New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Stanley 140 - questions

Posts

Stanley 140 - questions

#1

Stanley 140 - questions

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Yes, OK, this is also a gloat. This and three other tools for $10. I never expected to see a 140 in the wild, and certainly not for that price. It was almost embarrassing, but the guy said he'd done his internet research and priced tools from the research ($25 for a Stanley 75, for instance).

I suspect this "lever" cap tightening screw is not original, and that the originals used the same kind of blunt-ended screw that you can find on dozens of other Stanley block planes - yes? Seems to work fine, and the huge square nut isn't visible when it's in place; I can live with non-collectible status.



I'd never seen anything quite like the iron adjustment. It's similar in concept to the adjuster on the 60(+1/2), but those fine serrations are definitely different, and must have been a machining challenge. Does anyone know whether these fine serrations were a solution to some problem - increased back pressure from the cutting edge or some such - or just another mad scheme by some Stanley engineer?



Side comment: this Spring and early summer's garage sales were terrible; lately's been some of the best I've seen for years. I wonder what causes these apparent trends? Sun spots, maybe?

Re: Stanley 140 - questions

#2

Re: Stanley 140 - questions

David Miller from Iowa

You asked 2 questions �

1 � the lever cap circular tightening screw looks original to me. It is the same one used in other Stanley plane models and there were minor changes over time, but there is no reason to believe it is not factory issue.

2 � can�t answer your serrations rationale question, other than to say that high level machining for professional grade products was not such a big deal back in the day.

Re: Stanley 140 - questions

#3

Re: Stanley 140 - questions

Andy Lincoln,in Dearborn MI

Bill,

I think you may be closer to original than you think.

I just took some photos of my 140 and they are pretty close to what yours show.

Of course ,mine does not include the original side plate or screws like yours.That is

a real sneaky stealth gloat to be sure and make them visible in your pics.

Also I am not sure how many parts are original on mine???

I suppose you are waiting for the dust to clear to show the other two tools you got in the lot for $10.

probably a Stanley #1 and a 605 1/4???



Re: Stanley 140 - questions

#4

Re: Stanley 140 - questions

barryavbeach

Bill, I just picked up the Miller falls version, the lever cap adjuster is similar, but not the same, but the depth adjuster looks exactly the same. I considered making a thicker blade for mine, but the machining for the adjuster slots looked like too much trouble. I thought the plane worked surprisingly well despite the engineering flaws. look at the LV and you can see a much better design ( IMHO ) in that there are solid cheeks on both sides of the plane, and the blade is notched instead of a removeable side.

Re: Stanley 140 - questions

#5

Other tools not so impressive *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Marples mortise gauge. The good news is the points are pristine. The bad is that the wood beam swelled or warped or something and the brass slide is really reluctant to move. I did a little work, and it's slightly better, but still needs work.

Nearly complete set of gimlets from Germany (Famco), missing just the smallest size. Lee Valley lists essentially the same set for $14; so not quite so dramatic a deal.

What I think of as the Stanley 702 sawhorse vise (see linky below). I have the cast iron version of this, and it's never worked very well. Not sure I needed this one, either - the Workmutts can do what this does and provide more working space - but, like Everest, it was there.

I guess I could see these as free tools with a $10 No. 140.


Like this

Re: Stanley 140 - questions

#6

Sun Spot Effect on Old Tool Sales

Al Kapocius

Know what you mean. Could only find a Stanley #5 apparently defective 'cuz it was marked #5 1/2. Cost me $10. Also a pair of Stanley #271 clamps or something or other that someone added a mini back scratcher to one. Another $10 for curiosity value.

Al Kapocius

Re: Stanley 140 - questions

#7

Re: Stanley 140 - questions

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Bill

It looks original to me. I did post an article on tuning up the #140 here, and then on my website, several years ago.

The link to my website: http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ToolRestorations/Tuning%20a%20Stanley%20140%20Skew%20Block%20Plane.html

There are a couple of pictures for you to compare.

Further, it is possible to upgrade the blade. LN made a "Stanley Replacement" for the #140, which is thicker. I achieved good results with the original Stanley blade, and later did replace it with the LN (because I had purchased it pre tune-up). The combination works very well.

Later I acquired an interesting LN #140: http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ToolRestorations/LNSkewRabbetBlockPlaneRestoration.html

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Stanley 140 - questions

#8

Thanks

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I remembered your piece on restoring a 140 after I posted my questions.

In looking at your article/gloat on your early LN 140, I'm struck by how thick the left side (the non-removable side) is - this appears to have been LN's solution to the structural weakness of this plane design.

I just compared the left side on my new-to-me Stanley 140, and it seems no thicker than the side on any of the regular Stanley block planes. They beefed up the cross-piece in front of the mouth, but the "hinge" point in the design, the left side at the mouth, has no extra reinforcement. It's a wonder to me that any of them survived at all.

This is especially surprising when I consider that the No. 140 was issued a good decade after the No. 78, another open-sided plane. Patrick Leach shows both an early and a later (1920s) example of the 78 on his "Blood and Gore" website, and it's clear that Stanley learned, probably from field testing (also known as customer complaints), that they needed to reinforce the side - there are distinct "struts" on the later design. I don't know how soon after the first issuance they upgraded the design (if I ever get bored, I suppose I could start a type study of 78s), but a decade would seem enough time to have identified the problem.

At any rate, my examination of this plane tells me that I should probably limit use of this plane to its best uses, like cleaning up tenon cheeks, and continue pulling out the 78 for garden variety rabbetish work.

Re: Stanley 140 - questions

#9

Re: Sun Spot Effect on Old Tool Sales *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

You can still get the mini back scratcher for the 271 from Stanley. Quality seems decent.


http://www.stanleytoolparts.com/roplcu.html

Re: Stanley 140 - questions

#10

Nice score Bill!

John in NM

I had to pay way more than that for my 140! Good find.

Only thing I don't like about this style of block plane is that the lever cap will loosen up on me when using it one handed, but that's a very minor beef with a useful little plane.

Re: Stanley 140 - questions

#11

Now that I drag mine out....

John in NM

There's no separate screw at all on the levercap wheel. Mine has a smooth nub on one side to bear against the blade, and a threaded shaft on the other side to thread into the cap, all part of the wheel casting. I'm going to guess that these are either Stanley did them both ways or that the screw and nut is a repair job.

Re: Stanley 140 - questions

#12

It did look like a repair to me

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

but one I can live with.

Re: Stanley 140 - questions

#13

Yep, nothing wrong with that....

John in NM

Main thing is to have it function

Re: Stanley 140 - questions

#14

Those subtle Stanley engineers

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

On continued examination, the left side of the 140, which is roughly the same thickness as a regular block plane at the top (about 1/8"), thickens to 3/16" at the sole, while regular block planes are of more or less constant thickness from top to bottom of the side.

It strikes me that Stanley was putting an LOT of trust in 1/16" of cast iron, but it appears they were at least aware of the stress on that part of the tool.

Re: Stanley 140 - questions

#16

scott grandstaff

blade serrations

scott grandstaff

The blade adjuster serrations were forged in.

Its the same scheme as the underrated #103 pocket block serrations.

If making your own homemade blade, you can use a Dremel and a paper thin cutoff wheel.

Close enough.

yours Scott

Re: Stanley 140 - questions

#17

Interesting, and wandering off topic

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

From what I've read in Patrick Leach's Blood and Gore, Stanley used the same adjusting mechanism on the early No. 140s as the No. 103 uses, the odd little lever. I guess, when they went to a screw adjustment (Professor Leach says they did so because it held the adjustment better against the pressure from the iron), they decided against changing the blade manufacture.

There are quite a few under-respected planes in the Stanley pantheon. Myself, I'm quite fond of my No. 203, which Professor Leach describes as "...designed primarily for manual training use." It's a nice, high-angle (23 degrees) version of the small planes that both LV and LN sell, and cost me a lot less - a gift from a friend when I helped him move out of his house. Great for trimming and work on small items.

Re: Stanley 140 - questions

#18

Forging...

John in NM

That occurred to me too, but I didn't have time and a magnifier to look closely. I thought perhaps the main indent area was forged in but the serations could have been cut. Hard to imagine forging those little lines cleanly, but then I've never had an oxygen free setup to use.