New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Does FWW feel Popular WW breathing down its neck?

Posts

Does FWW feel Popular WW breathing down its neck?

#1

Does FWW feel Popular WW breathing down its neck?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I got the latest issue of Foine Workwooding today. They're introducing a new feature, "Handworks," about hand woodworking tools.

And they're featuring an adaptation of a Limbert Arts and Crafts table.

Hmmm...where have I seen those kinds of things before?

Competition is great, and it will be nice if FWW pulls up its socks and starts offering good articles again. I just hope they don't think they can do it by imitating the Popular Woodworking initiatives - better they come up with their own.

Re: Does FWW feel Popular WW breathing down its neck?

#2

Re: Does FWW feel Popular WW breathing down its ne

ThomD

Their problem is there isn't an article you can think of they didn't do first, but what are they now. PW has grabed attention by limiting their scope to certain areas. FWWs tragedy is they did it all first, and for the most part best, but in a highly fragmented universe what do they do that doesn't make them into reader's digest or something.

Re: Does FWW feel Popular WW breathing down its neck?

#3

One can only hope...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

But since the demise of Woodwork anything worth upholding has gone straight down the, well you know :\

Re: Does FWW feel Popular WW breathing down its neck?

#4

Re: Does FWW feel Popular WW breathing down its ne

Adam Cherubini

Respectfully, FWW never did articles anything like mine. I and the folks at PWW work very hard to create articles that are fresh and new and different.

I like FWW and always have. I think some of the criticism has been unfair and undeserved. There's so much to do with wood, so many ways of looking at the same basic operations and projects, I think it would be a shame if FWW tried to chase PWW's success.

Altho guys quibble, I've always appreciated FWW's science project articles- when they review chisels, glue strength, joint strength, etc etc. I think folks unfairly seek content that validates their pre-existing notions. Better are the articles that are challanging and thought provoking.

That said, I agree that FWW has been slow to look into period woodworking in greater depth. Internal rules prevented me from contributing so I suggested a replacement and spoke to an editor, suggested suitable articles, and volunteered to edit, provide photographs etc etc. That didn't happen so PWW absorbed that author. FWW's loss in my opinion, but I'd try again. I'd like to see more period woodworking in FWW.

To answer the question, I've had this conversation with FWW's EIC. They don't feel PWW breathing down their neck. They play their game and PWW plays a different one. My feeling is this is beneficial for the readers. Magazine subscriptions are a super cheap source of info and inspiration. I think you should subscribe to everything that seems remotely interesting to you.

I don't believe "hand tool content" is a business model one can execute in a board room. Like the success of Steve Jobs (Apple) or Oprah Winfrey, the success of hand tools as a movement in the craft has been brought about by a "cult of personality". If FWW wanted to make hand tools work, a reasonable first step would be hire Chris Schwarz. Chris has really done things, just because of the sort of person he is, charismatic, gregarious, generous, that a company can't simply copy.

Also not to be overlooked is Ellis Wallentine, our host here, who has facillitated, certainly my entre into writing, but a great deal of the hand tool industry. Worthwhile to refect on these individuals as likely thousands gather in Northern Kentucky to listen to presenters largely discuss hand tools and a full room of hand tool manufacturers offer their wide range of products.

Adam

Re: Does FWW feel Popular WW breathing down its neck?

#5

Moses Yoder

Re: FWW Changes

Moses Yoder

I have a lot of old FWW magazines and it is easy to see that the newer publication's articles simply do not go into the depth of the old ones. It seems obvious to me that this is due to cutting costs to try to stay competitive. I think FWW should look at a copy of Gray's Sporting Journal and take some lessons from it. A lot of people are willing to spend the money for a premium publication.

Re: Does FWW feel Popular WW breathing down its neck?

#6

Re: Does FWW feel Popular WW breathing down its ne

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

I really like PopWW, just as I really liked the FWW of the early '80's, although they are/were very different rags. If FWW today were more like FWW 1980, I'd certainly subscribe.

However, while PopWW has encouraged the use of hand tools (especially with your great column), I think the catalyst was the reporting of the cancer hidden in sawdust. It's peculiar that FWW doesn't seem to have caught on yet.

Pam

Re: Does FWW feel Popular WW breathing down its neck?

#7

Re: Does FWW feel Popular WW breathing down its ne

ThomD

"Respectfully, FWW never did articles anything like mine. I and the folks at PWW work very hard to create articles that are fresh and new and different."

Well the original post was hand tools and Arts and Crafts. Hand tools goes without saying where their coverage in the early days has still mostly to be surpased, and as far as arts and crafts is concerned they have covered it for years, before it was popular, since it became popular, and with cover stories, projects, you name it. There isn't any individual exactly like you Adam so at that level you are obviously right.

"FWW tried to chase PWW's success."

1rst I suppose there is the question as to who is more successful than whom. I gues it is supposed to be easy to check that kind of thing as a potential advertiser, but I don't know how to do it, other than to examine product placements and ad pages.

"Altho guys quibble, I've always appreciated FWW's science project articles- when they review chisels, glue strength, joint strength, etc etc. I think folks unfairly seek content that validates their pre-existing notions. Better are the articles that are challanging and thought provoking."

There is always going to be a subjective element to these tests, but FWW misses the mark so regularly and by orders of magnitude, that it all got sorta sickening for me. Also, I think there is a bit of the inherant eror there for FWW to struggle with, since they invented and first colonized the whole market, they continue to want to make broad statements about it. Wouldn't it seem irrelevant if they did a test comparing green joinery, to bicuits to dovetails as though people regularly incorporated all these product in one project (ok I might have but that's my dirty secret). It is apples and oranges. But that is where you are when you do a broad spectrum chisel test (and it doesn't help to blow the science by orders of magnitue). There isn't a FWW Norb Mullaney, if you want that kind of franchise.

"That said, I agree that FWW has been slow to look into period woodworking in greater depth."

It depends what you mean though doesn't it? Klausz, Alexander, Hedley and Lowe all happen to know what they are actually talking about, which is one kind of depth. K. is actually in uninterupted descent. There are many other examples. But they did books articles and videos with that crowd.

"charismatic, gregarious, generous, that a company can't simply copy."

The question is whether they moved puposely away from that model. One could run down a real list of people with first order skills, and charisrma that FWW had a fair role in bringing into the public light through mags and videos, only to have them "go down the elevator at night" and not come back. Maybe like a lot of companies they realized they should actually focus their eforts on their brand rather than building brands they don't control. They sure aren't making a magazine I enjoy any more, but are or are they not successful?

All that said, people tend to cycle through activities like this relatively fast. While there are long patterns that may seem relevant to me, the majority of people probably are much shorter term and their primary influence can come from many different places these days.

Re: Does FWW feel Popular WW breathing down its neck?

#8

Re: Does FWW feel Popular WW breathing down its ne

ThomD

"I think the catalyst was the reporting of the cancer hidden in sawdust. It's peculiar that FWW doesn't seem to have caught on yet."

And I first read about that in FWW. If the implication is that dust should cause one to become a hand tool woodworker, I don't really agree with that, for three reasons: Not all power tools are dusty; Dust is 100 percent a manageable problem; Not all hand tools are low dust. That said I do use hand tools as part of my dust strategy, since I am really bad at certain other things I would need to be good at to implement some of the above points. I may not be favored as far as tidyness is concerned, but at least God made me to clutter up the surface of the tablesaw, when I had one, thereby savng me from cancer. Unfortunately I also clutter up the surface of the workbench, which has led me to high blood pressure.

Re: Does FWW feel Popular WW breathing down its neck?

#9

Re: One word...

ThomD

Ok, sometimes I go on far too long, I am working on concision, so here it is:

Roubo Bench.

Re: Does FWW feel Popular WW breathing down its neck?

#10

Jim in Burlington Ont.

It's No Contest

Jim in River Oaks, Ont.

Pop Wood flew past FWW in quality and content YEARS ago... I like the fact that the editors and writers at Pop Wood are visible and we can follow them on line if we like. Pop Wood has been number 1 in my books since Chris was promoted.

Take care,

Jim

Re: Does FWW feel Popular WW breathing down its neck?

#11

Re: It's No Contest

Andy Lincoln,in Dearborn MI

Jim,

Nice to see you back posting on the boards.I had not seen you post in awhile and have missed your wisdom.

Hope all is well.

Andy

Re: Does FWW feel Popular WW breathing down its neck?

#12

That was two words..... 

Marv

Re: Does FWW feel Popular WW breathing down its neck?

#13

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Thank You Andy

Jim in River Oaks, Ont.

Thank You Andy,

I appreciate your kind words, I took some "me time" and feel it was well worth it to balance my life priorities.

:-)

Take care,

Jim

Re: Does FWW feel Popular WW breathing down its neck?

#14

Re: That was two words.....

ThomD

Like I said I try to always leave them wanting less...

Re: Does FWW feel Popular WW breathing down its neck?

#15

Re: Does FWW feel Popular WW breathing down its ne

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Well, we disagree. The dust coming from most any power tool is much finer than that from hand tools; so a fine mist of dust develops in a power tool shop while the dust from a hand tool falls to the floor quickly. Dust collection system or not.

Maybe FWW reported this first. If so, they're doubly at fault since they continue to not discuss hand tools with any seriousness or volume. In fact, they probably use the cancer report to sell more DC systems, which don't work, can't work, and are a lot of bother.

Pam

Re: Does FWW feel Popular WW breathing down its neck?

#16

Re: Does FWW feel Popular WW breathing down its ne

Steve Kirincich

I just returned from Woodworking in America, and although I can't comment on magazine subscription numbers, it is safe to say that PWW has developed a loyal following based on magazine content and very active blogging. I only use the FWW site to access old articles. For me, WIA was a unique opportunity to interact with many of the leading handtool makers. Incredible tools with great knowledge and experience to stand behind these products.

Steve

Re: Does FWW feel Popular WW breathing down its neck?

#17

Barb Siddiqui

Re: It's No Contest

Barb Siddiqui

Hi Jim. Nice to see you back. I agree, PopWood "flew past them years ago." And it has been 'a cult of personality,' but due to the team they've built, I think, not due to any one person. Their team has really melded together to produce the best of any subject. Can't be beat.