New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Reasonable mouth for a bullnose plane

Posts

Reasonable mouth for a bullnose plane

#1

Reasonable mouth for a bullnose plane

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I bought a Record bullnose some time back, from that auction site.

To my disappointment, with the shims removed*, the mouth is 0.040". Not quite wide enough for a cat, even a Siamese, but kinda large.

One of my round tuits is to glue a shim on the iron bed to raise the iron and thus shrink the mouth. Is 0.005" a reasonable mouth opening to shoot for, or should I aim for smaller?

I had to go back to sine/cosine/tangent calculations to figure out a shim thickness, and was reminded that this was about where I began to glaze over in math. One of my math teachers told me I was very good, but it wasn't terribly interesting to me; now I appreciate it more.

*For those not familiar with the Record approach, the No. 77 bullnose (I think that's the right model number) has a removable nosepiece with two shims to set mouth opening.

Re: Reasonable mouth for a bullnose plane

#2

depends...

David Miller from Iowa

...upon what you intend to do with it. The only bullnosing I seem to do of late is tenons and tenon cheeks in medium hardness wood, and 4/100ths would be fine for me in that use. If you are using mostly hardwood, I would bring that in a little, but 5/1000ths seems terribly tight for a general purpose bullnose - you could only use it for final micro trimming. Perhaps my joints aren't as tight as yours.

I don't generally find myself surfacing exotic hardwood against the grain, an activity where one really needs the tight mouth. And for every time I wish the mouth on my plane was tighter, I have 10 times when I'm cursing because the mouth is too tight and stuck full of shavings.

Remember I'm the guy that thinks the plane flatness issue is overated, and I sometimes feel that way about the narrow throat issue. I am also the guy that thinks that stock quality and edge sharpness trump all the other discussions about plane minutiae.

Re: Reasonable mouth for a bullnose plane

#3

Re: Reasonable mouth for a bullnose plane

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Bill

A couple of points.

Firstly, if you want to close up the mouth of the #77, it strikes me that you may obtain better results (than using a shim) if you lap the front of the body (not the toe). The trick here is to remove metal evenly - using machinist blue, perhaps a fence/support to ensure it remains in the vertical, and a lapping surface.

If you go down the shim-on-the-bed route, then you may get some ideas from this Slater Bullnose restoration I did: http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ToolRestorations/SlaterBullnoseRestoration.html

Before:


After:


The second issue is whether you actually need all this effort going into this plane. What do you plan to use the plane to do? It is not suited (at all!) for tenons. It is used for bullnose rebate work, which does not require fine shavings, or detail work, which does. However, I must say that I find a bullnose plane of this width one that gets used once in a blue moon. Generally I am happy using a chisel in its place. On the other hand, the narrow versions from Veritas make useful planes to sneak into dados and grooves. The #77 is too wide for that.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Reasonable mouth for a bullnose plane

#4

ma-new-sha-ee

Marv

David,

Good word....minutiae....just wish it was spelled properly. :D

I'm with you....if I want a thinner shaving, I adjust the iron back. If I want a deeper faster cut, I adjust it downward. I don't care what the shaving looks like when it curls up and out as long as it comes up and out.

Marv

Re: Reasonable mouth for a bullnose plane

#5

Bill, my Record 077...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

does not have the shims. You have a a 077A (adjustable) one.

I've never had a problem with mine. It mouth with the blade retracted is .070 inches.