We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
Lessons Learned...Adventures in mounting an Emmert *LINK*
James Watriss
So, after fussing with this thing for a while, I finally put up an account of everything I went through to get my Emmert vise mounted.
Originally, I tried to inset the vise, figuring I might still have enough room for it to function well that way. Turns out that's not the case. But I did figure out how to get rear jaw in line with the front edge of the bench.
Well, most of the work involved resulted in learning why it was a bad idea to try to have a contoured inset.
The shorter version of how I'd do it all now is:
-Lay out using the clamped-on board trick.
-Cut the square notch out of the end of the bench.
-Dig out the wood under the bench top to clear the hub and beam.
-Set the mounting plate into the bench surface.
-Mount the vise.
I could have kept it to that, but I figured I'd record the rest of the process for posterity, in case some other nitwit besides me had the same ideas about how the vise should fit neatly into the front edge of the bench. In my mind, it was a neat, clean job. In reality, it wasn't such a good idea.
Re: Lessons Learned...Adventures in mounting an Emmert *LINK*
I have a Wilton vise that attempts to do a simplified version of the Emmert - I'd offer a picture except that it's buried in my storage shed. I considered making it flush, but realized I'd have to chew out so much of the front of the bench that it wouldn't really be the front anymore.
It lasted about nine months, before having the rear face of the jaw 2" out from the front of the bench drove me crazy. One of the things I learned from the experience is that a flush jaw provides quite a bit of support for longish boards held in the vise - the lateral support from touching the front of the bench makes them far less likely to start wiggling when one tries to plane edges.
I still have the vise because I have this fantasy that I'll someday have a shop large enough to have the bench out on the floor instead of against the wall, and picture mounting the vise on some odd corner for its swiveling feature when shaping offbeat pieces of wood. More likely, my sons/grandchildren will wonder why I kept it all those years as they're cleaning out my shop and environs.
Re: Lessons Learned...Adventures in mounting an Emmert *LINK*
I know what you mean. I've worked with vises that sat out like that before, and they drove me nuts. I like having the front edge of the bench in line with the vise... and having some T-track mounted in the front edge of the top, to hold the ends of long boards. Still... I've seen a lot of benches that have them just stuck on the edge like that.
I'd been sitting on the vise for a year and a half, because i hadn't really figured out how to lay out for the flush mount, or how to proceed from there. Eventually I wrapped my head around it all, and... well, now you know how that went.
After all that, I decided it wasn't worth the effort. At least, not to me. Next time, if there is one, I'll glue up all but the last 2" of the bench, mount the vise, and laminate the last board to come out to be in line with the rear jaw.
Your comment about how it was one of those 'I think I'll just put this on now,' projects is a valid one. Looking back, there are things I'd have done differently, and I can't help thinking I should have had them figured out. I'd done a fair amount of homework on how it was all supposed to happen beforehand, but there were other things that hadn't occurred to me until I was ankle deep in debris, and some that didn't make sense until after everything was done.
I can remember a time when I wouldn't have been able to wrap my mind around any of it, and it would have remained a pipe dream. Now I get to be the guy who did the experiments. And even since writing the whole thing up this morning, I'm still putting things together in my mind. It's not surprising, I've had plenty of projects where it took 2 or 3 times of doing something to really get it all worked out. Next time...
Well, if I go through all that again, and figure out how to make it work better, I'll write about it then.
Re: Lessons Learned...Adventures in mounting an Emmert *LINK*
it's also a matter of what we see when we know more. I briefly worked as an auto detailer in a Chevrolet/Cadillac dealership in my youth. When I started, I was knocked out by the Cadillac paint jobs; but after three months, I could look across a Caddy hood - and back then, when you could have housed a family of five on top of the hood and had room to park a VW on it too, "look across" meant something - and see waves of color change across the width of the hood. Subtle, but there; I learned during that short job that Cadillacs were famous amongst detailers for the inconsistency of their paint colors. Fortunately, few of the customers for Cadillacs could see what we could.
Re: Lessons Learned...Adventures in mounting an Emmert *LINK*
This was one thing I like better about the Tucker, it seems to have been designed for woodworking benches as we have them today. Even there, while I love my vise, It is sorta on the bench not part of it. Which has lead me to wonder whether the approach shown in the Landis book might be better-a free standing post mount. I use the vise 10 times as much as the bench, and the bench is mostly just a surface next to it. When I use the bench proper, the vise is mostly in the way. It seems that it would be just as good to have them separate. Often when using the vise I would prefer it higher, and better still height adjustable.
Re: Lessons Learned...Adventures in mounting an Emmert *LINK*
I know what you mean. One the things I'm looking forward to is rotating the vise 90 degrees to DT some drawers sides. With an 18" wide jaw, that should put the top end of the vise a bit higher.
I hear what you're saying about the post mount, and I did think about that a bit. But 90 pounds of cast iron is a lot to balance in the air like that, for me. I may change my mind, though. If you read another post in a few months about me scabbing the old bench top back together again, you'll know.
Re: Lessons Learned...Adventures in mounting an Emmert *LINK*
So, I got the vise mounted and it's just as great as it was, if not more so. I also figured out another trick or two about getting the vise alignment dialed in perfectly. The genius of the Tucker was that proper alignment of the vise was built into the design. Well, getting an Emmert aligned wasn't as much of a leap of faith as I'd though it would be.
I read over that blog post and decided that it had good information, but was not exactly the encouraging advice I'd want to read if I was facing an installation, or trying to design a new bench for an Emmert or a clone. So I put up a new post with my final thoughts, and a few suggestions on layout and mounting. It's not as easy to mount an Emmert as it was to mount a simple QR front vise. But knowing what I know now, it'd be a lot easier and a lot less stress-inducing to accurately mount one of these things again. So I wanted to get that information out where people could use it.
James, your Emmert blog has been very interesting to me, as I had three Emmerts before the shop burned down in '99, and my partner Pimo had a fourth, so we were loaded for bear. None of our vises was ever mounted with the rear jaw flush with the face of the bench. Instead, we supported long boards on a deadman and dealt with the space between the bench and the work the best we could.
One other thing that popped to mind as I was reading your blog is that I had non-marring clamp pads on my main (turtleback) Emmert, because I didn't want the metal jaws
Only one of the vises survived the fire in good enough shape to be useful again, but somebody accidentally threw it in the dumpster when we were cleaning out the basement a few years back, so now I have none at all.
On another note, I have spoken with the man who owns what's left of the Emmert company and all the patterns and spare parts that still exist. Unfortunately, he is in an institution now, so it looks like the end of the line for Emmert.