New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Wooden Plow Plane Question

Posts

Wooden Plow Plane Question

#1

Wooden Plow Plane Question

Steve Kirincich

At the spring 2009 LFOD auction and tailgate sale, I purchased a 19th century plow plane with a matched set of irons. Everything seems to be in working order, but I am wondering about the alignment between the front and rear skates. If I were to set the plane (without iron) down on a flat surface, should the two skates sit on the surface with few if any gaps between the skates and the flat surface? The bottom edges of the skates are not parallel and at the start of a pass down the board, the results vary depending if I start with weight mostly on the front end, the rear skate or teetering somewhere in between. I am inclined to remedy this situation with a file since I am concerned that loosening the screws which anchor the skates to the body may not retighten well.

Thanks.

Steve

Re: Wooden Plow Plane Question

#2

Re: Wooden Plow Plane Question

John Aniano in central NJ...

Steve,

Yes, the skate bottoms need to be parallel and at least sort of in line from side to side. If the skates can be removed (they have screws holding them) you can often put thin tapered wooden shims under the skate seat area - usually a groove, to get the two parallel. If they are riveted or cannot be removed, a file can be used to get them flat to a glass plate. Don't go overboard - flat to a straight edge is quite good enough IMO. Plough planes are sort of a roughing tool and take a thick shaving anyway...

Just my $0.02 worth...

John

Re: Wooden Plow Plane Question

#3

craigd

Re: Wooden Plow Plane Question

craigd

Both skates should sit flat. But that is unlikely - the groove in the back of the iron beds on the rear skate and if the skate is a wee bit forward, wedging the iron pushes the skate down and back. At a minimum, if there is clearance in the screw hole, the skate just moves down. No clearance, the screw moves and the screw hole gets bigger or the wood cracks. End result, the skate is humped at the iron. I don't think this is fixable and is a design flaw. I also doubt that it is a problem, plows are not precision planes. I've filed a couple of them, not sure it makes a difference as a long depth stop will counter act the problem.

You can see this by looking at the skate mortise and noticing no gap at the back and a gap at the iron.

All three of my wooden ploughes have some variant of this problem (my Matheson

has about a 1/16" hump).

Re: Wooden Plow Plane Question

#4

Re: Wooden Plow Plane Question

Gary Roberts

Steve

A plow in tip top condition should run smoothly, without bumps, catches or glitches. When rehabbing a plow, I've removed the skates and leveled the surfaces with an extra fine double cut file until everything is planar. The skate 'runners' need to be smooth and inline. You can relieve the following skate a tad just behind the blade to prevent catching the wood, but only a touch is needed.

years of humidity and temp changes alters the geometry of the plow, so you have to bring it back to working order.

BTW, my favorite files for adjusting trim are extra fine, fine and medium double cut. These particular ones don't have teeth along the outside edges. I'm sure there is a name for this type, but I have no idea. I bought them years ago in Waltham at a hardware store now long out of business.

Re: Wooden Plow Plane Question

#5

Re: Wooden Plow Plane Question

Steve Kirincich

Gary,

Should I be concerned about backing out screws from boxwood and then getting them back in firmly after adjusting the skate beds? My questionable instincts are telling me to just take file to skates.

Steve

Re: Wooden Plow Plane Question

#6

craigd

Re: Wooden Plow Plane Question

craigd

The edge of a file with no teeth is called a "safe" edge. Not sure if there is a special name for a file with a safe edge though. My favorite ones are the ones Karl Holtey grinds on his surface grinder.

I've taken the skates off of my beech planes many times with no issues. I only have boxwood for the arms and nuts, a boxwood body would be very pretty.

Re: Wooden Plow Plane Question

#7

An alternative opinion.

Bob Hackett

First,have you tried it on a project?

If it ain`t broke don`t fix it.

My experience is that the skate is just a point of index for the cutter and the most important point is than thin edge that serves as a sole does on a bench plane.

Depending on what width cutter you have installed at the time the sides of the skate become rather meaningless as they don`t contact anything at all,they are there just to support that edge.

As long as no part of the side of the skate projects past the side of your thinnest cutter while the plane is working you are golden.It makes no difference how pitted,bent,out of line,etc that skate is as long as the skate is holding the cutting edge in the proper relation to cut the wood and the bottom edge of the skate keeps the plane properly oriented on the work the sides of the skate just need to fit within the groove you are cutting and platinum plating them will have no effect other than to please your eye.

I check my skates by attempting to plow a groove with my smallest cutter.If the plane cuts and the skate fits in that groove and doesn`t rub I leave it alone!

If it doesn`t fit cause it`s bent I support it between two pieces of wood in my vise and hit it with a mallet till it does fit,done deal.

The rest is just eye candy on a rough plane like this.

Re: Wooden Plow Plane Question

#8

Re: An alternative opinion.

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I was thinking along the same line. I give Steve a lot of credit for getting the plane going and seeing how it works before too much alteration. I think I would try to link any refinement to performance issues. And I would go easy on the alterations and try to discern if the work done is solving specific problems. The front skate regulates the depth of cut, the back holds the cutter and the two keep the plane flat on the stock. I guess theoretically the two skate bottoms could offset by the thickness of a shaving, which is typically rather thick for any plough.

Re: Wooden Plow Plane Question

#9

Re: Wooden Plow Plane Question

Larry Williams

If your results vary, you need to fix the plane. There are easy fixes for screws not holding but, if the plane is early, you need to make sure the screws go back in the same hole they came from. I'd do that even if it's not an old plow.

Is the skate plated? That's where a brass piece is attached to the upper out-side of the skate. If it's not plated, your repair may be temporary and you'll need to make sure the irons register properly on the skate and the wedge doesn't apply too much pressure to the bottom of the skate.

You may not have to remove the skates, just sand paper glued to a flat surface should fix the problem you described. Make sure the sides of the skate are in the same plane as well.

Re: Wooden Plow Plane Question

#10

Re: Wooden Plow Plane Question

Steve Kirincich

Thanks for all the suggestions! I was able to remove the skate and the attached brass piece, gently clean up the mating surfaces, and replace the parts. There is just enough play to improve the alignment of the bottom edges of the skates. The side-to-side alignment was never an issue. These adjustments coupled with careful iron adjustment made for a very nice planing experience.

Steve

Re: Wooden Plow Plane Question

#11

Re: Wooden Plow Plane Question

Gary Roberts

Steve

The screws should back out just fine. Perhaps a touch of wax when you return them if they're binding.