Re: Does FWW feel Popular WW breathing down its ne
ThomD
"Respectfully, FWW never did articles anything like mine. I and the folks at PWW work very hard to create articles that are fresh and new and different."
Well the original post was hand tools and Arts and Crafts. Hand tools goes without saying where their coverage in the early days has still mostly to be surpased, and as far as arts and crafts is concerned they have covered it for years, before it was popular, since it became popular, and with cover stories, projects, you name it. There isn't any individual exactly like you Adam so at that level you are obviously right.
"FWW tried to chase PWW's success."
1rst I suppose there is the question as to who is more successful than whom. I gues it is supposed to be easy to check that kind of thing as a potential advertiser, but I don't know how to do it, other than to examine product placements and ad pages.
"Altho guys quibble, I've always appreciated FWW's science project articles- when they review chisels, glue strength, joint strength, etc etc. I think folks unfairly seek content that validates their pre-existing notions. Better are the articles that are challanging and thought provoking."
There is always going to be a subjective element to these tests, but FWW misses the mark so regularly and by orders of magnitude, that it all got sorta sickening for me. Also, I think there is a bit of the inherant eror there for FWW to struggle with, since they invented and first colonized the whole market, they continue to want to make broad statements about it. Wouldn't it seem irrelevant if they did a test comparing green joinery, to bicuits to dovetails as though people regularly incorporated all these product in one project (ok I might have but that's my dirty secret). It is apples and oranges. But that is where you are when you do a broad spectrum chisel test (and it doesn't help to blow the science by orders of magnitue). There isn't a FWW Norb Mullaney, if you want that kind of franchise.
"That said, I agree that FWW has been slow to look into period woodworking in greater depth."
It depends what you mean though doesn't it? Klausz, Alexander, Hedley and Lowe all happen to know what they are actually talking about, which is one kind of depth. K. is actually in uninterupted descent. There are many other examples. But they did books articles and videos with that crowd.
"charismatic, gregarious, generous, that a company can't simply copy."
The question is whether they moved puposely away from that model. One could run down a real list of people with first order skills, and charisrma that FWW had a fair role in bringing into the public light through mags and videos, only to have them "go down the elevator at night" and not come back. Maybe like a lot of companies they realized they should actually focus their eforts on their brand rather than building brands they don't control. They sure aren't making a magazine I enjoy any more, but are or are they not successful?
All that said, people tend to cycle through activities like this relatively fast. While there are long patterns that may seem relevant to me, the majority of people probably are much shorter term and their primary influence can come from many different places these days.