New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

A refurbed 12" Disston Backsaw

Posts

A refurbed 12" Disston Backsaw

#1

A refurbed 12" Disston Backsaw

Dominic in Buck's County PA

Hi Gang,

I found this backsaw at a flea market for the princely sum of $3. It looked like it was in nice shape under all that rust. The plate looked nice and straight. And for $3, I guess I couldn't go wrong. Worse case scenario I get a saw to practice my sharpening skills on.

Disston Tenon Saw - Before

Disston Tenon Saw - Before

So I got it home and took it apart.

Disston Tenon Saw - Before

The saw plate was cleaned using wet dry sandpaper and then it was buffed until I could almost see my reflection. The next step was sharpening the saw. However, I got a little over zealous with my file and took the teeth down too much!

No worries! I have a Foley Retoother and it just so happens it was sitting on the bench ready to go. So I dropped in a 12TPI ratchet bar and a minute later had nicely spaced teeth in this saw plate. BTW, I really love using that tool! It scores HIGH on the gizmocity scale!

Disston Tenon Saw - After

Then I dropped the saw into my shop built vise and sharpened and set it.

Disston Tenon Saw - After

After giving it a coat of wax to prevent rusting, I set the saw plate aside. I then concentrated on the handle. The beech handle that came with the saw was a bit blocky. I decided that it needed some attention. So I stripped the finish and then softened the corners with a rasp, scrapers, and sandpaper.

Over the next couple nights I applied a coat of shellac sealer followed by several coats of blond shellac. Before adding the next coat, each previous coat was sanded with 300 grit sandpaper. Tonight I buffed the last coat out with 0000 steel wool and wax.

I also took some time and cleaned up the existing saw nuts and medallion using a wire wheel brush and some 600 grit sand paper. After all this was completed, the saw was re-assembled. Now for the reveal:

Disston Tenon Saw - After

Disston Tenon Saw - After

Then I took it for a test drive on some red oak at my bench hook.

Disston Tenon Saw - After

After that I tried cutting a sample tenon and that worked even better!

As far as finding an age for this saw, I used the medallion cross reference found at the Disstonian Institute . And unless I'm totally off base here, this saw looks like it was from the 1940s.

So there you have it. From flea market fodder to viable user. Not bad eh?

See ya around,

Dominic

Re: A refurbed 12" Disston Backsaw

#2

Ellis Walentine

Awesome, Dominic

Ellis Walentine

That retoother is a real prize. Nice job of rehabbing that saw!

Thanks for posting.

Ellis

Re: A refurbed 12" Disston Backsaw

#3

that gives me hope for a

Bruce, a MN Galoot

POS that I have hidden under my bench.

Great write-up and even better result!

Re: A refurbed 12" Disston Backsaw

#4

Re: A refurbed 12" Disston Backsaw

Marv

Those 40,s saws just scream.......radius me, radius me....more radiusing! More, More!

You took one of the uglies and morphed it into something more pleasant to look at. It no longer makes my eyes bleed. Nice job!

The nice thing about those particular saws, the steel is just as good as the older saws. With proper filing and setting, that saw will cut just as good as a $250 saw.

I'm glad you didn't paint it John Deere green. :D

Marv

Re: A refurbed 12" Disston Backsaw

#5

Another fine job Dom...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

I have to agree with Marv, I'd round over the handle.

BTW, What's up with the half backs?

Re: A refurbed 12" Disston Backsaw

#6

geez...

Tony - Memphis

You're really making me feel bad Dom. I bought a $40 saw (very similar to yours) and tried my hand at sharpening and was just happy it even made some dust! THANKS A LOT! Actually, somebody must have tried to use it as a hacksaw on metal. The tips are curled over pretty good. The first sharpening didn't get rid of that, but I figured it was good practice. I'll give it another shot soon. Thanks for sharing all of your tool rehab adventures.

Tony

Re: A refurbed 12" Disston Backsaw

#7

Re: Another fine job Dom...

Dominic in Buck's County PA

Scott,

Thanks for the compliments!

And about the halfbacks,....they're on hold for a bit until I can get rid of this jinx that's hanging over my head. I ruined three handles right in a row and found that my formed spine was causing the saw plate to bend. So I had to move back to square one on that. So, just a little delay.

But I plan on jumping back on to that project relatively soon.

Re: A refurbed 12" Disston Backsaw

#8

Re: geez...

Kenneth Martin Sacramento

Before you file again use a saw set on the teeth. As you squeeze the tooth to put in the set it will also press both sides of the tooth. That should help take out some of the curl in the teeth.

Ken

Re: A refurbed 12" Disston Backsaw

#9

So Dom...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

Those dead cow handles really turned out to be dead cow! :D

Kiddin'! Hope all the best for the second round-up!

Re: A refurbed 12" Disston Backsaw

#10

Re: A refurbed 12" Disston Backsaw

Stuart Hough

Nice work, Dom! You make me jealous!

Re: A refurbed 12" Disston Backsaw

#11

Re: A refurbed 12" Disston Backsaw

Dominic in Buck's County PA

Marv,

Thanks for the compliments! When I saw that handle it hurt me as well. I thought to myself, "How the hell is that supposed to be comfortable to use all day"? But after some softening of the edges, it feels right nice in my hands.

You know, I thought about painting it John Deer Green for short time. 2.35 seconds to be exact.

HAHAHAH!!!

Re: A refurbed 12" Disston Backsaw

#12

Re: Another fine job Dom... 

Marv

Dom,

I recently made a backsaw using a steel back. I hate the idea of bending it so I milled the slot. My saw plate is .030 and I just so happened to have a slitting saw the same size. I had to make an arbor for it with collars that only exposes 1/2" of the slitting blade. It cut best when climb milling. Having a slot the same as the thickness of the plate allowed a press fit into only a 1/4" deep slot. No epoxy, no nothing. Should work the same with most any metal. You might want to have a deeper slot.

Here's my slitting saw set up.....


This shows it pressed onto the plate.


Marv

Re: A refurbed 12" Disston Backsaw

#13

"it just so happens"???

wilbur

"I have a Foley Retoother and it just so happens it was sitting on the bench ready to go."

I love how Dominic casually mentions that he has such a device hanging about his shop. That's sort of like mentioning that your 36" bandsaw happened to be tuned up and ready to go. ;)

Re: A refurbed 12" Disston Backsaw

#14

What he said. Holy Cr@p.

James Watriss

Re: A refurbed 12" Disston Backsaw

#15

Re: Another fine job Dom...

Dominic in Buck's County PA

Marv,

Thanks for the pics! what is unique about the half back saw project I'm undertaking is that I am making THREE of them. Each with a different method for making the spine. Mostly because I am a glutton for punishment and I was curious about the ins and outs of the different techniques out there.

The first was laminated, the second slit, and the third was bent (formed). The laminated spine was the most labor intensive. The formed spine was the second. The slit spine was buy far the easiest to install. If I could come up with an easy way for me to use my drill press, I'd use a variant of your method to make slit spines. I believe that there is an arbor you can buy that has a bearing it can ride against (much like the Robo Sander). I just need to look into it more.

But honestly, the real problem lay in my inability to cut the slip for the plate or let in for the handle properly! I don't know what happened! All of a sudden I couldn't do anything right. So I shelved the project in order to get my mojo back. LOL!

So far, I think it's working

Re: A refurbed 12" Disston Backsaw

#16

Re: Another fine job Dom... 

Marv

Dom,

Yeah, that slot for the saw plate in the handle can really mess things up. I have a rip saw that was originally made for cutting nails. All the major saw makers used to make them. I have close to zero set in the teeth, but still a little to prevent drag. You are sawing end grain, so it's best to use a rip saw.

I pencil two lines around the handle where the cut will be made. The pencil lines are as far apart as the blade is thick. Then with the handle in a vise, I just saw between those lines. Go from one side, like the top of the handle, then rotate the handle and saw some more and keep rotating and sawing until the cut is about a half inch deep all around, then the saw you are using will tend to stay where it belongs and be guided by the shallow cut. You always have to be mindful of keeping the saw from sawing against one side of the slot or the other. But with near zero set, there is less scrubbing going on on the sides of the kerf. I've tried doing it on my bandsaw. Didn't work. The top of the cut was accurate, but at the bottom, puke! For me, the handsaw job is the only way to go.

With my Concept saw, it doesn't require a slot for the plate. That was one of the advantages I was going for. Today I put the final finishing touch on it. I made a rubber bumper to prevent banging into the front of the handle when making a deep tenon cut for example.

Marv


Re: A refurbed 12" Disston Backsaw

#17

Re: Another fine job Dom...

Dominic in Buck's County PA

Marv,

Thanks for the info on that rip saw. What TPI do you think that is?

I'm thinking that I can snag a piece of spring steel, cut the teeth into it, file it rip, and then I'm halfway there.

Before I started screwing up handles (LOL!) I used to have a good deal of success with setting a saw on my bench and blocking a saw plate up to the proper height with some wood. Like this:


So if I could make a nice rip saw that would help me here, then I'm thinkin' I'd be in like Flint! :D

What say you?

Re: A refurbed 12" Disston Backsaw

#18

Re: Another fine job Dom...

Marv

Dom,

I've seen that set up before. Looks like a good way to go. Certainly for sawing a guide slot about a half inch in. Have you used that method for sawing the full depth of the slot? Looks like it would work for a small handle, but how about a handsaw handle?

Marv

Re: A refurbed 12" Disston Backsaw

#19

Re: Another fine job Dom...

Dominic in Buck's County PA

As you have mentioned, this method works perfect for dovetail saw handles. But as soon as you need to go deeper, you run into problems.

I think that I need to use a combination of methods to saw "deeper" handles. Maybe use the blocked up saw to define the kerf, then switch to holding the handle in a vise and carefully sawing.

Re: A refurbed 12" Disston Backsaw

#20

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Re: A refurbed 12" Disston Backsaw

Jim in River Oaks, Ont.

Wow Dom,

You do amazing referb work on hand tools, this is a perfect example, Love them

Take care,

Jim

Re: A refurbed 12" Disston Backsaw

#21

Re: A refurbed 12" Disston Backsaw

Dominic in Buck's County PA

Thanks Jim!