New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

plane sole rehab

Posts

plane sole rehab

#1

plane sole rehab

Gerald Gibbs

I am attempting my first plane rehab on an old Bailey #4. The sole has some scratches that I have no intention of sanding out. I know the sole has to be flat at the toe, throat and heel, but do those areas have to be nice and shiny? Am I wasting my time if there will be visible scratches left? If so, I'll still use the plane, just stop sanding on the bottom. Jerry

Re: plane sole rehab

#2

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: plane sole rehab

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Yeah, you're wasting your time. As long as the scratches don't have any sharp edges or burrs, they cause no problem.

Flatness is often over-rated. ;-) As long as the sole is flat adjacent to, and behind the mouth, it's pretty much good enough. Shiny counts for very little. In actual use, you'll not feel muc - if any - difference between a sole finished to 220 grit and one finishe to 100 grit. Actually, if you use wax or parrafin on the sole (like I do) the 220 grit's minor scratch pattern will hole the wax better than a more polished one.

Re: plane sole rehab

#3

Think of them as field-applied corrugations

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

As long as there aren't burrs or super-sharp edges that could scratch the wood, you shouldn't have a problem. I've got some planes with soles that appear to have been used to plane lava fields, and they work fine.

It's kind of funny: people spend extra on corrugated-sole planes, even while other folks are spending hours getting the soles of their planes smooth as baby's tushies.

Remember, incidentally, that wax is your friend when it comes to plane soles. Once you're done getting it as straight and smooth as you want it, a coat of furniture wax on the sole will cause it to glide smoothly across the wood.

Re: plane sole rehab

#4

Question about wax...

Ron Bauman

I've never used wax on the sole of any of my planes, I was scared off at an early age by fear that the finishes I use would "fish eye" with any foreign elements on the wood. Does any of the wax come off?

Re: plane sole rehab

#5

Moses Yoder

Re: Question about wax...

Moses Yoder

I use Johnson's Paste wax and have never had any problems with the finish because of the wax. I use Johnson's wax on all my unmentionable cast iron surfaces.

Re: plane sole rehab

#6

Re: Question about wax...

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I remember reading an article in which the author asserted that wax sticks very well to other surfaces but not well to itself. If you use furniture paste wax*, and buff it out well, you'll have a very thin layer of wax sticking to the sole of the plane. The rate at which it wears off - which I estimate by how INfrequently I have to reapply it - seems to be such that only traces of it are left on the wood, apparently much less than is needed to generate problems with the finish.

But do buff it out well and thoroughly.

Paraffin wax, I'm not so sure about - it's harder, and doesn't "spread" as easily. Kind of like the difference between butter that's sat on the table for a while and butter fresh from the refrigerator. For that reason, I don't use paraffin wax; but I know a lot of folks swear by it.

*This is one of my broken-record warnings: don't use automotive wax, which contains microabrasives designed to cut through the oxidation on the car's paint. A can of furniture paste wax from your local hardware store or big boxy store will last you years in this application, AND you can use it for furniture too.

Re: plane sole rehab

#7

Re: Question about wax...

Ron in Sterling, CT

Wax on the sole of a plane makes a HUGE difference in the effort one has to use when using a plane. I have used plain old parafin wax for years and have never had a problem with finishes.

Ron

Re: plane sole rehab

#8

craigd

Re: Question about wax...

craigd

What Ron said, I use a candle like a crayon and scribble a line or two front to back and the plane goes like greased lightening. Unless you are talking about a wooden plane, don't need wax there.

Re: plane sole rehab

#9

Probably myth but . . .

steve mackay

I use Johnson's also. Learned it RIGHT HERE. Probably from Mr. Yoder. BUT after I mentioned it to my Dad (tool & Die) he surmised that what we were actually doing was filling the pores in the metal. If we buff the wax REALLY WELL the amount on the surface is going to be very little but we keep the protection in the pores where moisture can get in and do it's thing, piting. But then, we're probably over-thinking the whole thing.

I'm sure a nuclear physicist could give us a beter explanation from an atomic point of view. I'll just stick with the folklore.

Re: plane sole rehab

#10

Me too...

Tony - Memphis

I was given a chunk at a class many years ago (Phil Lowe). I think what he gave me was purchased as canning wax? Seems like I have seen it at the grocery store? Yup, it makes a huge difference in planing effort. I use it on all my planes just as described above. I've never had any issue with it either. I put paste wax on all my planes but I use the parafin wax while planing.

Tony