarp set up as an awning, it's not fun; but it needs done, so I'd best go do it.
-------
*I mean no disrespect to teachers who wind up doing analogous things but doing them well, by the way. I have had some excellent instruction from people who were parachuted into a class at the last minute and were figuring it out along with the class; the humility and open exploration this engendered made for really good learning.
Re: The trouble with Craftsman?
Jay Samuels
Bill: In general, I agree with you, but any number of people seem to think some toxic substance will attack their projects if anything marked "Craftsman" touches it, irrespective of the quality of the tool. I have a MF made Craftsman 78 that is identical to my MF 78 except for the logo. The old Sargent made Craftsman adjustable mouth block plane is a very nice tool, much easier to find than a Sargent, and much less expensive when you find it. The key, as you say, is knowledge. Jay
Sears duplex rabbet planes
Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA
I didn't know Millers-Falls made 78-style planes for Sears. I know Sargent did; I gave my Sargent-made Craftsman to my son at some point; and just gave him a similar Sargent-badged plane after I scored an earlier model Sargent that's way cooler.
What he said
James Watriss
When I tuned an old stanley up, using that article, it performed as well or better than my Lie-Nielsen.
Side tip: Charlesworth mentions using silicon carbide powder to rub things together. Typically that's a huge industrial order type thing. But Shapton also sells/sold small bottles of it for use with their lapping plates to flatten their stones with.
So does Lee Valley
Cecil Nickerson in Halfmoon Bay