New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Refurbishing an Old WW Vise

Posts

Refurbishing an Old WW Vise

#1

Refurbishing an Old WW Vise

John McGaw

I was given an old cast-iron vise marked "The Columbia Vise & Mfg. Co", "Cleveland Ohio U.S.A.". Vintage is unknown but it clearly isn't new and it has seen some abuse. The big problems are rust and dirt, a quick-release on the screw mechanism which doesn't do much of anything (except to release when it shouldn't) and a front "finger" (or whatever that little bit is that is supposed to rise up above the front jaw to enable clamping a workpiece between it and a bench dog).

I've never restored any old tools but would like to tackle this as a learning experience. Dirt and rust can probably be taken care of most easily by media blasting and repainting; or if this will ruin some inherent antique value perhaps there is another way to tackle it. The quick release situation is unknown but opening up the housing will probably tell the tale but it is possible it is nothing more than something stuck in place by rust.. And the stuck "finger" will probably yield to some penetrating oil and patience. Does this sound like a plan or am I heading for disaster and ruin?

Re: Refurbishing an Old WW Vise

#2

Re: Refurbishing an Old WW Vise

Bob Entwisle in NJ

Hi John,

Sounds like a plan to me, but what do I know?

Does the vise resemble the drawing in this link?

http://mprime.com/Emmert/columbian.htm

Re: Refurbishing an Old WW Vise

#3

The question...

Joe Rogers, Northern Virginia

What do you want to do with the vise? If you want to use it at least make it functional. That can't really hurt any value. If you have no intention of selling the vise and want to use it a lot, I say rehab to your hearts desire. A visit to the on line auction sites to check values for equivalent units may show the value, at best, wouldn't preclude the rehab anyway.

Joe

Re: Refurbishing an Old WW Vise

#4

Re: Refurbishing an Old WW Vise

Ron in Sterling, CT

Hi John,

The Columbian Vise is a very good, solid, old "Made in USA" vise. I bought one at a flea market this summer for $25 (not the quick release model) and am in the process of cleaning it up and painting it before mounting it to my bench. Not a big job, just need some time and patience.

As a point of reference, on another woodworking website several Columbian vises were just sold. The quick release vises brought $60, and the non-quick release vises brought $50.

Good luck in cleaning it up, and using it, or selling it.

Ron

Re: Refurbishing an Old WW Vise

#5

Re: Refurbishing an Old WW Vise

ThomD

There are different approaches to value in various fields, it is very common place with industrial tools to do restorations, in which the tool is returned to something like new condition, think of antique cars. Hard to see how this would improve historical valuations, but it does seem to improve market pricing for non-extraordinary items.

There are lots of sites and threads on restoring old machines, you could try a place like Practical machinist, or search on things like electrolysis rust removal

http://www.rickswoodshopcreations.com/Miscellaneous/Rust_Removal.htm

Though I haven't read that specific article. Good idea to read several to check main details.

Re: Refurbishing an Old WW Vise

#6

Re: Refurbishing an Old WW Vise

John McGaw

It doesn't resemble any of the vises shown on the webpage -- mine is a straightforward woodworker's vise with no taper adjustment or fancy pattern-maker's features. I need to study the castings a bit but I see what looks like a 1RB on the front above the handle; if I get a bright light and illuminate it at a glancing angle I can probably read it better. There is a different number on the back casting on the part where the screw engages but I haven't had time to record any of these.

I'm not really interested in selling this as an antique or anything and was just going to mount it at the opposite end of my bench from the existing one. Making it work well and look clean(ish) is good enough for me. My heirs can worry about antique value when I'm gone.

Re: Refurbishing an Old WW Vise

#7

Columbia

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Columbia made a whole range of vises. I owned a Columbia metalworker's vise that was clearly developed for the homeowner who wanted to step up from the cheapest vises.