New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Source for compass plane?

Posts

Source for compass plane?

#1

JL

Source for compass plane?

JL

The men of our church help out the older women of our parish. One guy, Mike, has been helping a number of these women. They asked me to find out what he wanted/needed - they were going to get him it as a present for Xmas. Anyway, he was over to my house the other day raiding my stash of 4/4 poplar. He said he missed his compass plane more than any of the tools he lost a few years ago.

I've seen some of the compass planes on Ebay. The prices are all over the map.

I'm looking for advice on which would be a good compass plane (Stanley 113 or whatever) and what would be a reasonable price to pay. I'm also looking for a good reputable source.

Somehow I don't think the women have that high of a budget, but we'll see.

TIA

Re: Source for compass plane?

#2

Re: Source for compass plane? *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I have felt that the Stanley 20 or Record 020 (link to one current eBay auction for an example) was a superior design to the more complex compass planes, which seemed too gizmotic to be durable. The engineers did some clever things like cut the threads with flat tops, so that they don't scar easily when you tighten the clamping screw against them.

Also, the No. 20 seems to have a very natural grip, like an old woodie coffin smoother.

I can't recall what I paid for mine, which I have yet to have a chance to use (not a lot of call for it in house remodeling!); but it wound up being one of those auctions with a good tool that no one else noticed.

Not that this is necessarily much help if you're trying to stay within a gift budget.


http://cgi.ebay.com/1940s-Stanley-CIRCULAR-Plane-No-20-w-Bedrock-Lever-Cap-/150495825830?pt=LH_DefaultDomain_0&hash=item230a400fa6

Re: Source for compass plane?

#3

Re: Source for compass plane?

Gary Hodgin

Bill's ebay suggestion is probably the least expensive route. Highland Woodworking carries two circular planes, both replicas of the Stanley 113. The Anant Circular 113 sells for $240 and the ECE Circular sells for $400. I've never used either, but do own an ECE smoother that's a good plane. Never tried an Anant.

Re: Source for compass plane?

#4

Re: Source for compass plane?

Dean Lapinel

I have a nice old stanley that I'll sell. I use my spokeshaves now and rarely grab this old workhorse. You can contact me via PM if interested.

Re: Source for compass plane?

#5

Re: Source for compass plane?

David Weaver

I have had both a 113 and a 020. I have the 020 now, and like it better than the 113 (which ) because it seems stronger. I don't use it a lot - once or twice a year, but it's a nice tool to have.

In this market, for a clean 113 that's stated to have no problems, I wouldn't want to give more than about $75, and for a clean 020 probably $100. Superb versions of either will bring a little more, rough versions less.

I bought a spotless 020 for $135 a good while ago when tools were selling better and kind of wish I would've bought a doggish looking functional one.

If you end up buying one on ebay, just make sure the auction states it's in good shape with nothing broken (or ask) in case it arrives with a broken mechanism, etc.

No disrespect meant to anyone who mentions the new compass planes, but I've never seen anyone actually buy them, and the vintage planes in good shape are probably as good or better quality. It's not a tool with which anyone will spend hours hogging away mass amounts of wood.

Re: Source for compass plane?

#6

JL

Re: Source for compass plane?

JL

Thanks for the kind offer. If my bid doesn't pan out, I may take you up on this.

Re: Source for compass plane?

#7

Good advice!

Rob Lee

Re: Source for compass plane?

#8

Re: Source for compass plane?

Gary Hodgin

None taken. I mentioned the new prices simply as a reference point, not a recommendation. If I were in the market I would try to find one for sell in a forum or on ebay. However, ebay is a crap shoot for something like this if you're not familiar with the plane (or the seller). My understanding is that the adjustments on the older compass planes are often a problem that is not easy fix.

I've tried a compass plane one time and it wasn't a pleasant experience. Maybe it was that I should have given it more time, but I'd much prefer spokeshaves for that sort of work.

Re: Source for compass plane?

#9

Moses Yoder

Re: Source for compass plane? *LINK*

Moses Yoder

I just noticed one in really good shape on ebay, link below. It must be a newer version, it's 2 tone, but the #20 is a much better plane than the #113.


Compass plane